@Wave Yeah, I tried to highlight any mentions of OWB as he's the only confirmed scum.

@Alz Ok, I had trouble following you but I think I got it. There casual and indirect defense of one another would point you to scum in cahoots? Req may have convinced me of his town status (he was my first filter read) so I may have missed that and so put that connection to both town instead of both scum. I think you make a valid point. I rushed Asmo's a little bit (I was very aware of the amount of time I was taking to do this at that point lol) and yeah I missed the pretty frequent offhand mentions that didn't seem noteworthy but I guess that's Mafia :\

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 16:14 GMT

#1959

Ok so everyone else just pick someone and look for stuff on owb is a much better idea.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 17:18 GMT

#1973

On October 18 2014 01:46 Requizen wrote:
Despite the lack of proof, for some reason I find mordek's claim really easy to swallow. I don't know if that's bad or if other people get the same feeling.

It's hard to prove when the guy you poisoned was shot and you used the antidote on him. It was that or use it on someone random and even then, no one is notified I don't think. I can only point to how it's consistent with my votes and reads and once I realized I wasn't going to be able to say "Hey, guys I'm the one who killed Soniv" I went into breadcrumb mode (inspired by jcarl) because I wasn't sure if I needed to shield anyone else.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 18 2014 17:38 GMT

#1995

I think Asmo's the right call here too, good posts from Wave and Alaric. Going to a wedding.

##Vote Asmo

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 19 2014 11:53 GMT

#2058

Well this sucks. I haven't had time to read the big posts in depth. This game is silly.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 19 2014 12:34 GMT

#2059

Ok this is how I see it. We lose alz tonight. I understand suspecting everyone but at this point if Wave is scum... Well he earned it. We need to choose correctly between Ghandi Alaric and Req tomorrow :/ it's lynch or lose, correct?

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 19 2014 13:35 GMT

#2060

Obviously that isn't saying much but I'm going to focus on those three and hopefully have a Wave worthy post this afternoon

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 19 2014 18:34 GMT

#2062

Is it something I did that looks scummy or is it something I'm not doing? I'm not sure why I'm more obvious than req and Ghandi.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 00:01 GMT

#2066

Godspeed and farewell Alz

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 00:08 GMT

#2070

Whoops I skimmed that spoiler and forgot to come back to it Alaric sorry. You're going to be really disappointed when what you thought was scum play was just noob town. I explained why I voted Tolkien from the beginning. He was bing disruptive I felt. I had a feeling on soniv and Ghandi N1. I was going to poison Ghandi but said YOLO let's get soniv since Ghandi is easy d2 lynch. My vote in soniv to start was to make sure others thought he was worth killing. I should have let the poison go and hoped dandel wrote that part in. I don't have a good argument for anyone else. I thought you all were town at some point this game.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 00:09 GMT

#2071

The intrigue the mystery!

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 00:10 GMT

#2072

This an Alz mislynch bait is my first impression.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 16:44 GMT

#2086

Honestly my best read right now is Alaric thinks I'm scum so maybe he's scum? Because I'm town lol. This game is just silly.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 18:41 GMT

#2092

When I read through Asmo's and Req's filter earlier I concluded they were both town but I mean I'm not doing so hot on my calls thus far. The most compelling argument was that it's hard to get caught in some voting slip-up or tell when you just vote for the same person all game. Interestingly enough it was Wave that brought that up, right?

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 20 2014 18:45 GMT

#2094

Which goes to show that the storyline being pitched is sticking in people's minds. Dangerous when those reading aren't putting in the due diligence themselves.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 21 2014 14:15 GMT

#2112

Can someone explain how this plays out in the end game? We have 3 votes on Req and he has the oldest vote so he's getting lynched unless someone comes off and we got 4-2 or more on someone else. Right now Req has resigned himself it seems but I honestly don't think you can read that one way or the other. I'm more wondering on how the votes have played out so far this day. What does scum want to do? Hold off on voting and let a mislynch happen if Town!Req? Bus if Scum!Req? I'm trying to see if anything can be gleaned by voting so far but it doesn't seem there is anything solid.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 21 2014 15:00 GMT

#2115

Ok, I read through Ghandi's filter and I'd say I'm fairly convinced he's town. I feel the need to return the favor to him and mention how atrocious and useless his filter is (

) but yeah, I think there's enough there that just doesn't have scum motivation.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 21 2014 15:28 GMT

#2118

100% huh. That is interesting.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 21 2014 15:30 GMT

#2119

So you think there were only 2 blues or what Alaric? I mean, I thought I'd made the best case I could with the circumstances I had after Soniv died but there's obviously no other blues because I was the third one.