|
On July 18 2014 16:29 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2014 15:57 gobbledydook wrote:On July 18 2014 15:48 kushm4sta wrote:On July 18 2014 15:09 gobbledydook wrote:
cool, so we have BH cop claim and robik counter claim blue.
Only one of them can be blue, and the other is VT or mafia. I doubt a VT fake counterclaiming because that just doesn't make sense. BH fakeclaiming blue as VT would be counterproductive, because a blue counterclaim would ensure a townie gets lynched, not a good idea.
It's not certain that if BH is blue, that he actually is cop. He may be a non-cop blue pretending to be a cop to throw mafia off. That way, because he is the real blue, he's safe, but mafia are misled as to what town can do.
Case 1: BH is blue, robik mafia
Why would robik counterclaim as mafia? If he was mafia, and he got BH lynched and BH turned blue, then he's next. At the end of day 2 it would be 5-1 which is very town favoured. So I don't think that's likely.
Case 2: BH is mafia, robik blue
We can assume that BH was genuinely concerned that he would get lynched. So if he was mafia, either he gets lynched if he says nothing, or by fakeclaiming at least he has a chance of getting town to mislync-h the actual blue. This might be the case, in which case we lynch BH.
Case 3: BH is VT, robik blue
It's not very possible to tell Case 2 from Case 3. I don't think BH would do something as dumb as VT fakeclaim blue, confusing town more than it confuses mafia. I think this isn't likely.
So I think we lynch BH, as he's not likely to be blue or VT, and more likely a desperate mafia.
##unvote
##vote Blazinghand I really don't like this post. He writes a lot about some very obvious logic. He doesn't really think deeply about the reasons why robik's claim is probably not real. Looks like he just wants to put his vote down somewhere, whereas everyone else is trying to figure shit out. Plus nothing jumps out at me as especially townie in his filter. If I don't elaborate my logic then you say I am being vague and scumread me. I still think on the balance robik is actually blue. You don't like my read that's fine. But who do you think is the real blue? All you've done is snipe from the sidelines without giving reads. Here he starts to OMGUS me. He did the same thing when fuba suspected him in detention mafia.
It's true that you have sniped from the sidelines without giving reads on any of the 4 (fake)claims. You avoid my question. There's no pleasing you, good night.
|
On July 18 2014 16:31 gobbledydook wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2014 16:23 kushm4sta wrote:
so gg, because snickers's read is wrong he's scum? No, it's not only that it's wrong. Being wrong is fine, I'm probably wrong on some of my reads too, this being a 'guessing game of epic proportions'. But it's that he was offering one line posts (no effort), then trying to justify his no effort with a weak argument that therefore I refuted and used as evidence to vote him. Do note that this was in the first half of the first page of his filter. Since then he has contributed more, possibly because of the votes pressuring him. And then he does the weird fake claim shit, I mean wtf? I don't even know what to think of that.
blatant lie. If you leave the thread you are going to look super scummy to me.
|
On July 16 2014 18:52 gobbledydook wrote:
So let's have a recap of what's been said and done:
BH RNGs robik to lynch, obi and me vote him to see what happens.
robik becomes defensive and shouts that this is a bullshit lynch, it would be the first time he got mislynched (or lynched), and insults the people who voted him.
BH thinks robik is really scum after those responses, which sounds like a scum getting randomly caught and raging. The implication being that a real town, secure in his innocence, wouldn't need to defend himself emotionally against what is essentially a nonsense lynch. Whereas a scum instinctively will protect himself strongly as scum are not expendable compared to town.
I agree with that line of reasoning, but I want to confirm, BH, is that what you think too? Do you have anything else to add?
If gobble or obi flip scum REMEMBER THIS POST. WE CANT TALK DURING NIGHT.
|
Yea it's time for you guys to stop voting robik.
Atleast two players have proven they are bad. Sebastian brought up percentages. The percentage of newbie games first lynch mafia is a lot lower than ring.
Anyway gobble is scum, so obvious.
f robik is mafia and his partner is one of the four that voted, this post is the best post in the game. Obi why are you doing scummy stuff.
I retract some of my last statement but Obi unvoted in such a scummy way.
Answering kush. Best as in people people read flipped scum filters and get fooled by them. Aka everyone lets lynch everyone who did not vote robik.
such oneliner much content
the shit in the middle before the post I quoted was buried in a mile of robik spam, tldr, seems to be some accusation of kushmasta that I missed. Sorry.
|
On July 18 2014 16:39 gobbledydook wrote:Show nested quote +Yea it's time for you guys to stop voting robik.
Atleast two players have proven they are bad. Sebastian brought up percentages. The percentage of newbie games first lynch mafia is a lot lower than ring.
Anyway gobble is scum, so obvious. Show nested quote +f robik is mafia and his partner is one of the four that voted, this post is the best post in the game. Obi why are you doing scummy stuff. Show nested quote +Answering kush. Best as in people people read flipped scum filters and get fooled by them. Aka everyone lets lynch everyone who did not vote robik. such oneliner much content the shit in the middle before the post I quoted was buried in a mile of robik spam, tldr, seems to be some accusation of kushmasta that I missed. Sorry.
So in most of that post and it seems like you are trying to prove me wrong. I am thinking to myself, oh maybe he meant i was posting some one liners.
Then you admit that you were wrong. Then apologize. I am puzzled.
|
On July 18 2014 16:42 Snickers wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2014 16:39 gobbledydook wrote:Yea it's time for you guys to stop voting robik.
Atleast two players have proven they are bad. Sebastian brought up percentages. The percentage of newbie games first lynch mafia is a lot lower than ring.
Anyway gobble is scum, so obvious. f robik is mafia and his partner is one of the four that voted, this post is the best post in the game. Obi why are you doing scummy stuff. I retract some of my last statement but Obi unvoted in such a scummy way. Answering kush. Best as in people people read flipped scum filters and get fooled by them. Aka everyone lets lynch everyone who did not vote robik. such oneliner much content the shit in the middle before the post I quoted was buried in a mile of robik spam, tldr, seems to be some accusation of kushmasta that I missed. Sorry. So in most of that post and it seems like you are trying to prove me wrong. I am thinking to myself, oh maybe he meant i was posting some one liners. Then you admit that you were wrong. Then apologize. I am puzzled.
1) When I made the post accusing you I had only noticed your one liners and they didn't sit well with me.
2) When I made the post I just skipped through the robik spam and missed your bigger posts.
3) Sorry for accusing you based on a premise that is false due to my mistake.
|
Idk not reading the whole thread, shows disinterest.  and you voted me but did not read solely my filter .
|
On July 18 2014 16:45 Snickers wrote:Idk not reading the whole thread, shows disinterest. and you voted me but did not read solely my filter .
Sorry new to TL mafia (as you can see I have 1 game here and I got modkilled day 2), I don't use the filter as much as I should, I go with impressions a lot.
|
Gg you accused snickers of no effort after he had that long conversation with me and obi.
|
im willing to vote gg but i refuse to vote until the blue claims stop derping so hard.
i refuse to move any further until the wifom train stops.
|
On July 18 2014 16:56 kushm4sta wrote:
Gg you accused snickers of no effort after he had that long conversation with me and obi.
I said I didn't see that inside the wall of robik spam
|
On July 18 2014 16:58 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
im willing to vote gg but i refuse to vote until the blue claims stop derping so hard.
i refuse to move any further until the wifom train stops.
I feel like you have not moved at all.
|
On July 18 2014 17:01 gobbledydook wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2014 16:56 kushm4sta wrote:
Gg you accused snickers of no effort after he had that long conversation with me and obi. I said I didn't see that inside the wall of robik spam
That was way after the robik spam.
|
On July 18 2014 17:10 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2014 17:01 gobbledydook wrote:On July 18 2014 16:56 kushm4sta wrote:
Gg you accused snickers of no effort after he had that long conversation with me and obi. I said I didn't see that inside the wall of robik spam That was way after the robik spam.
Now that I check his filter again it was on page 13 right at the end of the robik spam, but anyway I didn't read it before and now I did, I retract that accusation
|
GG, im talking about Snickers long conversation he had with me and obi.
The one that ended with this quote, the quote you used in your case against him:
On July 17 2014 13:45 Snickers wrote:If you read closely, I was not even talking about that post. And it is time for me to come clean. Off of the top off my head, I said gg was obv scum to get discussion going. The reason I said him was because I find it most likely for scum to be the third one to jump on. Also I think his reasoning was weak. As for obis unvote, his reasoning was also weak. Now these were mainly to get conversation going so I do not really care if my recalling of details is accurate. And if Robik wants to read me mafia this game like last game I did something similar, well I would not have such a great case on kush without them  .
You are saying you voted him because of lack of effort, but the time at which you voted was right after snickers had a long conversation with me and obi. Clearly you didn't miss that conversation.
|
Kind of sleep deprived but i dont think bh is the lynch for today, and that obi still hasnt posted anything worthwhile. Also bh please rescind your cop claim. I dont want to have to mislynch you as you're one of my top town atm.
|
|
|
I think MM is saying he is the role and hes not taking it back.....
This is hard, i'm pretty sure rob is a fake claim I don't think BH is coming off his claim and neither will MM.....
|
I will shed a tear if mm says he is being serious and bh does not get lynched. For two reasons.
|
Wait, we're not lynching BH?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
