SL

Geript flipped town and it didn't make sense for a mafia to late vote in that situation.
Robik and JAT made good posts about why you are town. There maybe other people I town read who made good points on you but I cant remember.
I haven't copied your reads I think I have pushed my own thoughts independently.

If you want evidence of my town. Look at what Viv Just copied.

My scum list - LM, super and ritoky

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

January 15 2015 02:31 GMT

#8802

But now bed.

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:31 GMT

#8803

On January 15 2015 11:23 KelsierSC wrote:
vivax if you read through sl he said he was going to reclaim cop the next day soni wanted to see what he said.

You will see that my reasoning is consistent. Inwas unsure of SL after geript flipped town I listened to Jay and tobik and I ended up town reading him.

So first you are unsure if he's cop, after you uncovered he wasn't.

Then during the night you see arguments from JAT and Robik that don't have anything to do with the cop claim except JAT cause JAT was already sure he was town, but not cop. Meanwhile you weren't sure he was cop.

But you say JAT convinced you while he was sure SL was town but not cop, while you weren't sure he was town OR cop.

You're so in the bag scum

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:32 GMT

#8804

On January 15 2015 11:28 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
I kind of don't want to let LM get away today though. It feels icky.

I need to evaluate a dozen times if I'm wrong on one of these guys. Let's not let this become and autolynch.

Damdred

15669 Posts

January 15 2015 02:35 GMT

#8805

Just got back from getting the wife.

I think I'm going to put SL to the side atm, we need to focus on a few things

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

January 15 2015 02:35 GMT

#8806

Hey vivax I have a good reason why Lm is town if ksc is mafia.

So when ksc does a soft counterclaim on me. You say he does this to see if im worth a nk. But why would he do this if green checked his partner? He knows im bullshitting then.

So lm could be town if ksc is mafia.

But ksc role hunts as mafia (carol) and counter claims cops he doesint believe as vt so its hard.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

January 15 2015 02:36 GMT

#8807

JAT said something like the cop claim makes no sense from a mafia perspective. SL said he was going to reclaim cop the next day and so I asked him about it.
I've explained my reasons, I dont see how this makes me scum

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:37 GMT

#8808

On January 15 2015 11:31 KelsierSC wrote:
SL

Geript flipped town and it didn't make sense for a mafia to late vote in that situation.
Robik and JAT made good posts about why you are town. There maybe other people I town read who made good points on you but I cant remember.
I haven't copied your reads I think I have pushed my own thoughts independently.

If you want evidence of my town. Look at what Viv Just copied.

My scum list - LM, super and ritoky

Scum lists don't mean shit, you can bus all you want. Super wasn't playing properly. Ritoky was about to fakeclaim cop the next day, and Lazer still didn't flip. So unless you know 100 % for sure that Lazer is going to flip scum when he gets lynched this defense of yourself is an example of TMI, and it fits perfectly into my theory that last day you and marv bussed him to grab endgame cred.

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

January 15 2015 02:37 GMT

#8809

I feel like in your world. Lm is still a likely mislynch and it could be dandred or gb.

Im not even sure im in your world tho tomorrows todays gonna suckkk

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:40 GMT

#8810

On January 15 2015 11:36 KelsierSC wrote:
JAT said something like the cop claim makes no sense from a mafia perspective. SL said he was going to reclaim cop the next day and so I asked him about it.
I've explained my reasons, I dont see how this makes me scum

JAT townread him, and said he wasn't cop.
You scumread him, and weren't sure if he was cop.

But you say JAT's argument convinced you.

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:41 GMT

#8811

JAT ignored that SL said he was going to reclaim cop.
You didn't.

But JAT convinced you.

Easily uncovered story that doesn't fit.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

January 15 2015 02:41 GMT

#8812

Well I'm confident LM is mafia. I pushed him everyday tbh except d2 when I thought geript was mafia.

You seem desperate to call me scum for things that I have explained and aren't scummy.

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:43 GMT

#8813

And what about Robik convinced you that SL could be town? The obviously trolly post from Robik? Hard to believe when you were scumreading SL for harder reasons.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

January 15 2015 02:44 GMT

#8814

JAT convinced me he wasn't mafia.

I had no fucking clue who was the cop. I asked SL if he was reclaiming cop because he said he was going to.

I mean you keep asking the same questions I'm going to give the same answers

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:44 GMT

#8815

On January 15 2015 11:41 KelsierSC wrote:
Well I'm confident LM is mafia. I pushed him everyday tbh except d2 when I thought geript was mafia.

You seem desperate to call me scum for things that I have explained and aren't scummy.

Yes but you just used the argument that LM is mafia before he even flipped to prove you're town.

TMI.

Vivax

21972 Posts

January 15 2015 02:46 GMT

#8816

I'm willing to lynch LM, and then apply the TMI argument to lynch Kelsier. And if marv isn't dead by then, he's the easy choice.

GGnore scum

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

January 15 2015 02:47 GMT

#8817

On January 15 2015 11:43 Vivax wrote:
And what about Robik convinced you that SL could be town? The obviously trolly post from Robik? Hard to believe when you were scumreading SL for harder reasons.

N2/d3 I was reevaluating the game , my main reason for scum reading sl was I thought geript was mafia and sl late voted bats to save geript. this theory made no sense after geript flipped town.
I was town reading robik and he was townreading SL I can't remember the reason but I trusted robik.
I cant filter dive right now as I'm on the phone but I remember liking the reason