On June 28 2014 00:44 Cavalinho wrote:
Koshi having shitreads is not alignment indicative.

Tried to lynch him for it before, didn't work.

I want to lynch between Vivax and Palmar.

What shitreads does Koshi have? Do you not agree with his OO read?

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 27 2014 16:17 GMT

#385

On June 28 2014 01:13 HaruRH wrote:

Show nested quote +

On June 28 2014 01:00 Rainbows wrote:

On June 28 2014 00:46 IAmRobik wrote:

On June 28 2014 00:15 Rainbows wrote:

On June 28 2014 00:08 Vivax wrote:
Rainbows frankly I don't think you can nail Koshi with the buddying argument cause we were kinda hoping to not roll opposite alignments this game.
I buddied him back even when being suspicious of him so you can't only apply that argument to him but also to me. Just consider it something that would have happened in some way regardless of our alignments.

You already mentioned the post where he talks about kush, robik and somebody else I think and imho that is more concerning about Koshi who I remember as more tryhard as town.

He's usually quick to recognize me as scum if I deviate from my town standard so during the whole Palmar vs. Me thingy I would have expected him to either acknowledge Palmar's arguments as bad or at least try harder to figure me out instead of trying to get me to talk about other things and staying on the sidelines.

It's a bit of a subjective feel read, but if you compare his filter with this game you will notice that he also starts with a jokey phase but becomes curious about the stuff that's going on rather quickly.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/447645-normal-ass-normal-game?user=Koshi&view=all

Tbh I would like to have more stuff going on about Palmar and his new read on Koshi. Will he deliver such a case as he did on me?

My problem is the other game Koshi was town in, I had a scumread on him in the beginning. This time he gives a lot of 'we should look more closely!' whereas in another game to not be named he gave a lot of genuinely considered bad reads for Day 1 and was pressured heavily for it.

I think rainbows is town for the bolded

I think that he'd be more careful not to get modkilled if he was mafia and would make sure he wouldn't even come close to referencing ongoing games again after the mod warning

I wasn't referencing an ongoing game. I was referencing a completely random finished game where similar stuff happened, I swear.

##Unvote
##Vote: HaruRH

Plz responderino. Reads now

<3 rainbows

I do not normally do reads on d1 unless someone ultimately scummy pops out.

<3 HarurRH. I don't care what you normally do.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 27 2014 16:21 GMT

#391

On June 28 2014 01:16 HaruRH wrote:

Show nested quote +

On June 28 2014 00:35 Rainbows wrote:
All the pressure on Koshi, makes me not like Koshi lynch. Responded well to pressure. Don't like how Haru comes in and votes Koshi. First two quotes in his vote post mean nothing, the third is pretty meh.

On June 27 2014 23:25 HaruRH wrote:
Koshi is weird.

On June 27 2014 21:29 Koshi wrote:
Kush is scum and plays lazy
Robik is onto him and calls him out
Kush pretends to be still lazy while he is waiting for a fake role PM from Holyflare
Kush got the fake role PM and wants a fresh start

##vote: Kush

On June 27 2014 21:34 Koshi wrote:

On June 27 2014 21:31 kushm4sta wrote:

huh? what does the fake role PM have to do with anything..

it's a role pm not flavor pm. It would make no sense for the fake claims to all have different countries, since countries are irrelevant and that would be obvious gamebreaking. do you think HF is retarded?

Ah wait. That makes sense. The countries are irrelevant.

Still. I like my my idea. You scum.

Strong scum push on kush, retracts it, goes onto OO and then

On June 27 2014 22:40 Koshi wrote:
Note to self. I am so scummy that both OO and Vivax want to lynch me when 4 people haven't posted anything of worth. Impressive work Koshi.

condescends his way out of a push on him. nope.

##Unvote
##Vote: Koshi

Seems like he's voting thread sentiment imo. Whenever I make a post and vote somebody and someone else casually drops a vote like that it makes me very uneasy.

On June 28 2014 00:09 HaruRH wrote:

On June 27 2014 23:48 kushm4sta wrote:
@haru if you felt so strongly about koshi being scum then why did it take me asking about your scum reads to say anything about it?

Because I just woke up, read through the thread and saw that hilarious post by koshi. When you asked me for a read/lynch, I reread the thread a few times and I picked up on koshi.

What is the thread sentiment? I no get it.
So are you pressuring me now or are you voting me because you don't like a koshi lynch?

Koshi was thread sentiment (thread was moving from vivax/palmar to koshi/oo). Gave reasons koshi is scum, but not the reasons that were correct.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 27 2014 16:25 GMT

#398

Robik I didn't like your early game aggro tbh.

But your read on koshi formulates well imo

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 27 2014 16:28 GMT

#401

On June 28 2014 01:26 IAmRobik wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm not asking you or anyone else to read my. I know my alignment (mafia). I'm trying to figure out the alignment of everyone else in this game (or at least try to figure out if they're a PR or just VT). So I want people to respond to my reads posts and tell me whether they agree or disagree with them and why. Having them ignored just pisses me off

##Unvote
##Vote: IamRobik

Freudian slip.

also trying to find blues nice

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:24 GMT

#566

On June 28 2014 11:18 kushm4sta wrote:
haru and cav look like good lynches.

cav talking in the order mafia postgaame but this this thread. that is a bad sign.

Foolishness is posting in another thread but not Order. he so experienced must be scum giving up.

fuck that game. i thought cav promised reads on palmar and vivax wheres they go

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:27 GMT

#569

Robik stuff is also hilarious. wanted to see how many people sheeped / called me mafia for voting robik for obvious mistake.

didnt think the blue stuff was intentional though myself so +1

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:28 GMT

#570

On June 28 2014 11:24 Cavalinho wrote:
Blegh I forgot, hang on I'm filter diving them now.

how do you forget that you wanted to lynch between the two players at the beginning of the game wut

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:34 GMT

#571

but my opinion on vivax / palmar is that i didnt like palmar cus he stroked his ego and implied he was town somewhere and i thought it was kinda scummy. cant quote cus on phone but it went something like "you [vivax] werent promoting discussion. anyone can do that. Look at what I'm doing!" seemed kinda like he was fawning at how townie he was being and seemed scummy. Vivax looked OK to me his responses seemed fine.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:37 GMT

#572

i dont think i want to lynch robik today.

##unvote gonna filter TP fore beddy timea

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:50 GMT

#576

i dont like how you insult Robik banks, kinda shitty

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:52 GMT

#578

is robik an alias on video mafia? i used to watch that. remember banks and dont remember a robik

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 02:56 GMT

#581

i thought his counter pressure was townie. I havent read his filter since before work but thats a generalization. remember palmar leaning less town than vivax for his own aggro.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 03:03 GMT

#583

SO CAV WHERE ARE THOSE READS ON VIVAX AND PALMAR DISCUSSION.

YOU WANTED TO LYNCH BETWEEN THEM BUT APPARENTLY TOTALLY FORGOT ABOUT YOUR POTENTIAL LYNCHES.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 03:17 GMT

#586

On June 28 2014 12:13 Tehpoofter wrote:

Show nested quote +

I think if sinani hadn't basically outed I'd be voting vivax for the way he wanted to keep pushing palmer even after Koshi tried to get him to move past it.

Whats wrong with what vivax did? Seemed invested in his read. being adamant isnt scum imho. If vivax is scum he probably isnt scum for counter pressure onto palmar. i feel like scum would just defend and try to change the subject.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 03:20 GMT

#587

scum revealed when i get up. some these wagons look good but not fantastic

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 13:27 GMT

#650

Right now I'd lynch into OO, Haru, Cav. Mderg and Exo haven't done anything but whatever, if I lynch based on that again and they flip town im going to go straight to the nearest ravine and throw myself into it (I chickened out in Order, but I will really do it this time I promise)

OO's reaction to Koshi pressure was terrible, he hasn't given any other reads than his vote on Koshi, which was straight omgus. Claims that he's out trying to find his "town partners" but I haven't seen evidence of it so far. Scum because gives a lazy read on me for useless posts at the beginning of the game, promotes discussion (apparently) but doesn't seem to partake in it himself.

Haru also been fairly active but has refused to give decent reads on D1. He claims his meta is "I don't normally give reads D1", which is bullshit. His Koshi vote was very bad. First two reasons didn't make Koshi mafia, and third one was meh. Only bad feeling I have about lynching him is that I thought he was scum in order, but for different reasons and he flipped town. Don't want a repeat of that, if town might have to go ravine.

Cav wants to lynch between vivax and Palmar but completely forgot that he wanted to do that. Gave bad reads on both then didn't do anything. Came into the thread and 3 people instantly called him anti-town afterwards--a scum that's that bad? Maybe.

Still wary of Koshi. Responded well to questions in a townie way but lingering feels in my mind about evul koshi scum. But not lynch today.

Also wary of Palmar. Case on Vivax was OK for early game, but hasn't done anything to prove himself recently. Didn't like that he was building himself up as self-proclaimed super townie during the pressure on Vivax, seemed scummy that one would feel the need to do so. Votes Koshi for no reason and then disappears, no like Palmar atm.

Not sure how I feel about Kush. Hasn't done the signs I thought he would if he were scum. D2 learn more.

Most others leaning town for now.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 13:28 GMT

#651

Vivax u dayvig? That's sick if true

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

June 28 2014 13:31 GMT

#652

Calls robik probably town for his scum trap when most people are leaning that way, and then calls him scum for it later on when it's convenient. GG

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts