EPTStudent Mafia IV (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 01 2014 22:22 rsoultin wrote: Okay, so now it's time to be newb and need help. "hammer" - does that mean vote? cause "hammer" sounds negative lol And I am reading the damn timestamp right this time, right? We've got more than 24 hours left? Hammer is the vote that sets it to lynch. And yeah over 24h (48 h days) | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 01 2014 22:36 rsoultin wrote: Lol, SL...circular reasoning dude. I didn't like that in Damdred (HTS is bad cause SL is bad cause HTS is bad), and I don't like it here. Sides, he left me off too. I seem to recall being left off several lists early game. Felt unloved ;o; Though I was being a bit of a sarcastic ass too so that's okay lol. No one has to love me. I'm sure oats loves you. Oats loves everyone. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
I was going to say lynch LS then HTS but I don't have a good enough case on either right now. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 02 2014 10:26 rsoultin wrote: Edit: @ meat Would really just like to hear what you have. It's okay if it's not super solid or something. I think we're all uncertain right now, which is why everyone is so worried about who to lynch and lynching the wrong person, lol. In a way, I assumed he was N2 after for voting kush. Mainly because LS was already scum read to me and I assumed that neither bats or oats would be. So leaving off rasputin, breshke and sl that left me with hts and hopeless 1der. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 02 2014 10:44 rsoultin wrote: Honestly, meat, by that logic you should be voting for me lol. Which I wouldn't blame people for doing. I'm the one who voted for kush last and refused to change my vote to HTS. It might help if you read EoD Day 2 and Night 2...your last few posts lead me to believe you haven't been paying attention to those. I have read it, is there anything you want to draw my attention to? Maybe I missed something... Also I am more confident that you are town over HtS, so far I haven't been convinced on bats either. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 02 2014 10:58 rsoultin wrote: HTS didn't switch his vote to me when he could have to prevent his being lynched. He also said something when he thought he'd been lynched, but a couple of the votes weren't counted. Those two reasons are my reasons. He was pretty null to me before EoD Day 2 as well. Since you read that, I assume there's a reason you're still suspicious of him? Wait, he didn't prevent himself being lynched so that makes him town? That's weird of him either way. I'm going to check it again, I had thought that the last votes were counted. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
Ls is in this game to ask dead end questions and be all around pilly wally. What has he done besides cover his tracks and post little during the times when he was able to coast, mainly because bats and oats and mainly the rest of town has been fighting over one another. So my previous vote analysis notwithstanding, it's almost clear that scum has had almost no play in the push of town against town, and this explains the passive play by ls. He could vote for A or B or whatever and it doesn't really matter because either way one step closer to lylo. I would be happy to vote on ls even if I had another viable choice here. In fact I would have thought about it yesterday, but kush being afk made me assume that he was lacking in defense. Oh oats I guess I owe you an apology. You were right about kush all along. But the problem is that you did a crappy job of convincing me or anyone else. I dind't have any reason to believe you especially when the way I was reading him was different to yours. I guess you have played together before still it's pretty easy to change your play especially when you're not posting much, right? | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 02 2014 22:08 Breshke wrote: Meatpudding what i don't get it you read kush as scummy for not posting much of a defense or whatever, and i agreed with you on that so im not blaming you for starting that wagon but you have been under the spotlight most of today and at least in my eyes have failed to defend yourself until now. Why were you happy to do something that made you read kush as scummy? I had to read that a couple times before it made sense but you're asking why I haven't been defending myself? I guess I suck at defense. I was hoping to put together a good case but I didn't get the diving done that I wanted to, especially the more recent posts by hts and oats. So I also haven't really updated my reads at all. But about kush I was first reading him as scummy for making very off topic and limited content posts. When he went massively afk that was just a bonus reason. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 02 2014 22:17 LightningStrike wrote: Okay I will explain my sheeping since I woke up. I did sheep in my last game too till I got lynched and when I was in the OBS qt for that game after death I swore after one player that died who called sicklucker town sicklucker was scum because afterwards his posting seemed to be scum like at the time. I was shocked to learn he really was town and so I don't really trust my own judgement still after that game so I was going with the Veterans of TL mafia for voting unless I get a power role that can detect alignments aka Cop/Detective or Tracker/Watcher. That's all I can say about my sheeping. Read my filter from the Campus Mafia for proof of my sheeping in that game. Vt has the power to vote. Not using your votes to hunt for scum in anti town hence leaning heavily on scum for your alignment. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
| ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 03 2014 08:50 Half the Sky wrote: Breshke, it's almost midnight here, I can crank a few more things for the next half hour, anything in particular you want me to check? Almost through with LS. Here's another post we can examine... The above was D2. What is the point of this? Half his reads are null anyway. Is there anything you can tell from here or any reason to repost it now? | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 03 2014 13:00 sicklucker wrote: Heres the only situation you should vote breske out. If theirs one mafia left and its the roleblocker. Even then im not saying you should do it but thats the only situation where it makes sense. That makes absolutely no sense. Any scum could have claimed not just the rb. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 03 2014 14:04 rsoultin wrote: Bats did. Though looking back through, it was Hope who started the lynch push on me, after bats posted that list and Damdred said I was acting scummy with the hammer vote and that he wished more were around so they could lynch me lol. Hrum. Whatcha think? LS following bats (who he had a scum read on) around like a duckling a clever move designed to implicate bats if he ever flipped, or a new scum player transparently following bat's lead? I don't think even a new player would be that transparent. | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 03 2014 20:19 sicklucker wrote: Meat who are the last two mafia Probably not bats | ||
|
meatpudding
Australia520 Posts
On December 03 2014 21:57 Half the Sky wrote: Read this AND the last thing I posted on his record. Now that we know LS is scum, I'm re-reading everything he's done and put out there. His list of threes tells me he seemed like he wanted to take you out for awhile, which makes me reconsider you as scum, second page, since all the reads are together, he probably didn't want to indicate he was possibly aligned with anyone. It's always good to go back and re-examine someone when their role is revealed and that's so that we aren't missing anything. I am also posting such that if anyone else here had a different opinion on this, they can say something on it. Context. If there's one mafia left and it's the roleblocker...the key word here is AND. Even then I would take this a step further and say that if it's one scum left, we know it's RB, and the people left are what we think are the towncircle. Either way his situation he describes is that we know what specifics are being revealed as a scum goes. You read the N3 post right? It revealed LS as a goon, so we have one goon and the RB left. This still doesn't make sense. IF mafia didn't use the rb, then the rb could have asked someone else to claim. | ||
| ||
