|
Gonna hold off voting Coma for awhile, it doesn't really trigger any discussion. He's more of a fallback if nobody gains traction.
Asmo been super lurking as well, he says he's going to post something soon-ish tho so I'm holding off there too.
Alzadar really shaped up his posting recently, I think he's trying to prod people into talking. If anything he's being almost too guarded in his questions to people. Maybe to keep suspicion off of him? Will watch that. As of right now hes town to me though.
Cixah is clearly guilty. No other possible conclusion.
Also OWB is really escaping a lot of notice here. Clearly hes just more lurky than Coma. But seriously, that's suspect as well.
Req says town to me from his posts, I dont see anything sinister, just struggling to adjust to the game at the beginning (I can relate).
Wave, I think you're completely wrong, and your arguments make little sense (or just none at all), but I think you have good points said in your defense, and that's enough to put you right around where Soniv is on my scumscale.
Asmo is still my #1 suspect because of the shittypost-bandwagon-lurker combination, but again, he says he's gonna post soon, so I'll give him some breathing room.
Alaric and Ketchup are pretty clearly town to me. They have long, thoughtful posts that, while not always correct or well-reasoned, steer us into good discussion and prevents us from tunnel-visioning (except that one crusade Ketchup had about Wave).
Wave also seems really desperate to vehemently defend himself when his livelihood is even slightly threatened. But im still holding off.
|
You're correct, I didn't see that post.
My bad.
|
At the same time, you just spiked a lot more to me in suspicion. I don't wanna seem like I'm deflecting here, but that's a bit of a big leap for just not seeing your post. It sounds from my perspective like you're being dramatic to hide the fact that you're jumping on a bandwagon.
|
Cixah I was being sarcastic.
:F
|
I made reads already today. After that, wave reflex-voted me. We argued awhile. We both finished realizing that nothing else would come of it, so I decided to post my updated reads in case it might spark some discussion towards anything.
|
I'll hold my tongue on this for a few minutes, I think.
|
Wave I really want you to know that you keep making the mistake of
Not as interested as you = disinterested
I think that goes for everyone you described there.
|
I'm not saying that as a reflection on your guilt or innocence, I'm just saying its unfair as a metric.
|
I see Wave and Soniv as sort of opposites right now. They represent two schools of suspicion for me, and that means I don't think both of them are scum or town. I could also see Asmo or Req as scum, but I couldn't see Asmo as scum with Soniv. Wave and Req as both scum would mean that their exchanges were the results of deep coordination, which I don't buy from a first-time Requizen.
Right now my suspicion is leaning less off of Wave.
Also, upon thinking more, I'm pretty confident Req is innocent. I can't see him being Mafia with either Soniv nor Wave right now, and I think one of those two is scum.
|
AKA I want to vote Soniv right now, but something is holding me back.
|
Is there a limit on the amount of times a 3p can attack? This is the case in similar games I've played, so I'm curious.
Spoiler I'm not 3P
|
You really think Ketchup is on the scum list?
You have high appraisal of his abilities.
|
I wonder why you're choosing to push so late in the game Coma? Did you find an opening, or just what you think is an easy, safe target?
|
He's not stepping up at all. He hasn't provided much of anything other than a vote he knows will keep certain people off his back. "I think the suspicious guy is suspicious."
I don't think this makes him scum, but he needs to work more for that.
|
I think, in terms of hours, it is pretty late. He only really actually started talking as soon as Soniv began a bandwagon against him.
|
And since the safest thing was to vote for Coma, and he's Coma, he voted for me instead, the next safest thing. People aren't going to question any reads on me very deeply at all. Additionally he didn't really add anything that hadn't been said about me yet. I feel like he's using my infamy for his safety.
|
Why does this always happen whenever I get home
U make me look bad when anti-timing occurs
|
Gimme a few minutes like last time since i just got home. Gotta take care of my doggie.
If you dont believe me, you can check yesterday's posts, this is right around when i got home yesterday.
|
Its 4:30. I get out of school~ 3, busride home is a little over 80 minutes typically.
I was following the Wave-Soniv thing with a lot of interest, and Soniv is still my #1 most wanted. Right now, he's the only lynch other than me (but I'm innocent, I'm afraid) that tells us a lot. Req is contested too, but I really think he's just being a shitty player. He either comes up shitty town or genius mafia, but we wouldn't be a lot closer because he has no real connects or disconnects with anyone. Interestingly enough, one of the people he hasn't really gone after is me, so if he flipped red I'd be looking pretty guily. But that's not likely in my eyes.
We learn nothing from Coma, end of story. He has no connections. If he's town, people might start blaming me, but beyond that it's basically a dead end really only meant to flush out lurkers rather than hunt down mafia.
Soniv, on the other hand, has had a few important relationships with a lot of people, and I don't need to go into it since Ketchup described my feelings in a post yesterday ('bout those yung pockets). It confirms what I believe in that Wave and Ketchup are both town (Req that ketchup vote was just straight stupid). Just to clarify, I definitely think that Wave is town, but banking too hard on the "kill useless town" memo.
I want to note that even if I get lynched, when I flip green we learn essentially very little. Wave is exonerated, cool. Ketchup is too. We already knew that. Beyond that though, nearly everyone has flipped onto voting for me at some point, and it's really hard to look through that to see who is doing it for cover and who isn't. It should be important to note that one of the scum has almost definitely tried to bandwagon onto me at some point.
Alzadar has had a lot of shifty posting, and very little tangible contribution, but somehow gets to avoid things whenever his name comes up. This is really interesting to me, and I'm going to look into who keeps steering the conversation away from him. It's the same for Asmo for me. If there's a pattern there, we might have something. Then again, the same could be said about Ketchup and I, but he's almost certainly town, so it's not foolproof.
Mordek has had NOTHING done, I think it's interesting that he's not enemy lurker #1 right now. All he did recently is hop onto the Ghandi bandwagon, something that has very little value.
I still think Soniv right now as #1 scum, or at least best possible lynch at the moment. He says a lot, but in reality he never really does much when he points fingers. He tends to separate those posts. Also, he's doing the pretend rage thing that I called him out for earlier. That's scummy. Or, at the very least, it's fishy.
And for god's sake if you really want to look at the most useless town it is by far cixah. He doesn't post, and he's never going to act as a shield and die during the nighttime. He's guaranteed to live until the end of the game and he knows it, so he hasn't been posting. I cant ask to lynch him instead of a likely scum like Soniv, but dude we need you to be contributing.
Also interesting how so little blue impact was felt or discussed after the first night. Is someone maybe keeping quiet about being roleblocked as a 3P, explaining the one death? Would be worth looking into.
|
On October 15 2014 08:38 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On October 15 2014 08:21 GhandiEAGLE wrote:
Why does this always happen whenever I get home
U make me look bad when anti-timing occurs LOL This is too fucking hilarious. You get a chance though because I've noticed what time you post and it has been around now. What I don't excuse is your posting all day in OT and avoiding this thread mostly.
It's much easier to do throwaway cancer posts during class in OT than it is to do a full response in a thread where I'm a main suspect and need to be more paced with what I say. I'm able to read the thread though, so I have been following the discourse throughout the day.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
