EPT@HF, I like your read on SL and on Rayn.
To me templar looks better now after reading his filter a bit and i'm still not sure why lian is being so self destructive even if hes scum.
@VE, do you still think HF is scum?
VI Titanic Mini Mafia: The Return of MSPaint - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
@HF, I like your read on SL and on Rayn. To me templar looks better now after reading his filter a bit and i'm still not sure why lian is being so self destructive even if hes scum. @VE, do you still think HF is scum? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 22 2014 00:09 VisceraEyes wrote: This is why I'm voting for Holyflare. Stop being lazy VE, you haven't really tried to convince anyone that HF is mafia you have just kinda took pot shots at him and put your vote their. And I really just don't see scum!HF from what the little you are showing us | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 22 2014 00:13 VisceraEyes wrote: Then get led astray. Again. You still haven't really shown why this is scum!hf you are just throwing your vote down and fucking off come on nowve | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 22 2014 00:37 Holyflare wrote: my list of 6 We have I think something like 13 and a half hours left until deadline, so out of the six who would you say has the greatest shot at being scum? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
I know your case on SL and its not bad at all, I think templar looks better after reading his filter again this morning but why me hf | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 22 2014 07:54 raynpelikoneet wrote: And i complained about thefact templar has\had no reads, YET HE DID NOTHING TO CHANGE IT!! If you dunno who is scum you find that out, he didn't even try. That's the fucking point. I am amazed you can't see this and instead throw some crap on me. Templar has done a good bit and even though its in list post form he draws attention to some good things so yes he does have reads. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
on phone so quotes will be limited Your list post that you just posted had reads to a degree as in they showed thought behind it and you actually brought a few decent points of contention towards me. While they aren't rock solid I think that it shows where you are and where you are going. You show effort in your defense and while writing long posts isn't totally town it still shows reading and thought process. so yea i think rayn is wrong in what he's saying | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Sicklurker IS a good lynch today and I would like to lynch him. He's been flinging stuff and town reading people based on little to nothing and makes excuses. I would vote him very quickly if I had paint right now (is there a paint ap?). Look at the post he just talked about me in, the same things he's saying about me could be said for half the game probably. Who cares if I haven't cluttered up the thread with tons of towneeads I tried that once it backfired pretty hard, I question currently and some things aboutrayn hf and ve bother me but I don't think that they could be mafia together so I'm reading other games when I have a break and I do have townreads like I would marry GB right now | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
GB just stay a litlle longer to try to work this out i'm about to read hopeless now to see if I like him over SL.And sheep me yea? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 20 2014 19:22 sicklucker wrote: ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/S2fPznW.png) So I think people have jumped on a little quickly at 5am 3 hours into the game for me but ll try to keep up. VisceraEyes is pretty town here . I dont think someone with 16k posts is going to make a 10 page case right out of the gete with pretty small evidence. I truly believe he thinks what he says. I didnt think much of templars post but I cant wait to hear what rayn has to say about it because I think hes a pretty good town player, their both null for me now. liancourt is scummy as hell. But im not sure I would ever come into the game as any alignment make my first post saying I havent read the thread then make a second post voting someone. So im not totally sure what this means is he usually like this?. He even said hes not going to read the thread. But the only game of mafia I ever played, the mafias were super obvious so im in the mindset of guilty untill proven innocent with him. Lets start with the first bolded part. Read it, tell me does he have a real reason to read VE as town by the introduction into the thread.... Ok I gave you time to think about it, the short answer is NOOOOO its not reason enough to give someone a town read especially that early with the amount of information that was present in the thread at the time. It feels like he is trying to find a reason to townread someone and look like hes doing something in the thread. Moving on to the next bolded portion of text to me this looks like the most whimsical scum read that their can be. I think such and such is scummy but i'll wait to see what <insert player name says> if he doesn't think much of the post why doesn't he elaborate on what is wrong in it and just go into it instead of trying to make someone else do something with it. On November 20 2014 19:50 sicklucker wrote: No let me clarify I said your post means nothing to me, as in I dont see it making you town or scum. Thats why I said both rayn and you were null for me. Im just curious what rayn has to say backtracking under a little bit of pressure On November 21 2014 04:17 sicklucker wrote: I kinda wanna mislynch you again to ff ^_^. I got some time to contribute rereading the thread. ritoky is town. Hes trying to keep the peace and get that horribly overreacted fight done with. I dont think a mafia ever has the balls or the motive to keep the peace when we have people threatening to veggie shoot people two hours into the gamee. This is just a super weird post to me. Even if it was a joke this is something that mafia would say. Before this post with ritoky he looked ok but I do not think is enough to town read someone on it basically looks like another town read out of nothing. Look at his scum reads basically everything he says can be taken back from. Templar was his top scum read and soon as Templar pus together a few posts he immediately retreats and says whops nope. Every single one of his scum reads can easily be moved from. And some of them he doesn't even acknowledge past a point (hf). Overall I find SL to be one of the most scummy people in the thread,he seems to come up with his townreads out of thin air. Even though he posts it doesn't feel like hes sticking his neck out very far and is able to pull back very easily from whatever he is doing. I think hes a good shot at scum | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i60.tinypic.com/2nqv4vp.png) | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On November 23 2014 00:50 The_Templar wrote: Damdred You're really going to need to do better than that. This is barely even a defense of me at all. You weak-defend me a lot when it looks like I'm going to be lynched. Almost as if you know I'm going to flip town. While you posted this, which happened to be correct, You never actually said why this was accurate at all. You had 4 hours between these two posts and your only clarification was that "I drew attention to things". Well, what does this mean? Can you ever tell anyone how I actually played in mission mafia or is that no longer important? "Templar posted a lot of words and some of them made sense so he is showing that he has basic literary skills, so I think Rayn's mafia read on him is wrong." This is not a town read. This is actually a "he is playing the game" read, used to determine whether you are going to policy lynch a lurker or not. His soft reads of me as town combined with the fact I was likely to be lynched at that point make me read him scum up to this point. When people start unvoting me, he immediately turns away from me to push sicklucker who he hadn't said anything specific on yet. Here's what I read. "I'm busy excuse excuse. A IS a good lynch. By the way, I also want to lynch him. Suspicious things he's done mainly involve B (which I would like to clarify more but can't), as his reads apply to multiple people. I haven't read many people as town because excuse excuse excuse excuse excuse completely unrelated read excuse excuse C is town." Basically, he says SL is scummy because he's pushing a vague read onto him. At this point, it seems like OMGUS to me because it doesn't really mean much to say that someone is doing this. He proceeds to make a fairly good case on SL, but he hasn't done anything since then despite being around. Basically, the only person he has bothered to invest time in reading is SL. Honestly your case is a whole bunch of nitpicky things that really don't add up to me being mafia in the grand scheme of things or hell they don't even make me scummy. Your first couple of points against me basically amount to, he did not post enough words which btw is most of your case. To move on when i clarified and what you call as i say you are playing the game isn't what it is at all. As mafia generally the train of thought is more fragmented and you can't really see how person got to point a o point b, you can somewhat see it and to me i looks like you are critically thinking about what you are doing. I'm no sure what it has to do that I stop talking about someone who is a town read when they aren't going to be lynched at that moment, this whole part doesn't make sense to me. I move from someone I think is own o someone who I think is pretty scummy. I'm not exactly sure what you are getting at with your last part, I wanted to make a case on sl I was unable to do so and when I was able to do so I did so. Its only an EXCUSE when you can't deliver on a promise, and not sure wha tyou mean about not doing things even though i'm around.... How do you know when i'm here or when i'm not.I was here after my case but the only people in the thread were ff who was on my scum read and Hopeless there really wasn't much to do at that point. Overall i'm not exactly sure what you are doing here, it doesn't quite feel like a scum read and the conclusion feels like is missing... | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i59.tinypic.com/2432agi.png) | ||
| ||
