|
On September 01 2014 07:20 Amiko wrote:
@bunnies: Your D1 posts indicate that you were scumreading ritoky. I haven't checked all the pages, but I don't think anyone else was really scumreading him. When you later said you felt he was more town, what did he do to make you feel that way?
He was becoming more active and trying to actually figure out the game.
TBH- I'm worried that he started doing that because I called him out on it.
I wasn't really here much of day 1 so I couldn't pressure him the way I wanted to for it. No one else was reading him scummy, so on top of my "Let's sheep Marv here" I thought maybe my read on ritoky was just bad and that I needed to switch my read on him.
|
Ninjabunnies votes
On September 01 2014 00:24 27ninjabunnies wrote:
3. Amiko, if you think BH was scum, how am I scum with him when I voted him?
Ninjabunnies votes twice on D2 - once on Ritoky, once on Blazinghand.
When ninjabunnies voted blazinghand, the vote count became:
batsnacks (6): Oatsmaster, Blazinghand, WaveofShadow, Not really holyflare, Professor Apathy, Amiko
Blazinghand (5): batsnacks, marvellosity, Holyflare, your mom, 27ninjabunnies
Ritoky (0): 27ninjabunnies
(I counted those myself so if I got it wrong let me know)
If Blazinghand is mafia, which feels more likely to me than ritoky, I think this does help a case for ninjabunnies as town because the votes were close when she would have voted for a mafia ally (3 votes outstanding).
Not conclusive of course, but I do think it's a fair point.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On September 01 2014 07:04 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2014 06:42 27ninjabunnies wrote:
Simba.... Wtf.... I thought what we had was special....
Also, because Marv was playing like Marv plays in his town games. Marv has really good reads in his town games. Therefore, sheepable marv.
I thought we went over this HF? have you seen marv play mafia? when you sheeped him it was like RIGHT at the start of the day and he hadn't really done a single thing then
On September 01 2014 07:13 27ninjabunnies wrote:
@Simba, it's cause I love you.
@HF- I'm pretty sure it wasn't at the beginning of the day. My vote was on Ritoky most of day 1. It wasn't until day 2 did I switch to BH.
On September 01 2014 07:18 27ninjabunnies wrote:
HF- I put ritoky as second, yes. And BH as first.
I also said I want to be green on ritoky's spreadsheet.
But I still don't get what that has to do anything?
I was trolling. Everyone does it
marv doesn't look towny at start of day, you sheep marv at start of day
you say you weren't voting bh day 1 as if it meant like you weren't sheeping him when he didn't look towny but that was in fact a lie
|
Oh btw although bunnies was in Golden Sun & Order, I really don't remember those games in a way that's relevant. I know in Order she was low activity toward the end of the game, I just posted the two I remembered better (because I played them) and cell because it's closer to this game and she was mafia there. If they disprove my points or something, bunnies you should let ke know.
|
On September 01 2014 02:18 WaveofShadow wrote:
At some point if anybody who either knows bunnies (or doesn't and wants to look it up) can show me some examples of usual townplay from her that'd be great. Eventually I'll do it myself if no one does.
If you want to look at Order Mafia (town) or Golden Sun (town) for comparison it couldn't hurt otherwise maybe I will later
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
come play voice mafia at the same time
|
On September 01 2014 07:19 MysteryMeat1 wrote:
Amiko, why do you think Prof is town, and what do you think of lilwade?
I'm not all that certain on either one.
Apathy is largely a feeling read. I guess if I try to identify the posts that made me feel good, I'd point to:
(1) Seemed willing to coordinate or compromise on D1 for mayoral votes
(2) Was questioning of bunnies D1, which was someone I felt was suspicious
(3) Provided seemingly thoughtful answers to the positions he took D1
Mafia could do those things, too, but it gives him an edge to me over bunnies (who seems suspicious to me for reasons above and general feel).
For lilwade I'll make another post in a few minutes I have to check his timings
|
On August 28 2014 14:38 lilwade wrote:
Hello, just your fellow town hero nothin to see here.
As for order goes I have no preference being as I have only played with 1 or 2 of you.
Cant believe all the butthurt people at ritokys great posts.
Empathy you are clearly the mafia in our cell.
On August 28 2014 14:39 lilwade wrote:
Somehow I typed empathy must be getting late I meant 27ninjabunnies
On August 28 2014 14:35 lilwade wrote:
##vote: Ritoky
did i seriously get 2 slips in 2 days
|
oh I'm dumb that's mayor, ignore that
|
On lilwade-
Voting
Lilwade votes on BH once in thread, then a second time in the vote thread after I pointed out he didn't vote there.
In either vote, I think it would make the split 8-5 (with Batsnacks leading and Lilwade voting for Blazinghand)
+ Show Spoiler +1) Vote count if he had voted when he posted in thread-http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/463542-cell-mini-mafia-iii?page=62#1235batsnacks (8): Oatsmaster, Blazinghand, WaveofShadow, Not really holyflare, Professor Apathy, Amiko, batsnacks, Holyflare Blazinghand (5): marvellosity, your mom, 27ninjabunnies, damdred, lilwade2) Vote count if he had voted when he posted in the vote threadbatsnacks (8): Oatsmaster, Blazinghand, WaveofShadow, Not really holyflare, Professor Apathy, Amiko, Holyflare, your mom, Blazinghand (5): marvellosity, 27ninjabunnies, damdred, batsnacks, lilwade
Doesn't tell me too much
Activity
In terms of his activity, yeah it's low.
In Newbie LVII he was on his fourth page of filter by the start of Day 2. This game he's still on his first page.
I won't really comment on LVIII since I'm hosting it.
Other stuff
Dude, I don't know. He seems focused on the people in his cell, which feels somewhat towny to me (in the same way focusing on a lynch does).
But it's hard to say he's been actively pushing reads on them or trying to get much from it.
I guess I understand ritoky's point about lilwade coming into the thread as a ballsy move, but honestly I don't see how that's substantially better than not posting at all.
Honestly just not strongly convinced either way. I guess it's more that I recognize some things with bunnies that feel off, Toad feels a little town, lilwade not sure.
|
I gave town points for Apathy voting on lilwade instead of bunnies, but do you think lilwade is an easier mislynch? In a sense there is still 24 hours to go, if he pushes on bunnies who will post for sure, or does he deflect onto lilwade, since he hasn't posted anything?
|
On September 01 2014 07:14 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2014 07:13 27ninjabunnies wrote:
@Simba, it's cause I love you.
@HF- I'm pretty sure it wasn't at the beginning of the day. My vote was on Ritoky most of day 1. It wasn't until day 2 did I switch to BH.
i called you out when you voted ritoky and you said your vote was a lie because you wanted to be coloured green and it was actually meant to be on BH, what bs are you pulling now?
Also, her d1 did discuss finding ritoky scummy even if the vote was suggested as joking
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On September 01 2014 08:28 Amiko wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2014 07:14 Holyflare wrote:On September 01 2014 07:13 27ninjabunnies wrote:
@Simba, it's cause I love you.
@HF- I'm pretty sure it wasn't at the beginning of the day. My vote was on Ritoky most of day 1. It wasn't until day 2 did I switch to BH.
i called you out when you voted ritoky and you said your vote was a lie because you wanted to be coloured green and it was actually meant to be on BH, what bs are you pulling now? Also, her d1 did discuss finding ritoky scummy even if the vote was suggested as joking
yes but apparently that ended up being "wrong" and her vote was a joke
|
The problem is that it was BH himself that said ritoky was town. I was hoping someone still alive would have been the first one to suggest that.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
|
On September 01 2014 09:08 slOosh wrote:Day 3 Vote count:27ninjabunnies (4): Not really holyflare, WaveofShadow, Holyflare, Oatsmaster lilwade (2): : marvellosity, Professor Apathy to vote here.
|
Day 3 Vote count:
27ninjabunnies (5): Not really holyflare, marvellosity, WaveofShadow, Holyflare, Oatsmaster, lilwade
lilwade (2): marvellosity, Professor Apathy
Voice Mafia (0): Artanis, Cephiro, GlowingBear, Holyflare, WaveofShadow, Scip, VisceraEyes, Lord Tolkien
to vote here.
|
that voice mafia vote count LOL
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
|
This day is super easy I had scum read on 27 bunnies like 30 seconds into day 1
And so did apathy...
voting 27ninjabunnies.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
