|
On November 27 2014 07:48 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 07:42 Half the Sky wrote:
That is frustrating, his voting also made no sense. We had no way of figuring he was the doctor, and I was convinced enough by kush. Now I'm having a really bad feeling about this. Who else seemed driven to vote DSMI? Oats and Damndred. Sorry the late reply for the night post but my fears had happened :|. rsoultin your apology is accepted. My reads had now changed because of this lynching. My scum team are the ones who pushed for DSMI Kush Oatsmaster Damndred. If we got a cop check one of those 3 out. If we got a Tracker go on to anyone since we got possible setups with a doctor revealed and we got no idea which setup is being used except for either Set up A or Set up C :|
Pushing on someone and getting them lynched and then they flip town doesnt mean someone is mafia. Town can be wrong, town is often wrong
Also sicklucker my read on you is that you havnt gotten anything from last game. You say noone townreads you ever? So why has your play not changed at all? At the moment i think you are towna nd this is why it is so frustrating. You think im mafia because i voted bats and say i should be lynched then backtrack on it later saying it was just a pieace of evidence. What about the rest of my play? Or are you going to vote me purely for one thing of "evidence'
|
On November 27 2014 07:59 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 07:55 Damdred wrote:
Why are people who pushed things scum? Who actually went through the trouble of making a case? Kush was the one who went through the trouble of making a case for the lynching.
Was he the only one who made a case today?
|
Looks like a few people.
So I hear DSMIC did little or nothing to defend from hearsay comments right after the lynch.
What was the reason he was lynched given?
If nobody can think of it and put it down fast enough for me to see it, then whoever led the lynch is probably mafia.
Note, the leader is not the first voter, it is the person who most actively pursued the lynch.
|
I most actively pursued the lynch,
It was he said he had no time to read, but came away with a vote saying he read someones filters
He voted for said person even though he said someone else was scum and the person he voted he never said was scummy.
He asked questions with no follow up
Always took the middle ground
Dodged Questions posed by others
At time of his lynch he did not fight or claim he was medic or give any substantiated reads.
|
Your reads are not completely horrible ls, but theirs no way their all right mafia is not so obvious to vote with each other on day 1. So when you say the scum team is the people who voted him out your just wrong. Some towns lead the charge. Some mafia might have joined in. I think its a bit likely one of kush or dand are mafia. Little chance they both are
|
On November 27 2014 08:03 sicklucker wrote:
Your reads are not completely horrible ls, but theirs no way their all right mafia is not so obvious to vote with each other on day 1. So when you say the scum team is the people who voted him out your just wrong. Some towns lead the charge. Some mafia might have joined in. I think its a bit likely one of kush or dand are mafia. Little chance they both are
This is wifom basically, sometimes mafia do vote and use this exxcuse later
|
On November 27 2014 08:01 Alakaslam wrote:
Looks like a few people.
So I hear DSMIC did little or nothing to defend from hearsay comments right after the lynch.
What was the reason he was lynched given?
If nobody can think of it and put it down fast enough for me to see it, then whoever led the lynch is probably mafia.
Note, the leader is not the first voter, it is the person who most actively pursued the lynch.
The original leader was hands down kush. My first reaction to it was that it was pretty weak. He made id rather get out scum lurker then a scum bats case.
|
On November 27 2014 08:03 sicklucker wrote:
Your reads are not completely horrible ls, but theirs no way their all right mafia is not so obvious to vote with each other on day 1. So when you say the scum team is the people who voted him out your just wrong. Some towns lead the charge. Some mafia might have joined in. I think its a bit likely one of kush or dand are mafia. Little chance they both are
True but then again my last game when I got lynched as Cop 1 mafia had their votes on me so it could just be 1 of them on the Doctor lynching.
|
Kush didnt really give good reasons. Just that it was obv and I was bad for slightly town reading him early etc. But at the same time I think bats gets lynched if damdred doesint join in.
|
Well I don't even know what to say then.
Gotta go beback
|
On November 27 2014 08:08 sicklucker wrote:
Kush didnt really give good reasons. Just that it was obv and I was bad for slightly town reading him early etc. But at the same time I think bats gets lynched if damdred doesint join in.
What is the significance of this? Please draw conclusions don't just recount what happened.
|
Slam do you think Damdred is a good enough scum player to make a really good case to convince people near deadline. Do you think he would do this to save a mafia? (bats)
|
On November 27 2014 08:09 Breshke wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 08:08 sicklucker wrote:
Kush didnt really give good reasons. Just that it was obv and I was bad for slightly town reading him early etc. But at the same time I think bats gets lynched if damdred doesint join in. What is the significance of this? Please draw conclusions don't just recount what happened.
Im summarizing for slam calm down he doesint have much time its a holiday
|
Breske being anti town too. Its annoying
|
Hold up a second here, if you were so sure that Bats is scum and I was wrong. Why did you say "OH HOLY CRAP DAMDRED HAS CONVINCED ME". And now blame me, you could of pushed bats and told dick to get on bats and it would of been 5 5 and you could of pushed bats off a cliff if you really wanted to, so why blame me now and throw dirt on me on a case that YOU said was good.
|
Wow thats even more anti town
|
I didnt think bats is scum I think thats clear. Ive said its your case that convinced me so im asking people info on you to help clear you or get dirt on you thats what a town should do not overreact to players trying to solve the game
|
Damdred im not even pushing you and your so defensive? what gives?
|
Then why didn't you push someone you thought was really scum?
|
Because it was between bats and dick. I had my vote on someone who I thought was scum. Like I said I dont waste my vote if theirs two horses ill vote on who Im convinced is more likely scum.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
