TL Mafia LXIX: Carol Of The Bells - Page 11

On December 17 2014 10:30 Fecalfeast wrote:


Why did you ninja vote oatsmaster?

On December 18 2014 09:48 rsoultin wrote:


Lol, seriously LS? I'm kind of disappointed in you, honestly. Both you and SL already know that NKs are WIFOM. You were both in my first game when we all discussed it. Yet you're going to take present speculation and NKs over a strong scum case? Remove lynches, NKs, and presents, and where has HF been scummy? More to the point, where has he been more scummy than GB?

You really think SL is town? Have you ever paused to wonder why he's been hyper-focused on presents the entire game? He gave a present to Damdred. Damdred died and flipped town. Mafia would never give presents to town. Unless, of course, mafia gave a present to town, killed him, then made the link that town must give presents to town. He's been hyper-focused on this the entire game. And hyper-focused that no matter how scummy GB is acting, GB is town.

Did it never occur to you that mafia could kill two town members who now seem quite townie but are reading HF as scum precisely to make it look like mafia is trying to protect HF? Did it never occur to you that a member of the scum team itself might not bring forth this interpretation of the NKs, no matter how WIFOM it is, to try to sway your vote?

What makes SL town in this game? And even more relevant...what makes him right? He has to be one of the least logical players in the game.