|
On November 27 2014 08:08 sicklucker wrote:
Kush didnt really give good reasons. Just that it was obv and I was bad for slightly town reading him early etc. But at the same time I think bats gets lynched if damdred doesint join in.
What is the significance of this? Please draw conclusions don't just recount what happened.
|
|
|
Damdred can i ask for your thoughts on my EoD actions. I only ask this because you seemed to agree with SL in the begining that it was scummy but havnt said anything since.
|
On November 27 2014 08:52 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 08:44 Breshke wrote:
Damdred can i ask for your thoughts on my EoD actions. I only ask this because you seemed to agree with SL in the begining that it was scummy but havnt said anything since. SL is correct in that its weird that you would agree with one case and then vote in a totally opposite direction. However it is not scummy in of itself Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 06:24 Breshke wrote:
I don't know on one hand I like damdreds case on dicksmash it makes sense. But on the other I don't like how easily this bandwagon formed although if i agree with damdreds case then i guess it isn't that weird because then other people obviously would as well.
SL i think its strange that when the vote had 5 people in it you didn't seem to think at least one was mafia and that you are already finding reasons to throw scum on people not for their play but for pre flip reasons on dicksmash. I still don't like SL's early trap as it achieved nothing and he didnt seem to make it try and achieve anything.
I also dislike bats, yeah you can change votes as much as you want it isn't a big deal but I don't feel like the reasons you changed votes are justified. I also don't liek that you are wasting your vote to basically prove a point.
##Vote: Batsnacks The bolded part makes me a little nervous, Hey guys this guy is wasteing his vote which I don't like so i'm going to waste my vote on Bats. Then you really don't push bats for the rest of the day even though you are here and you could of possibly got people on Batsnacks instead of dick. So no you voting away from a case that you agree with is not scummy, some of your other acions are questionable
Yeah i ddin't try and force the vote to go onto bats because yes i did agree with your case i just didnt like how easily the wagon froemd as i said because there was little to no resistance to it and there was hardly even a counter wagon which i thought might mean that Dick was town. I wasn't going to push this thought though because his partners might have just been leaving him out to dry.
Are you telling me you like bats? I didn't like bats and I didn't like Dicksmash, I voted for bats because i liked him less .
What else have i done that is questionable?
|
Because I wasn't going to take the vote off of dicksmash. Yes i thought he could have been town but you had a good case and he hardly even tried after that. Yeah he was the doctor but he didn't even try to defend himself I was happy with that lynch going though but i would have been happier with a bats lynch. Bats has been more involved though so im not going to try and force the lynch onto someone that will give stuff lateer in the day over someone who wasnt even trying.
Why did you specifically say i had other questionable actions yet you cant pinpoint anything else?
|
On November 27 2014 10:54 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 09:55 Breshke wrote:
Because I wasn't going to take the vote off of dicksmash. Yes i thought he could have been town but you had a good case and he hardly even tried after that. Yeah he was the doctor but he didn't even try to defend himself I was happy with that lynch going though but i would have been happier with a bats lynch. Bats has been more involved though so im not going to try and force the lynch onto someone that will give stuff lateer in the day over someone who wasnt even trying.
Why did you specifically say i had other questionable actions yet you cant pinpoint anything else? So you dont vote him but would rather hes the one that dies? Thats like your standard I wanna keep my hands clean scum play.
Nope how am i trying to "keep my hands clean" i didnt try to save dicksmash my hands arn't clean. The bolded section doesn't even make sense with the conclusion you drew. How is me admitting that i didn't want to take the vote off the person who flipped town keeping my hands clean?
|
Guess what SL you can actually think more than one person is scummy. There is 3 scum in this game. I never said i didn't want to vote him, I just wanted to vote bats more.
How about you explain why damdreds case convinced you so suddenly that it made you be able to read him town and DSMIC mafia?
|
So you have played one game with him and you think that gives you a god meta read?
What in his case was so convincing?
|
On November 27 2014 11:12 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 11:06 Breshke wrote:
So you have played one game with him and you think that gives you a god meta read?
What in his case was so convincing? The same stuff that convinced you?. Yes one read was enough for me to switch since he was the only reason I was not since my early suspicious of him were why I didnt.
Why cant you say exactly what that is then? If it convinced you so easily you should be able to say why. Why are you not answering the question?
So you really think damdred is not capable of making one convincing read as mafia?
|
On November 27 2014 11:33 sicklucker wrote:
Why dont you? See we can play this all day and your actually the one whos under the microscope for this not me. Your the one who agreed but didnt back it up by voting.
I figured out he was mafia in another game. I feel I have a good read on him. Hes still null for me since how it turned 0out but at the time I was totally convinced I didnt need much tho I was on the fench.
Brb eating maybe ill answer your question but I might not.
I don't see whats so hard about this answer the question? Why are you stalling why cant you say what you found so convincing about damdreds case.
You have a good read on him but he is null for you right now. Why is he null for you know but was town for you before the lynch?
|
On November 27 2014 12:01 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 11:42 Breshke wrote:On November 27 2014 11:33 sicklucker wrote:
Why dont you? See we can play this all day and your actually the one whos under the microscope for this not me. Your the one who agreed but didnt back it up by voting.
I figured out he was mafia in another game. I feel I have a good read on him. Hes still null for me since how it turned 0out but at the time I was totally convinced I didnt need much tho I was on the fench.
Brb eating maybe ill answer your question but I might not. I don't see whats so hard about this answer the question? Why are you stalling why cant you say what you found so convincing about damdreds case. You have a good read on him but he is null for you right now. Why is he null for you know but was town for you before the lynch? He was scum before the lynch. I dont vote with scums
Are we talking about damdred? You deffs voted with damdred?
|
On November 27 2014 12:01 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 11:42 Breshke wrote:On November 27 2014 11:33 sicklucker wrote:
Why dont you? See we can play this all day and your actually the one whos under the microscope for this not me. Your the one who agreed but didnt back it up by voting.
I figured out he was mafia in another game. I feel I have a good read on him. Hes still null for me since how it turned 0out but at the time I was totally convinced I didnt need much tho I was on the fench.
Brb eating maybe ill answer your question but I might not. I don't see whats so hard about this answer the question? Why are you stalling why cant you say what you found so convincing about damdreds case. You have a good read on him but he is null for you right now. Why is he null for you know but was town for you before the lynch? He was scum before the lynch. I dont vote with scums
Do you read your own posts? You said he was scum before the lynch? So you thought he was scum BEFORE the lynch yet still voted with him.
I actually already said what i liked about damdreds case when damdred asked me. It was the fact that Dicksmash defended you and then didnt puch back on damdred when he was questioning you. To which dicksmash had no defense, not that he defended himself much at all anyway.
|
On November 27 2014 12:21 sicklucker wrote:
Well I dont think he is anymore because no role misses a vote when their being looked at. I would love bats to take a bullit
What do you mean no role? this aswell makes 0 sense to me.
|
On November 27 2014 12:25 LightningStrike wrote:
After reading what everyone said from Oats would rather visit bats grave when his dog needs to take a piss to discussion on who to lynch tomorrow I think our best options is either Damndred or Bats. Bats because he keep changing his votes without a explanation which can be scummy or just bats trolling us like he did early on in the last game I played with him. Damndred because he help start the lynch actively without a good reason and had a baseless defense on his vote.
So why did you sheep damdred if you think he started the lynch actively without a good reason?
|
Yes sicklucker is probably town, it was frustrating last game and its frustrating this game.
|
On November 27 2014 12:49 batsnacks wrote:
You guys shouldn't worry about what SL is saying because it's wrong.
Just pretend he's saying, "I'M TOWN!" "I'M TOWN!"
And pretend he's right.
Best way to read SL probably
|
rsoultin to the best of my knowledge bussing is when mafia votes a mafia so if your town i would stop using that word to refer to your actions
|
On November 27 2014 14:20 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 09:55 Breshke wrote:
Because I wasn't going to take the vote off of dicksmash. Yes i thought he could have been town but you had a good case and he hardly even tried after that. Yeah he was the doctor but he didn't even try to defend himself I was happy with that lynch going though but i would have been happier with a bats lynch. Bats has been more involved though so im not going to try and force the lynch onto someone that will give stuff lateer in the day over someone who wasnt even trying.
Why did you specifically say i had other questionable actions yet you cant pinpoint anything else? I didn't want you to think i was dodging you so I figured i should answer you now. Your lead up to your vote, vote and then actions around deadline were questionable to someone who thought that they were on the higher percentage lynch candidate. Besides that you seemed ok today, you didn't go hard at me for no answering you on your read questions though when you probably should of pressured the hell out of me at that point.
I appreciate you going back and answering this.
Probably should have but I thought you were trying to get newbies to make reads first so they werent sheeping you then you ended up making a case anyway.
|
On November 27 2014 14:33 Damdred wrote:
Well I was trying to let things develop and some of the scum reads made me laugh pretty hard tbh damdred asked 16-17 questions he's so obvious scum. But the thread was kind of stagnant with no cases so I figured I should push the scummiest person.
What do you think of oats bresh
MM he has been focused on bats a fair bit but mentions reads on other people every know and then but everything seems to come back to bats for him. I agree with him on bats though and see why he is pushing it and like that he kept pushing it even though no one was really jumping on. I don't like that he wasn't around at EoD because if he has a strong mafia read id think he would try make himself be so he can push his read. This can probably be attributed to time zones though.
So i think he is lleaning town this could be biased because he is also reading bats scum but I am happy to see him as town for now.
The fact that im reading him as town and also reading trefel as town reinforces my feeling that bats is mafia because him and meatpudding were the only ones to not have their votes on Dicksmash at EoD and i think that while possible it is unlikely all three mafia stacked on him.
|
No other reasons.
It is strange though that you were happy to leave your vote on someone who you seemingly weren't reading as scum.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
