|
On October 11 2014 05:59 Fecalfeast wrote:Show nested quote +On October 11 2014 05:56 Superbia wrote:
Just wondering how Rad goes from top town to missing and I go from leaning town to pure scum. Rad did work early on, then went missing from the thread for a while and did much less work in his later posts causing me not to think of him at the time of my panic post. Reads change, obviously yours has when you said I was leaning town.
And it was purely based on me being gone during the night, right? At least at the point during which you gave your list.
|
You added me to scum at EoN1 to bring me back the the thread?
|
|
|
On October 11 2014 06:26 Fecalfeast wrote:
You're taking another random specific from my post and questioning it. I'll answer only because it seems nobody else is around.
I said the word "might" putting you in the scum list also might get you to go crazy over being scumread. You're reinforcing my read with every post you make but at the TIME OF POSTING yes, I put you in the scum column to see how you would react to being put in the scum column, along with the fact that you did not post hardly at all during the night.
Two things going through my head:
1. You have the biggest filter
2. I tried to find the post but I couldn't but from last game someone important (blazinghand I think?) said "The two people arguing are probably town, look to the people watching" in more or fewer words.
If you have a real reason to think I'm scum, vote me. If not, I'm not going to argue over my panic list anymore.
[/QUOTE]
So let me get this perfectly straight FF:
- It's almost EoN1.
- You want to make a quick list because you think you're going to die (this is your mindset during the post).
- You put me on the scum list because YOU WANT A REACTION?.
How does this make sense when you think it's possible you're about to die? It only makes sense if you think you're going to be alive to follow up the next day.
|
Bresh let's talk. You're reading elvis as scum?
|
Explain to me real quick why he definitely is scum here. Just give a quick rundown of your arguments.
|
That's actually a pretty decent case (the very first part).
Prob 1 scum on zen wagon 1 scum outside if that's what you're asking. That's the most likely set up.
|
Why are you voting for FF?
|
On October 11 2014 08:15 Rad wrote:Patiently awaiting your response to my questions.
I'm not voting for FF because I'm not sure on him being scum yet.
Abuse's comment looked like he was trying to make friends (again). Can be done by either alignment.
On October 11 2014 08:15 Rad wrote:The fact that you asked me that question makes me doubt my own read on you.
Asking relevant questions makes you doubt your own reads? Well that sucks for you then. I'm not going to stop asking questions. You shouldn't be sure about me anyway.
On October 11 2014 08:07 Superbia wrote:
Why are you voting for FF?
|
In fact, rad. Why the fuck did that make you doubt your read on me?
|
Whatever man. You make a post that ends up in some random vote that doesn't have anything to do with the post. That confuses the fuck out of me.
I'll wait and see what FF cooks up with his reads.
|
Rad, what are you thinking?
|
I'm off. Lynching scum tomorrow.
|
Abuse confirmed worst player ever. I've demonstrated before that I'm fine with sitting back. I'm not going to "do something" if I'm still iffy myself on who's mafia.
Your list also does not add up. How do you push scum on rad but then null him with "(coinflip with a bigger chance of being town)".
|
Heads up btw. I think Rad is scum here. Read his filter and tell me what he wanted to achieve during d1 or d2.
|
|
|
Abuse are you still around or what?
|
On October 11 2014 23:06 abuse wrote:
i didnt push rad as scum.
I said that post was scummy.
im going to need more than "i think rad is scum here, read his filter" to persuade me that he is scum in this game.
It's a short filter. He asks questions but never reaches any conclusions. His pushes are super weak (i.e. ##FoS) at best, and non-existent at worst. Today he shows up with some random ass post and then disappears. We had to explicitly ask him for a list at EoD1 because we had no idea where he stood. I have no idea where he stands or what he wants to do this game. I don't think he's scum hunting, I think he's scum.
|
On October 11 2014 23:07 abuse wrote:Show nested quote +On October 11 2014 22:18 Superbia wrote:
Abuse confirmed worst player ever. I've demonstrated before that I'm fine with sitting back. I'm not going to "do something" if I'm still iffy myself on who's mafia.
ok. Then start finding scum as you said you would do so many times already instead of just pointing a finger at rad and saying that he is scum. Until you do that, my vote stays here.
"Hey start finding scum instead of finding scum". I poured all my energy into a good tunnel D1 and it got us a misslynch. I also haven't caught anyone "slipping" or whatever. My read on Rad envelops pretty much all his posts.
|
On October 11 2014 23:23 abuse wrote:Show nested quote +On October 11 2014 23:09 Superbia wrote:On October 11 2014 23:06 abuse wrote:
i didnt push rad as scum.
I said that post was scummy.
im going to need more than "i think rad is scum here, read his filter" to persuade me that he is scum in this game. It's a short filter. He asks questions but never reaches any conclusions. His pushes are super weak (i.e. ##FoS) at best, and non-existent at worst. Today he shows up with some random ass post and then disappears. We had to explicitly ask him for a list at EoD1 because we had no idea where he stood. I have no idea where he stands or what he wants to do this game. I don't think he's scum hunting, I think he's scum. Many people do that and he did not FoS anyone after D1. Many people have pretty much disappeared today as you can see its just you and me here now. We had to ask him for a list at EoD, but we had to ask EVERYONE for a list at EoD and he was one of the first people to supply it even though at the very start of the game he said he hates lists. What do you REALLY think about breshke and why did you question him in such a friendly matter today and say "that is a pretty nice case you present" when let's face it - it wasn't really. Why are you doing this if you read him as scum aswell at the end of D1? Do you really think there is not enough evidence against him at this point? Do you honestly think he is not scummier than Rad now? What about loaf? Why do you not try to figure out if he is town or scum? What do you think about Elvis? Do you think that his mentioning zen was town before he flipped was a scumslip by him or not? Don't you dare tell me you do not have an opinion on that.
Look, the real fucking questions inside my head are:
- What did Rad do during D1?
- What did Rad do during D2?
I didn't get any vibes that he was looking to find any scum whatsoever. That's my read on him.
Breshke is too easy of a target. We both have played with him, do you have a good read on his town or mafia play? Because I certainly don't. If you have a decent case on him and want to lynch him: Fair enough, show me.
I'm not going to elaborate on loaf. If you want to lynch me for that, go ahead.
Elvis is my secondary lynch option here. He only seems to care about Breshke, and his play from d1 seems to be setting up a lynch on Breshke, after it became obvious that Zen would be the lynch. Could very well be mafia going after low hanging fruit. Assuming Zen was town before he flipped could very well be a slip, and it read scummy to me. He elaborated on it soon after, but I'm not really convinced.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
