I mean, I think it's because my case is really good and if you fight it you'll look bad.

If you are willing to go with weak ways of playing the game that ignore a scummy history of a player, it also seems possible scum is WIFOMing and trying to make the slOosh lynch look "too easy" especially since that was somewhat compelling to people D1.

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:01 GMT

#768

@sqrt:
(1) Do you think it's possible that you are getting played because of your reactions d1? I mean I was just writing that may be happening, since to me you seem like the prime person who might switch based on this "too easy" argument.

(2) Can you at least agree that fuba's play is weird today? He joined the thread making a case on you as if he was just stopping by and had been active in the thread

On May 31 2014 15:45 fuba wrote:
I'm glad you mentioned sqrt, because he's someone who's stuck out to me.

but yet he doesn't discuss the active topics (Meepak & slOosh)

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:03 GMT

#769

On June 01 2014 09:00 Palmar wrote:
Doesn't matter. My case on MZ is far more slam dunk than yours on sloosh.

What applies to M_Z that doesn't apply to slOosh?

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:04 GMT

#770

Also if you feel so confident in your case on M_Z, why haven't you pushed it all day?
(also my case is way better than yours, btw)

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:10 GMT

#773

Okay here's another good point

@sqrt:
Yesterday fuba was content to go with a bandwagon on jabber. He kept his vote on jabber.
Today he is afraid of a bandwagon that is going too easily.

Yesterday's wagon went more easily. Today he is concerned. WAT

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:10 GMT

#774

I'm the most towny based on d2 and it's by a huge margin

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:12 GMT

#776

btw the too easy comment applies to Palmar somewhat too

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:12 GMT

#777

Also
@sqrt since I feel like I might actually convince you, do you really think it is likely that you complete today townreading slOosh?

Like, maybe it's possible you are unsure between M_Z and slOosh. But how do you townread slOosh?

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:15 GMT

#780

Probably mderg.
I like bunnies too, although she wasn't active today her post on slOosh was pretty much exactly the kind of post in response - it showed reconsidering and suspicion on grounds I obviously feel are super valid.

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:18 GMT

#781

I don't think it's easy just because people are voting on it now.

I had to convince haru and mderg too, I think.
(btw vote counters, sorry I didn't notice but mderg voted Meepak initially http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/451317-detention-mafia?page=36#701)

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:19 GMT

#782

EBWOP sorry vote count had it I was just looking at the wrong one

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:20 GMT

#784

Also it's not easy, today there were competing wagons that actually had cases behind them (M_Z, almost Haru though I ended up deciding slOosh was more scum, sqrt). Yesterday it was just jabber

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:23 GMT

#786

I don't know. Yeah fuba's play is weird, I don't want people to vote with him, but I don't feel comfortable calling him scum right now because I have been focused on M_Z and slOosh. I did read fuba's filter for troubling comments but if I were making cases on people he wouldn't be my top pick.
I mean, I don't feel like I can answer that adequately on the fly because I'm not sure I have a good answer for a third even if I spend some time on it.

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:26 GMT

#787

Palmar's responses to my points on slOosh are weak (basically amounting to "I would vote slOosh" and not engaging with the actual case). He still isn't on my scumlist.

I feel like his comment that his case on M_Z is better than mine is just wrong, so wrong, and that bugs me. :C

This is the same problem I had with fuba. If you feel like maybe slOosh is scum because of the votes, well, that's a bad point but I at least get that it seems compelling after yesterday.
But I don't agree at all with reading slOosh as town based on his post today, or the idea that the M_Z case is at all better

I'm not gonna get groceries :c I'll go later I guess

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:28 GMT

#788

@sqrt:
Do you think M_Z is scummier than slOosh? Or is it purely that you don't like votes that have majorities?

Do you really feel today's wagon is "easy" like yesterday? I just don't. There's been resistance and other cases...

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:29 GMT

#789

Also to be honest I don't feel like talking about palmar/third scum/fuba is super helpful right now, if your vote is based on the scummines of M_Z versus slOosh and whether the lynch is too easy, can we focus on those?

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:33 GMT

#792

On June 01 2014 09:28 Amiko wrote:
@sqrt:
Do you think M_Z is scummier than slOosh? Or is it purely that you don't like votes that have majorities?

Do you really feel today's wagon is "easy" like yesterday? I just don't. There's been resistance and other cases...

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:34 GMT

#793

If you think M_Z is scummier than slOosh I want you to commit to that.

Amiko

United States1725 Posts

June 01 2014 00:35 GMT

#795

Okay, so I made multiple posts talking about the scummy things that I feel apply to slOosh that don't apply to M_Z.
Do you think those aren't convincing?