|
On December 23 2014 09:43 27ninjabunnies wrote: Mafia such noob. Didn't kill me.
Tho Palmer prob did more than I.
Who we killing today? Whoever you like I guess since people will sheep you like crazy.
|
SL wants you to kill your medic nb
|
Palmar getting shot over bunnies and damdred is... interesting.
Damdred is probably town. Confirmed town Palmar said this
On December 22 2014 05:29 Palmar wrote: Now he's an blue without a cc, and we must definitely have had 3 blues against 3 mafia and 1 sk.
Maybe we should look up past games to confirm this, but unless anybody else is claiming blue, seems likely he is town.
|
On December 23 2014 10:06 Damdred wrote: SL wants you to kill your medic nb
I voted coag? You put so much unwarranted scum on me I still think you might be mafia tho.
|
On December 23 2014 05:22 sicklucker wrote: ##vote Coagulation
|
If you wanna know that im town look at my posts right after the endgame on the christmas. Its totally legal too because I misclicked after the game was over ;p
|
If you guys need more meta stuff from player who were just in the Christmas Carol Game then feel free to look into it! Also sicklucker how you feel about me this game now?
|
|
titanic vi: 14 players | 4 mafia | 4 blue FF2: 14 players | 4 mafia | 5 blue Guilty: 13 players | 3 mafia + SK | 4 blue neat & tidy: 13 players | 3 mafia | 3 blue (weak) world cup: 13 players | 3 mafia | 2 blue cultured: 13 players | 3 mafia | 3 blue back to basics: 12 players | 3 mafia | 1 blue golden sun: 15 players | 3 mafia + survivor | 4 blue (weak)
Seems like Damdred kinda has to be medic. Meh. It's just really annoying, because if we consider him to be comfired town but then this game turns out to be really scum-favored like the Back to the Basics game, we'll lose. This is why I hate semi-open setups.
Anyway, if anybody else is blue you should claim. Otherwise, I think we should just consider him town and blame the balance team if we lose because of it.
|
On December 23 2014 11:05 kushm4sta wrote: so sicklucker is scum?
idk maybe. you have a good argument why?
|
On December 23 2014 11:05 kushm4sta wrote: so sicklucker is scum? He didn't seem to act much like he did on Student IV and Christmas Carol game( Carol of the Bells Mafia) but I think him defending Breshke and Marv is kind of odd but so was their defense on me when I'm not scum but otherwise I don't got much on him.
|
Sciberbia can you give me your reads please? I would like to talk with you to try to solve this game!
|
On December 23 2014 11:09 LightningStrike wrote:He didn't seem to act much like he did on Student IV and Christmas Carol game( Carol of the Bells Mafia) but I think him defending Breshke and Marv is kind of odd but so was their defense on me when I'm not scum but otherwise I don't got much on him.
@LS Why do you think that Coag calling Palmar scum implies that Coag is the scum?
|
On December 23 2014 11:10 sciberbia wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2014 11:09 LightningStrike wrote:On December 23 2014 11:05 kushm4sta wrote: so sicklucker is scum? He didn't seem to act much like he did on Student IV and Christmas Carol game( Carol of the Bells Mafia) but I think him defending Breshke and Marv is kind of odd but so was their defense on me when I'm not scum but otherwise I don't got much on him. @LS Why do you think that Coag calling Palmar scum implies that Coag is the scum? Well now I look like a idiot for it but nevermind on this because Coag is just being Coag. I just found it amusing. ##Unvote
|
Hi scrib. I was really convinced by your case but do you realize that VE being SK made it almost completely wrong? Thoughts on that?
Who are you looking among for scum? kush sicklucker coag ls ??
|
On December 23 2014 11:15 kushm4sta wrote: Hi scrib. I was really convinced by your case but do you realize that VE being SK made it almost completely wrong? Thoughts on that?
Who are you looking among for scum? kush sicklucker coag ls ?? Did you just listed yourself on your own list or was the list is for scib?
|
On December 23 2014 11:15 kushm4sta wrote: Hi scrib. I was really convinced by your case but do you realize that VE being SK made it almost completely wrong? Thoughts on that?
Who are you looking among for scum? kush sicklucker coag ls ??
@kush Hey man the first case was kinda wrong but the second case was still pretty spot on imo. The points about him not scumhunting and being overdefensive still stick regardless of whether he was SK or mafia. So I was a combination of lucky and good.
I'm mainly looking among you, sicklucker, and coag for scum.
The troubling thing is that if any of you 3 is scum you probably should have conceded by now, right? That makes me worry that either damdred is the luckiest scum alive, or that I've been wrong all game about LS being town.
+ Show Spoiler +On December 23 2014 11:13 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2014 11:10 sciberbia wrote:On December 23 2014 11:09 LightningStrike wrote:On December 23 2014 11:05 kushm4sta wrote: so sicklucker is scum? He didn't seem to act much like he did on Student IV and Christmas Carol game( Carol of the Bells Mafia) but I think him defending Breshke and Marv is kind of odd but so was their defense on me when I'm not scum but otherwise I don't got much on him. @LS Why do you think that Coag calling Palmar scum implies that Coag is the scum? Well now I look like a idiot for it but nevermind on this because Coag is just being Coag. I just found it amusing. ##Unvote @LS Can you explain your thought process a bit more? Why did you think it made Coag scum? Who do you think is scum now? I'm not sure myself and I'm love to hear some convincing arguments if you have any
|
I LISTED MYSELF ON MY OWN LIST OMG.
|
On December 23 2014 11:24 sciberbia wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2014 11:15 kushm4sta wrote: Hi scrib. I was really convinced by your case but do you realize that VE being SK made it almost completely wrong? Thoughts on that?
Who are you looking among for scum? kush sicklucker coag ls ?? @kush Hey man the first case was kinda wrong but the second case was still pretty spot on imo. The points about him not scumhunting and being overdefensive still stick regardless of whether he was SK or mafia. So I was a combination of lucky and good. I'm mainly looking among you, sicklucker, and coag for scum. The troubling thing is that if any of you 3 is scum you probably should have conceded by now, right? That makes me worry that either damdred is the luckiest scum alive, or that I've been wrong all game about LS being town. + Show Spoiler +On December 23 2014 11:13 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On December 23 2014 11:10 sciberbia wrote:On December 23 2014 11:09 LightningStrike wrote:On December 23 2014 11:05 kushm4sta wrote: so sicklucker is scum? He didn't seem to act much like he did on Student IV and Christmas Carol game( Carol of the Bells Mafia) but I think him defending Breshke and Marv is kind of odd but so was their defense on me when I'm not scum but otherwise I don't got much on him. @LS Why do you think that Coag calling Palmar scum implies that Coag is the scum? Well now I look like a idiot for it but nevermind on this because Coag is just being Coag. I just found it amusing. ##Unvote @LS Can you explain your thought process a bit more? Why did you think it made Coag scum? Who do you think is scum now? I'm not sure myself and I'm love to hear some convincing arguments if you have any At the time I was just being a idiot on reading that thing about Palmer being scum by him was scummy but he just being himself at the moment. I think I could nominate sicklucker mainly on meta reasons only though but if you want to hear it out then tell me and I will try to present my case on him. Otherwise I still clueless because I though scum would concede at this point. I got 1 more trick up my book to narrow it down more.
|
@scrib I think you are overestimating the likelihood scum would surrender. The defense "I would surrender by now" is extremely easy to think of, and potent. There are, what, 2 or 3 mislynches? One of us could be hoping that damdred gets conspiracy theory lynched.
|
|
|
|