|
On September 19 2014 03:50 Holyflare wrote:
also ray town reading geript super fucking suspicious based on his one game read compared to numerous people giving him their own meta reads based on loads of games played
you guys are probably right then. I don't see how it's suspicious though. I played one game where rayn was mafia, so I'm basing my read off that. If I played more with scum rayn, I would have more to go off of.
|
On September 19 2014 04:56 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2014 04:43 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 19 2014 03:50 Holyflare wrote:
also ray town reading geript super fucking suspicious based on his one game read compared to numerous people giving him their own meta reads based on loads of games played you guys are probably right then. I don't see how it's suspicious though. I played one game where rayn was mafia, so I'm basing my read off that. If I played more with scum rayn, I would have more to go off of. right so you're using your one game meta read to supersede people's million games meta, why was that??
I'm not superseding anyone. When people give a meta read that this game rayn's acting like his scum meta, that doesn't exactly help me because they can be referring to anything. That's why I brought up this one specific example from one specific game. It doesn't fit his scum meta in that one case and that's worth exploring. Robik posted a nice counterexample game, which I'm grateful of and I'll look more into later.
|
|
|
I reviewed the past games of rayn, and I'm a little more okay with the lynch on geript. I was mistaken on my read of how rayn is too passionate and angry that palmer was not being lynched over kush. In previous games, it seems that rayn gets really frustrated when people don't agree with his logic. It's not as much that rayn really cares who gets lynched over who. I was mistaken on that point. I'm not sure if this current game is his mafia game, since he does this kind of thing as both town and mafia, but the case on geript right now is quite strong. I'd be okay with lynching geript.
|
Palmer hasn't posted much today, but I kinda like his posts. He seems a little less scummy to me. Unlike the kush lynch, Palmer says he'll be reading into geript, and he also brought OWS onto the table. I'd give him another day to uphold his promise to wreck mafia.
|
Superbia has stepped up a bit, becoming more active, aggressive, and actually paying attention to things that happen in the thread. I wouldn't townread him quite yet since right before this we criticized him for doing the exact opposite. I'd like to see how he plays on day 3.
He raises an interesting point with this:
On September 19 2014 10:57 Superbia wrote:
Moving on to BloodyC0bbler. ... You were pretty adamant about lynching Palmar d1, yet he completely disappeared off your scum list during d2. What's up with this?
|
I'm voting geript for now. I'll try to pop in tomorrow to see if anything changes.
|
Actually Superbia's case on BC is actually quite sound. BC's first day was mostly spent on pushing Palmer. His reads can be summarized in:
On September 16 2014 05:39 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On September 16 2014 05:25 justanothertownie wrote:On September 16 2014 05:21 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
#vote Palmar
Basically just claimed mafia in thread, good enough for me. How? as town he "tries" or at least puts forth some effort as mafia he gg's out and dota's Note this is all from my own experience with him
On September 17 2014 06:08 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
Again, this is a fucking mafia claim -_-
Jesus fuck, this game is insane.
So far Palmar has claimed mafia outright IMO 2 fucking times. Hes not being killed. (im still on page 96ish and palmar filtering)
None of this has changed, yet BC has completely abandoned Palmer on day 2. There's still the possibility that BC ignored Palmer because he didn't want to repeat his previous reads, but to not push your scumread is weird, I dunno.
|
Actually, I wanna lynch BC. And if BC flips mafia, we should look into Superbia.
All of Superbia's other reads were quite general and I get the impression that he's only skimming over people. His read on BC was quite specific. So either he's town and he spends most of his time investigating one person, and still decides to post a tidbit on other people, or he's mafia bussing. It's far easier for a mafia to catch a teammate's blunder than a town to.
I think the latter is more likely since Superbia seems a little too sure on BC. Anyways, I don't know why I'm blabbing on under the assumption that BC will flip scum, so I'll be quiet now.
But yeah, I would also lynch BC tomorrow.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sorry, been busy with stuff and not being useful in mafia. Caught up now. Would lynch Holyflare, LT, or ShiaoPi. Leaning scum on Superbia, Glowing Bear, and Storrzerg. I think we got our 5 mafia within that group. I'll be on before EOD to catch up again and vote, but if not, I'll just sheep poofter. Sorry for being useless today.
|
Back, sorry was away on weekend.
I've skimmed through the thread.
What's the case on hopeless? I might have missed it.
|
Okay, I'm gonna dig his filter then
|
Wait, there is no alternative wagon?
|
My activity will be super sparse right now because I'm at work, but I'll be active tonight. But this is what I wanna do:
1. Don't lynch me, I'm town
2. Push a wagon onto ShiaoPi. The case batsnacks posted on him is pretty solid. I can see little reason why ShiaoPi would be so demotivated due to more recent happenings in the game, when he put in very little effort from the very start. Doesn't make sense. Also, instead of going to do something else like a demotivated person should, he stuck around and kept saying that he's demotivated and won't help whenever someone brought it up. That also doesn't make sense. He would be my #1 lynch today
3. I'm okay with the hopeless lynch because he hasn't contributed at all after day 1. Yes, I'm being a hypocrite here.
4. Ideally I would like a flexible wagon between ShiaoPi and Hopeless. If one of them comes on last minute and turns out he's the JK or something, it might be better to lynch the other. Don't make me the backup wagon because I'm town.
|
Fine, I'll vote hopeless then
|
Superbia, I'm town. DHJSGPKSDHGSG
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
