Newbie Mini Mafia LX - Page 4

On January 11 2015 06:18 rsoultin wrote:


To be honest with you, ExO...I don't get your LS/WW progression because of your argument with Trfel

It seems like you're pushing him toward WW in that post, while staying on LS, after you already said you wouldn't move your vote from LS. Afterwards you claimed that you'd move after you were asked about the fit you threw after flip, but nothing about it beforehand.

On January 11 2015 06:20 rsoultin wrote:


That.

On January 11 2015 07:37 rsoultin wrote:


This is the first time you mention making a vote change, ExO, after I questioned your reaction to the flip. You didn't leading up to EoD. If you did, please link me to it, because I'm not seeing it.

I'm sorry, but anyone can concoct a story later.

On January 08 2015 14:33 ExO_ wrote:



I'm mad at WW for bad play. He has a blue role. but he's inactive as hell, and when he does post his reads are bad and filled with wrong information. Then he soft claims blue when he's about to die. I know I'd try to fake claim if I was a mafia and looking like the inevitable lynch, and that's what this looked like to me.

So I'm mad that an important town player couldn't take the time to play the game, potentially fucking the rest of us over. I didn't switch my vote over to him because I didn't need to. But I was around at EoD and you better believe I was watching for last second shenanigans. If I saw people moving votes at the last second, I would've jumped on to the WW train.

I still believe LS was the better vote. I still believe LS is scum now. But the case on WW was decent in my opinion.

On January 11 2015 07:50 rsoultin wrote:
It doesn't make any sense that with your vote parked on LS and trfel saying he was voting for LS, that you started arguing with him that the WW wagon had merit.

That's bugging me. It's like you wanted him to settle there even though your choice was LS.

On January 11 2015 07:48 rsoultin wrote:


So all that statement meant was that you could be wrong? Then why did you say we'd have a "much better idea" in 15 minutes? Again, it's not to be super picky about wording, but that implies you actually thought that there was some sort of significance to LS flipping town and you and Tube pushing Celestial earlier.

We'd know in 15 minutes whether LS was town or scum. We'd have a much better idea of what?

On January 11 2015 08:13 rsoultin wrote:


That's the post I'm referring to. Am I misinterpreting it?

On January 11 2015 08:18 rsoultin wrote:
-squints at-

It just read to me like you had somewhere to go, some sort of read, analysis, something, that would have followed from an LS town flip. I mean...what really did that lynch by itself say? At least looking at the votes it just says everyone piled on LS when we shouldn't have -_-.

So I was expecting some sort of follow-up that never came :/

On January 11 2015 08:23 rsoultin wrote:


Gosh this is eating at me. You said that his flipping town would be telling though ><

And yeah, of course if he flipped scum it was a massive buss. Every single player was on him o.0.

On January 11 2015 08:59 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, well...we're running out of time for the night phase, so I'm going to put my thoughts into one post.

Town reads: HTS, Tube, JarJar (less certain on my brother and almost completely certain on the other two, but he legitimately does predictions based on statistics for a living and his voting patterns have been logical and in-line with his reads)

Nullish/Do Not Lynch Day 3: -Celestial-, Scott (doc claim/breadcrumbs and AFK replacement respectively)

Would Lynch:
- ExO (90% certain) his scumhunting seems more like throwing darts at a board (at the risk of sounding hypocritical) and his read progression/interactions with Trfel at EoD Day 1 especially, including the rage!fit after the flip, seem insincere to me...a good idea would be to check if his pushes start up after thread sentiment has already begun to swing that way (I know the Celestial one did)

- Shining (70% certain) for his start that I think I've mentioned a few times now, but also this oddity of completely dropping any pressure on ExO after WW flipped for no apparent reason...even goes so far as to say that there might be scum on the LS wagon but still gives ExO a bye when the only other one there was WW, says he's taking the game seriously after Day 2 but mostly just posts defensive posts and a push on -Celestial-, then finally ends with his only post of Night 2: a WIFOM game balance argument that Celeste must be scum cause this game can't possibly have a doctor (why when we don't know the set-up at all?)

- Silver (least certain) she never stepped up. could be newb play, but all I see from her filter is sheeping and I'm not getting the feeling that she cares to find scum, especially since she dropped the people she was scumreading to sheep me Day 1 (which is sad to say cause I <3 my silver ^^)...her big posts only come after she's prodded for them, contain a lot of fluff, and the rest are mostly excuses


Final Comment: With the breadcrumbing, I think that Celestial is a likely mislynch. Please, if I am not here to provide my input, whatever you decide, be really certain before you lynch an un-CCd role.

On January 13 2015 09:10 jarjarbinks wrote:
Totally wasn't!

I think I will never say the word "number" again in this game! Although I definitely will be using them!

On January 13 2015 09:16 Damdred wrote:
Seriously though why wouldn't you guys listen to shining about how there cannot be a medic and a vet in a twelve person game. Especially when newb 12 person games generally only have 2 roles in it, crazy LS didn't talk about this. Medic+vet is way to town favored lol