I don't believe he can be on a scumteam with kush. I don't believe he can be on a scumteam with you. It's also unlikely for him to be on a scumteam with slam.

No matter how strong of a scumread I have on sqrt, if I can't put him on a scumteam,

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 17 2014 23:22 GMT

#1678

Forget sqrt, I'm not voting him today.

We should lynch kush instead. There's not much more I can add that hasn't already been said. If you need to convince yourself that kush is scummy, just look at his filter, it's all there. We need to lynch kush because mafia shot rayn. Day 2 was lynch whoever rayn wants to lynch day. If rayn survived, this day would be another day of lynch whoever rayn wants to lynch day, and that means kush. I doubt there is any way someone here could influence rayn otherwise. If kush is town, then mafia just killed the wrong person. They would have literally won the game just shooting hopeless and let town sheep rayn into a kush mislynch. This is not something I expect the mafia team to WIFOM.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 17 2014 23:30 GMT

#1680

On October 18 2014 08:25 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

I mean

1) Why it is unlikely that he is partner with each of those guys?
2) So you're basically saying that you have being scumreading him since the beginning of the game, that he is your top scumread at the moment, but you're not voting him because you're making unflipped associations.

You're basically claiming scum if he flips mafia

Yes, I'm making unflipped associations. Given that it's mylo, why aren't you?

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 18 2014 00:32 GMT

#1687

It's 5v3, so it's mylo. A no-lynch means that it will be 4v3 tomorrow, granting us an extra day and flip. Theoretically, a no-lynch would have some benefits and have some drawbacks. If someone like VE suggested it, it would be okay, but sqrt suggesting it is super scummy, given that he isn't even making use of the time we have. I think sqrt is just baiting people to townread him.

Ugh... there is literally nothing I can do to read sqrt as town, yet the game doesn't make sense if he is.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 18 2014 00:48 GMT

#1690

We are definitely not going to no-lynch

I'm sticking with kush. This is what I'm at right now. Sqrt can either be mafia, or the scummiest town who ever lived. Kush can either be mafia with scumteam A or scumteam B. They can even both be mafia. Whether or not I want to lynch sqrt, I would like kush to be first.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 18 2014 00:48 GMT

#1691

and if kush flips town, I partially blame rayn.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 18 2014 01:05 GMT

#1694

We don't exactly have the luxury at this point to vote off the scummiest acting player. We did on day 1 and day 2, but we don't on mylo. We lynch scum, whether it be sqrt or VE. There's a good chance after this game, we're gonna be saying "wow, sqrt played so scummy, can't believe he was town" or "dang, VE played so well, fooled us all". I really think lynching kush is less of a mistake.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 18 2014 01:06 GMT

#1695

Anyways, I want to hear what other people have to say.

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 19 2014 09:18 GMT

#1757

Sorry been busy today, and will be 2mrw as well.

I think we have to vote off sqrt today tbh. Because of everything that has been said, and also he's voting with me on kush when I'm his only scumread.

##unvote
##vote sqrtofneg1

Chairman Ray

United States11903 Posts

October 20 2014 08:01 GMT

#1829

On October 20 2014 16:26 raynpelikoneet wrote:
A question:
Did any of the townies think ve is scum on the final day?

I was suspicious of VE for trying to sub out. He mentioned that he was waiting for a sub, but if that was approved, BH would have posted in the replacement thread, and if it was denied, he wouldn't be waiting anymore. I didn't want to mention it until the next day in case VE got shot in the night, but I had stronger confidence on the sqrt lynch because VE voted kush. So my mistake there.