Russia Today Mini Mafia - Page 33

On November 28 2014 03:59 Holyflare wrote:
It's only useless if you don't agree?????????

On November 28 2014 02:08 Superbia wrote:


You were an active part of last game's OBS QT, a game in which I was mafia and I survived the entire game. But rather than draw any correlations between my play that game and this game, you come up with a vague meta-read of "Superbia is a big list poster", which you can't even properly pin point to a fucking game, let alone an alignment. The fact that you were OBSing my scum-game from a couple of days ago, try to give a half-assed "read" on me based on "meta", during which you don't even refer to the scum-game I played a couple of days ago, is scummy as fuck.
you're overreacting over a simple statement. It doesn't matter if I was part of the obs qt or not. In fact, you were too quiet and one liner in that game. I wasn't following it closely too, I've only skimmed a little.

Let's move on to the rest of your game so far:



I hate this post. You basically discredit HF's case but draw zero conclusions from it. What's the point? Why do you feel a need to comment on the case if you have nothing to add and JAT hasn't even posted yet? How does this help town? Protip: it doesn't.
So you don't think that pointing out a bad argument that makes no one mafia doesn't help town? The conclusion I've drawn from it is that HFs case on JAT is wrong. I'm trying to put town on the right track



Yet previously you say:



What did you like about the post before? Because you just said that the post had no content and was useless. Moreover, you manage to make two posts about the same fucking post and manage to draw zero conclusions from it.
[b] The conclusion is that that post is bad and we should take a look on geript. And that's what we did.
Funny thing that, in the other hand, you rush to draw conclusions from something you don't even have complete information yet ("what is good in this post"). You're trying to point out scummy things in me without even considering the whole scenario.
The good thing about this post is that townies often call bad things out to generate discussion. Pointing that it's a bad argument is also part of the town role.



Again, you reach zero actual conclusions here. Is Elvis mafia for doing this? Do you feel like a newer player would be trying to actively disrupt the game in which there are a lot of veterans as scum?
Yes. It's more likely, though, as newbies tend to be ignored in the game and he could pull the newbie card.
Is he mafia? I don't know, still too early, but it means we should take a look at him.

Then GB goes for some weak fucking pushes on Elvis, followed by:



And a couple of minutes later:



What the fuck? Why aren't you voting on Elvis, who you should have the bigger scumread on (judging by your posts)?
You salty? does it makes me mafia?

TL;DR: GB's non-spam posts reach 0 conclusions. GB's meta-read is shit-tier, and it shouldn't be. GB isn't doing anything for town. GB is mafai.

##Unvote
##Vote: GlowingBear

On November 28 2014 05:09 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'll stop lurking later tonight.

Maybe.