EPTOn September 07 2014 02:04 kitaman27 wrote:
Damdred, its 115 hours into the game and you haven't given a read about batsnacks. Why not?
Damdred, its 115 hours into the game and you haven't given a read about batsnacks. Why not?
On September 03 2014 11:38 Damdred wrote:
I'll answer the second question first.
Currently, I am nervous about Micchan. He made his initial post (which i pointed out also), that complains about the thread atmosphere which honestly was not bad at the time of his post. I think we were still in setup talk and were startin to move towards actual talk. He did not stay in the thread and help improve the conversation or even say what the mess was. On his return his posts were an excuse and throwing more suspicion onto 3d with no follow up. He has since lurked obviously. This is worrisome to me, but it is not enough for a scum read currently I think. We still have a good many hours left to search for scum and their is just not much to go on in his filter, theres no real meta case to be made as he is a newb or a smurf. And well I really do not like going for low hanging fruit.
The people who I would like to see more out of right now are:
Batsnacks: His entrance to the thread was weird. On his re-entrance he ignored a lot of things that were posted against him, he never even showed interest in answering anything. His posts are really formulaic, right now they are reminding me of Neat and Tidy mafia instead of crazy bats in Cell or Titanic. Also usually hes really spammy, but his postings have been really hit and miss and even though he spared a lot of thoughts to 3d, his only reaction is that an apologetic tone is not scummy. But their are other things in 3ds posts that he could talk about and he does not really draw conclusions from that.
Bunnies: Bunnies is a bit odd to me, a lot of her early filter is a lot of trolling with fluff thrown in. Suddenly she town reads templar and poof and gives little reason for it. Even goes far enough to meta read poof and giving him a town pass for not very good reasons. This is the worrying part to me, Bunnies talks about shooting people over gut feelings and saying that Bats is a third party (hypothetically). Has not returned to the thread yet and responded to why she would want to direct vig at this point to make a kill and push us towards lylo over nothing.
Micchan for the reasons listed above
3D i'm not really sure about yet, he seems awkward which is not alignment indicative but he at least gives his views in the thread and then tries toe xplain himself. So more of a I want to see more of his thoughts.
I'll answer the second question first.
Currently, I am nervous about Micchan. He made his initial post (which i pointed out also), that complains about the thread atmosphere which honestly was not bad at the time of his post. I think we were still in setup talk and were startin to move towards actual talk. He did not stay in the thread and help improve the conversation or even say what the mess was. On his return his posts were an excuse and throwing more suspicion onto 3d with no follow up. He has since lurked obviously. This is worrisome to me, but it is not enough for a scum read currently I think. We still have a good many hours left to search for scum and their is just not much to go on in his filter, theres no real meta case to be made as he is a newb or a smurf. And well I really do not like going for low hanging fruit.
The people who I would like to see more out of right now are:
Batsnacks: His entrance to the thread was weird. On his re-entrance he ignored a lot of things that were posted against him, he never even showed interest in answering anything. His posts are really formulaic, right now they are reminding me of Neat and Tidy mafia instead of crazy bats in Cell or Titanic. Also usually hes really spammy, but his postings have been really hit and miss and even though he spared a lot of thoughts to 3d, his only reaction is that an apologetic tone is not scummy. But their are other things in 3ds posts that he could talk about and he does not really draw conclusions from that.
Bunnies: Bunnies is a bit odd to me, a lot of her early filter is a lot of trolling with fluff thrown in. Suddenly she town reads templar and poof and gives little reason for it. Even goes far enough to meta read poof and giving him a town pass for not very good reasons. This is the worrying part to me, Bunnies talks about shooting people over gut feelings and saying that Bats is a third party (hypothetically). Has not returned to the thread yet and responded to why she would want to direct vig at this point to make a kill and push us towards lylo over nothing.
Micchan for the reasons listed above
3D i'm not really sure about yet, he seems awkward which is not alignment indicative but he at least gives his views in the thread and then tries toe xplain himself. So more of a I want to see more of his thoughts.
On September 03 2014 11:59 Damdred wrote:
i'll start at the bottom and work my way up
In N&T where his posts were the most formulaic he was mafia. In Titanic and Cell he ws a bit more irrational and hopped about, but he never avoided questions he met everything head on and faught everyone who really wanted to scum read him. He ignored all of that here like he sorta did in N&T.
I have some town leans currently
Well, I mean hes a bit awkward in his posts in that he needs follow up to clarify what he means and the idea behind it. And he draws a lot of attention because of it. I'm worried about him mainly because I do not know his play style and can not look it up. So i'd like to see a bit more to give me a bit more of a concrete read.
Well theres still plenty of time to find a good lynch for today. Especially since this is not an instant majority, we have time to mull our options so no my vote is precious to me and I'll give it out when I think that they are mafia. So quit with the bad pressure to vote him right now.
i'll start at the bottom and work my way up
In N&T where his posts were the most formulaic he was mafia. In Titanic and Cell he ws a bit more irrational and hopped about, but he never avoided questions he met everything head on and faught everyone who really wanted to scum read him. He ignored all of that here like he sorta did in N&T.
I have some town leans currently
Well, I mean hes a bit awkward in his posts in that he needs follow up to clarify what he means and the idea behind it. And he draws a lot of attention because of it. I'm worried about him mainly because I do not know his play style and can not look it up. So i'd like to see a bit more to give me a bit more of a concrete read.
Well theres still plenty of time to find a good lynch for today. Especially since this is not an instant majority, we have time to mull our options so no my vote is precious to me and I'll give it out when I think that they are mafia. So quit with the bad pressure to vote him right now.
QUOTE]On September 06 2014 03:17 Damdred wrote:
Right now i'm suffering a bit from OMGUS and my reads are being colored right now,
Vivax: Hes seemed to tunnel pretty much every person he has went after this game. Templar, he said was scummy, bats he said was worth another look. But his vote ended up on someone he said was a plynch and then he peace'd out and went to sleep. He never reallye ven tried to get a wagon going on d1 and he jumped on a plynch As day two draws near he hears Oats wants to lynch people who over explained their votes. Vivax never looks back at the votes really. He jumps on me because of what he says is an over explained vote, but he never pressures the other people on the train who had contradictions in previous statements and where they ended up. He also gives no room for evolution of reads, or gives context for posts, he just looks for things that could be scummy and links them together.
3D: I just keep going back to those last posts he made in D1 and they just look bad. He has a lot of scum reads, and then says its scummy to jump on the hot lynch wagon after lurking but he does the same thing. He does say whatever he is thinking it seems like in d2 but his D1 to me was really scummy and his case on bats fullfilling some mission today is weird to me.
Getting concerened about a couple other people now, I still have bats as scum but the case on him hasn't changed much. Hes really formal and is try hard and formulaic in his posts which look a lot like N&T and Storm 2, even his night 2 postings where he was getting people riled up it fits into his scum meta.
[/QUOTE]
Though a current read i'm not as confident as batscum
if you say so, and yes I voted myself easy indeed.
