TL Mafia LXIX: Carol Of The Bells - Page 4

On December 17 2014 08:51 sicklucker wrote:
Like I cant even make a case you havent been playing. Thats my case. If you sit and do do nothing for over a week eventually your mafia by poe.

On December 17 2014 08:56 sicklucker wrote:
Oats has a 3 page filter in a 190 page game. Guys? Like ls, rstun, hts you know hes mafia from this alone based on last game where he had 10x the filter in a much less active game.

On December 18 2014 10:02 sicklucker wrote:
Gb can still be mafia. But hes so less likely and he correctly explain why hf is mafia. your on my mafia radar now the line in the sand has been drawn. Hf basicly claimed by not telling us who he sent the present to if you didnt read the thread.

On December 18 2014 16:54 GlowingBear wrote:
Remember that the present thing is not about FAKE claiming: it's about that a scum wouldn't give a present to a town unless he was going to shoot him.
So holyflare sent it to a scum partner because he will be caught on a lie of he says he sent it to a townie and he will incriminate a mafia partner if he gets lybched and flip red.

Again, it's simple logic.

On December 18 2014 16:48 GlowingBear wrote:


Really bad as scum
Extremely bad as town

It's ridiculous how many inconsistencies I've found on holyflare's gameplay. He's not one to drown on such fallacies and misinterpretations of posts.
It sounds mafia. It makes perfect sense that HF is the roleblocker therefore they lynched KSC.
Obi obviously did shot LoneMeow.

If you can't see this, you're really stupid.

Town holyflare has no problem in saying to whom he gave the present, because this guy already doesn't have the present l, so it's safe to claim to whom he has given it. He doesn't say because he will incriminate another mafia if he says or the townie will say he never got the present. This is a simple scum claim.

If you doubt it, just ask to HF to whom he gave the present. If he refuses to say, ask why. He won't give you a satisfactory reason, I guarantee.

Also, have this in mind: if he sent his present to someone, how does he knows this person have this present to FF instead of opening it? How does he knows this person gave the present to FF? Hint: it's because he gave the present to his scum partner and FF not being dead means he is the Godfather.

Forget it's me who is saying this. Think of it as a whisper in the dark. Doesn't it makes sense?

On December 19 2014 10:07 sicklucker wrote:
Heres holyflares mafia strategy. Lynch a team mate or gb if he has the numbers he has the perfect excuse to change his vote and save himself. Tomorrow if templars lynched as town or mafia regardless he gets a free lynch on gb because he will kill two votes against himself. Then it will be lylo with 2 or 3 mafia with a potential kp present in there hands. He will have gained a little town cred in the process.

On December 19 2014 10:45 rsoultin wrote:
Oats, can we get some reads from you, please? I agree with a good number of your comments...but at the same time countering SL is kinda obvious anyway. The guy doesn't think.

On December 19 2014 23:20 Vivax wrote:
What I can criticize about HF's case is that it came at a time where people were already willing to vote Templar so it didn't exactly add much novelty. You could call it a nail in the coffin but it also looks a bit like overkill, something a scum HF could have done just cause he said he would write a huge wall of text case previously, and not something we really needed.

I didn't even read it lol, Templar is an easy gut-read at this point and before, based on my previous games with him.

Sorry HF I don't think I will ever feel confident enough to call you town after my past experiences, there are these interactions with scum that suggest townie but I fully trust you'd have the means of planting them on purpose.

On December 20 2014 01:28 GlowingBear wrote:
About the mass claiming: I'd rather have confirmed town shot and mafia lynched than a power role alive but a townie mislynched.

Power of vote > power roles.

(Thanks IAMP, btw)

On December 20 2014 21:36 GlowingBear wrote:
Wow, Vivax is town...

Took me too long to realise, sorry.

I'm with you, Vivax. I think your analysis is informative. HTS, Xat and Templar makes a lot of sense.
But oats is playing this game so indifferently that it makes me shiver.
Maybe he is a possible 4 mafia?

On December 20 2014 23:28 GlowingBear wrote:


Sorry, you have been extremely useful in this game, I'd love to play of your way