Well I'm on risk.nuke rn, but I'm up for Circumstance as well. jrkirby I'm a litte wary about cause there are certain actions I don't understand he would do as scum,

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 03 2014 02:47 GMT

#1543

How bad am I going to look if Tolkien flips scum

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 03 2014 02:53 GMT

#1557

inb4 cleric is mafia rip

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 03 2014 02:59 GMT

#1570

zzzz I guess to prevent any shennigans that could happen...
Unvote all
Vote: Lord Tolkien
Vote: Lord Tolkien
Vote: Lord Tolkien
Vote: Lord Tolkien

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 03 2014 03:15 GMT

#1588

No one followed me onto risk.nuke which suspects that risk is also mafia.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 03 2014 04:10 GMT

#1626

The votes on me are me btw. Came with my power. Also anyone know what a homing chicken does. And I spotted Circumstance in the Blizzcon World Champions LR Thread in Liquidhearth btw.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 04 2014 03:19 GMT

#1814

##Send ObiWanShinobi to OBLIVION!

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 04 2014 03:51 GMT

#1857

Why Tirion good again?

On November 04 2014 12:21 ObiWanShinobi wrote:

Show nested quote +

Hm.

Did you ever follow up on that scumread you had on me earlier? You posted about how I was defensive and that's about it.

I think jaybrundage is more town than you.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 04 2014 04:59 GMT

#1952

On November 04 2014 13:40 Seuss wrote:

Show nested quote +

Just saying the role fishing going on here is pretty ridiculous.

lol fishing with Pagle

mmmm I wish Circumstance would spend some time in this thread instead of the Blizzcon HS LR Thread

I want to lynch risk.nuke, but want to see if I can figure out why Tolkien put his vote on risk.nuke (if bussing is reasonable).

Sorry, need to do work, gn.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 04 2014 19:53 GMT

#2101

On November 04 2014 21:30 jrkirby wrote:
He's been active, making reasonable reads, scumhunting, calling people on the shit i'd expect him to, not been doing suspicious things... pretty much everything opposite of you.

What's your opinion on the jay/obs oblivion shenanigans?

Did you lose your vote?

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 04 2014 20:14 GMT

#2103

HF, is it mod confirmed that your buddy is also town? And I guess vice versa.

@ my 4 votes on risk.nuke I'm surprised that no one hopped on with me to the wagon I was on. Instead Tolkien thought he would have a better chance on Circumstance. So mafia obviously didn't find it better to put votes on risk.nuke. Maybe they didn't want to give themselves away or maybe it's cause risk.nuke is also mafia, or both. Not sure which is more likely.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 05 2014 23:48 GMT

#2362

I think that jaybrundage vs ows is town vs town based on day 2's posting (I guess along with several other people). I'm going to keep my vote on ows though as I was getting town vibes from him throughout day 1.

I honestly don't think risk is trying at all to stay alive. The thing about the wagon forming quickly with no opposition I do not think indicates that risk is mafia because I think mafia would prefer to stay in the shadows, especially since risk was on several people's scum reads, and it was probably likely that risk would die.

##Vote: risk.nuke

HF vs VE thing: I avoid talking about these two since I'm honestly intimidated lol - I think HF is town. I guess I have a town read of VE since he gave me a chicken lol.

I would have thought Circumstance's mafia friends would have told him to start posting again by now, though I guess he's not really under fire.

Also, doesn't seem like jrkirby lost his vote. Either mods messed up or Damdred was lying about losing votes.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 06 2014 02:11 GMT

#2431

Good thing I came back I guess. Was hoping for a more comfortable lynch target though.

VE, you should be more certain about your reads. You gave me a chicken for a reason.

On November 06 2014 08:52 Damdred wrote:

Show nested quote +

Talk more about this if you will, So you had town vibes from ows day 1?

Also talk mroe about the second bolded section, it doesn't add up going towards your vote. Why are you scum reading risk again?

I'm not lying yo

Mistyped - meant town vibes from jaybrundage. Obviously, my sentence wouldn't make sense if I kept my vote on ows if I had town vibes from him day 1 xD
On risk.nuke, these points have been brought up lots of times: he didn't really contribute to day 1, he seems to be reading but not really trying to contribute - seems indifferent about everything. I don't understand your argument about "doesn't add up going towards your vote". I posted about this during the night, but I think that there is a possibility that risk is mafia as well, and that is why mafia didn't follow the wagon I tried to start. Things today is the same thing. Also, pretty sure he's good enough to read me as town, but is not - which also indicates he's just going for a mislynch.

btw, anyone who thinks I'm a lurker needs to remember that people have real life stuff. I've been trying to actively participate in this thread. I said I would be back the end of day 1 and I showed up because I knew I had time then. I'll stay on for the rest of this night as well since I'm procrastinating anyways lol.

Reads:
+ Show Spoiler +

1) ObiWanShinobi - slight town
2) Lord Tolkien as Valeera Sanguinar, lynched day one
3) Misder - town
4) ritoky - town
5) risk.nuke - mafia
6) jrkirby - leaning towards bad town, could be mafia
7) Seuss - town
8) VisceraEyes - town, off chance 3p
9) GlowingBear as Kel'Thuzad, killed night one
10) Oatsmaster - don't actually have a read on him, maybe I should lol
11) Alakaslam - town
12) Blazinghand as Thrall, killed night one
13) Damdred - slight town
14) liancourt - slight town
15) Circumstance - mafia, not enough to read
16) Holyflare - town
17) jaybrundage - town

Trying to get people to switch off Tolkien because I genuinely thought we were mislynching and Tolkien trying. Also didn't want to kill a claimed medic - if he doesn't die night 1, he can be the next lynch target day 2. I thought risk.nuke was a better target.

btw - if you guys paid attention, you can see that I no longer have my 4 vote power (there is not an extra vote on me after voting for risk.nuke). It was only a Day 1 power.

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 06 2014 02:33 GMT

#2450

Is it possible to have the rest of the scum members be this inactive :/ I guess it's possible...

Read through Oats's filter, seems like he's town - don't think he's going to try and push another wagon against Tolkien if he's scum. Though Oat's, why didn't you try and push risk.nuke at the end and instead left it on jrkirby until the end?

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 06 2014 02:50 GMT

#2470

On November 06 2014 11:24 Damdred wrote:
Part of it isn't a bad post I hate list posts with no explanations though.

why are you so sure of him oats

Explanations are hard with an hour left

Spare me since I want to post this before day ends...
+ Show Spoiler +

1) ObiWanShinobi - town: don't like his attitude - seems like can't take pressure, though his play day 2 feels much more genuinely town
2) Lord Tolkien as Valeera Sanguinar, lynched day one
3) Misder - town
4) ritoky - town: had town vibes day 1, pretty sure he breadcrumbed being mason with Holyflare
5) risk.nuke - mafia: talked about it already
6) jrkirby - see below
7) Seuss - town: assertive
8) VisceraEyes - slight town, possibility of 3p - I like that he's giving town stuff from his role, I think he's usually much more active though as town, and is wishy washy (biased cause his views on me changed)
9) GlowingBear as Kel'Thuzad, killed night one
10) Oatsmaster - town - just wrote it
11) Alakaslam - town: pretty sure he's been doing stuff - didn't look too carefully, but getting vibes
12) Blazinghand as Thrall, killed night one
13) Damdred - OH SHOOT AS I WAS WRITING THIS I REALIZED SOMETHING - the peacekeeper thing - at the time, Tolkien was set to be lynched. Could be a reason why extending the deadline was necessary in mafia eyes. I initially had town read because I didn't think mafia would need to extend the deadline when town was very unorganized but then that thought popped up. Something to think about.
14) liancourt - town - pretty sure him reading the thread and posting his thoughts as he reads them is not something mafia would do - i think he's been active
15) Circumstance - mafia, not enough info
16) Holyflare - stuck with Tolkien lynch, claims confirmed town, which can be believable, has been actively doing stuff
17) jaybrundage - mmmm town vibes from day 1

Also, if you want to see how bad I am at being mafia, http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/147475-how-to-improve-mafia-xxx-analysis
Even though that was ages ago, I'm pretty sure I would be just as bad

This is also the reason why I have bad feelings about jrkirby, because I feel like I would totally post things like him if I was mafia, though less assertive? Which is why I have him as a bad town read...

Misder

United States1557 Posts

November 06 2014 02:52 GMT

#2472

On November 06 2014 11:35 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

READ THE THREAD MAN.
MY VOTE GOT MANIPULATED.
I ENDED UP ON LT

I know. You were on jrkirby before it got manipulated though. You didn't even try to vote risk.nuke. My question is, why didn't you switch to risk.nuke if you didn't want Tolkien to get lynched? (Your vote ended up on Damdred)