Student Mafia IV (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 10

On November 30 2014 09:49 batsnacks wrote:
TMI

On November 30 2014 09:54 sicklucker wrote:
Breske rsoultin hts is a world.

On November 29 2014 22:18 Half the Sky wrote:


Neither individual is helping the town agenda (both have promoted policy votes over scum votes for example).
Looking at both Bats and Kush (as my current vote is on Bats) and using the above as a checklist for Kush:

#1 - Check. I had pointed out the D1 argument on page 51, but why does Kush expect any of us to think that D1 makes him a townie? Reads with the exception of the one Kush did on his phone have been weak/unsupported. Bats' voting D1 was a problem, but the gap between voting Damdred and then jumping to DSMI is even worse given the arguments he used to try and sell that vote. He pushed that vote well before Damdred did.

#2 - Check. Bats has dodged questions from three people this game (Oats, Breshke, myself). Kush isn't saying much of anything to begin with, but he dodged Oats on the Damdred read.

#3 - Check. Kush is way more sporadic than Bats, Thanksgiving is forgiveable, but afterwards, even Bats hasn't afked.

#4 - Check. At least I remember Bats for being overly defensive. Kush's filter on the other hand, I have had to filter dive three times in the last 12 hours.

I'd say he's topped Bats in the scum category.

##unvote
##vote kushm4sta

On November 27 2014 03:05 Half the Sky wrote:


LS, check page 1. DSMI is not in the noob category. You were last game and this game. You cannot compare the two situations.

Kush, I went through his filter again, and now your arguments are making a lot more sense. I checked the filter against the sequence of his reads/explanations versus others for the same individuals and there is a lot of bandwagoning. Too much for his own good this late in the day.

I'm still not feeling too good about Batsnacks though, ignoring any meta. I would be lying if I said otherwise.

##Unvote
##Vote Dicksmash McIroncock

On December 01 2014 06:31 Half the Sky wrote:
My three (no particular order)

Meat, Oats, LightningStrike

Seems like we agree on Meat and Oats. Just pick either one of those two and go with it.
N2 death will also reveal more.

Also Bats, just because someone is vanilla does not mean they are going to be correct, especially not being a power role.
I'm fully aware I am massively failing this game.

Damdred, I get your point on Breshke, but how probable is it actually? I guess you're saying that because he did nothing at EoD.

On November 30 2014 07:02 Half the Sky wrote:
Well GGs, frustrating, but that's that.

I refused to switch because I believed he was town, I'm going to be revealed as town shortly, but some of you really shot yourselves in the foot.

On December 01 2014 07:31 sicklucker wrote:


Did you tho? All I saw was you sheeping bats. This is very scummy

On December 02 2014 04:58 rsoultin wrote:
Damdred was town. Doesn't make him infallible. If you have a case, make it @bats

Dodging questions and not backing up your statements looks scummy, even taking out what I personally think of your play. Continually trying to hide behind your association with Damdred instead of building any credibility of your own through reads and trying to figure out the game also strikes me as scummy.

Why is LS a bad lynch if he's mafia? Why did you say that?