My initial read: That's way too much effort and consistency for this to be from a Scum!Req.
My town list:
Cixah
Soniv
Alzadar
Me
Req

Leaving owb, Asmo, Wave, Alaric. I mean Wave was in my town but I'll have to re-read Req's points.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 15:55 GMT

#1829

Almost editted... and Ghandi!

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 16:00 GMT

#1831

He's been doing a great job of convincing me of town since the lynch-train but he may just be throwing out any line he can think of that makes him seem innocent. I mean he did request to get parity checked. This is getting into WIFOM though right? I'd still keep him in the watch list.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 16:04 GMT

#1833

On October 16 2014 02:31 WaveofShadow wrote:
Like what WAS with all the greenfont shit?
And why does he feel the need to point out the extremely obvious, that there is a bus going on (unless both soniv/Jeff are town and the scum are in the rest of lurk city, or we've been massively fooled by, say, himself or ketchup).

I think a lot of us have actually let Alaric skate by on early towncred without looking into him in a long time.
Either that or the quiet is making me paranoid. I hate being in charge of lynches. Good practice though.

Any thoughts on this post? I feel like the points raised are still pertinent.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 16:15 GMT

#1835

I get that. You probably read through my filter and after digesting it for like 5 minutes it gives you a queasy feeling, sure. I'm going to remedy that

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 18:52 GMT

#1871

I'm town Alaric, I brought up your post because I thought it was worth discussing but I think you got it.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 19:40 GMT

#1885

LYNCH HIM

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 16 2014 19:48 GMT

#1891

Seriously. Also I think I'd prefer 24 hour days, 48 seems like forever. I hate waiting so long to actually get concrete information lol

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 00:42 GMT

#1924

Huh that was weird.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 01:25 GMT

#1927

You are not paying attention if you think I'm not town at this point.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 01:59 GMT

#1932

I have no clue what the right play is here. It's Alaric and Asmo tho

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 02:11 GMT

#1935

Ok it's a numbers game, and I'm basically vanilla at this point so I can't think why not.
Hi I'm your friendly drugstore pharmacist aka the Town Poisoner
I'll inform you that I decided with the delayed kill I needed to act N1. Ghandi and Soniv were my highest scum reads as I've stated multiple times.
So I poisoned Soniv because I figured Jeff was a very likely target D2. We might get a double scum flip :O
Obviously it turns out to be a terrible read. I used my antidote on soniv in the off chance he would live otherwise. I'm posting from my phone but just look at my night posts.
Anyways I figure now is the time to get town consolidated because there's no one left to shield anymore and I've used both vials.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 12:11 GMT

#1948

Alaric that makes me really happy. Probably the most fun I had this game besides hopping on the train of justice.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 12:16 GMT

#1949

If it helps look at my voting D2. I wanted to vote Ghandi but I also wanted to get more people's opinion on Soniv so I started off with a vote on him planning all along to switch to Ghandi or just let that bandwagon continue it's course if enough people were on it. I got plenty of feedback and it seemed for the majority of D2 everyone agreed with my assessment that Soniv and Ghandi were both the best targets. While it wouldn't have mattered, maybe this makes Soniv feel better, if he had just talked us out of lynching him and getting Jeff they would both be dead right now so it could have been worse? Unless Ghandi is kingscum.

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 14:24 GMT

#1952

I picked Req and Asmo as a potential scum pair and I'll be going through their filters this morning afternoon. If others want to pick a pair and do some analysis that would help. Like others have stated, I also need to be doing IRL work :X

mordek

United States12705 Posts

October 17 2014 15:24 GMT

#1954

Ok, hopefully some helpful contribution. I couldn't determine much between the two of them so I'll just post my notes on each and maybe people can comment with their perspective.
Req:
D1 displays some ignorance of game setup and hosting. (possibly because he got VT which he later indirectly claims)
There's also a definite display of frustration from lack of knowledge (could be scum plan but also how I felt)
He did have an early scum read on OWB which is the only confirmed mafia we know yet
He voted Wave (anger?) then LT (same reasons I had for voting LT)
He was against the MB vote, wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt. This would be odd for scum to do unless they felt very sure there was no dissuading the MB train. In my view MB train definitely had a chance of not happening
***Asmo argues with Req on his MB read (Asmo did state MB was in his top 2 at this time)

On October 13 2014 07:35 Requizen wrote:

Show nested quote +

I dunno, I think that was just him trying to spark discussion in his own, crazy, british way. Tryhard (though silly) posts != scum

Req brings up his OWB scum read again
(I missed the filter read on me somehow , you're very generous Req but I appreciate your read on me)
Req's filter check series section on Asmo concludes he's Green
He brings up that Wave had omitted OWB from his list post:

On October 14 2014 05:15 Requizen wrote:

Show nested quote +

You let OWB fall off the radar

Req's notable triad does not include OWB or Asmo but does include the thread's two 2 candidates and Wave (obv)
Req did agree OWB would be a good target for parity check (meaningless as scum would know they can kill Soniv)

Asmo:
Makes VT claim after called out for LURKERCITYSCUMBOYS status
Two initial reads are Alz + MB (one confirmed and one presumably)
Asmo does think Alaric + Req are town (D1 reads but worth noting)
Asmo wants OWB to "die lurker die" (D1 and such an easy accusation to make since that can be rectified by owb activity)
Asmo compliments Alaric's towniness on multiple occasions, comparing others to Alaric
Top 3 reads were all town initially (so were mine lol)
Rides soniv pretty hard D2 but does mention OWB seems scummy.

Concluding thoughts (feelings):
Reading Req's filter gave me strong town vibes. Reading Asmo's gives me mild town vibes, the main reason being a couple mentions of owb when I don't think many had made any strong arguments against owb up to this point. There doesn't seem to be any apparent connection between Req and Asmo.