TL 'Order' LXVI Mafia - Page 71

BM - Clearly putting in work here. He reaches out and talks to almost everyone thats around. He is trying to solve the game. If he isn't a villager here I will be shocked.

Chromatically - I liked what he had to say on Senani. He pushed on someone early but when asked about it he admitted it was an early read and basically he started the game from early game banter to serious mode.

Gumshoe - The only other game I've seen gumshoe not lurk the crap out of was Cell Mafia 1 and he oozed town that game did really well unfortunately made rayn freak out but still played well. The other games I've seen he just never posted so I'm hoping he just decided he wanted to play town. Keep up the posting!

ObiWanSmurf - Started the wagon of Justice on Ketomai. He seems like he did in Cell Mafia 2 where he was town a bit less jokey to start but gets down to business of wolfhunting!

Roundahydra- This is a read purely on Robik. I feel like what he did starting the game was indicative of his town play. He got very defensive early. As mafia he tends to play this super bus and buddy up game and has like the end goal of winning final 3. I didn't get this vibe from him he definitely wasn't trying to make friends.

Palmer - This Post and his leadup to it I will be surprised if it came from a wolf. I think the only way he is making this kind of full analysis post is if he feels like his team is very strong. He started off on the wolf list but moved to villager with the way he is playing and interjecting today. What he did bantering a bit with Marv felt pretty good to me.

ExO - The fact that he isn't appeasing the masses who want him to give reads and is heavily playing that n00b card buys him a day in the village imo. He needs to step it up in later days if he wants to stick around but for now I'm buying his stick of "Feeling out the meta" and "only adding to the village if he needs to"

HF - I didn't buy the whole "see ya Thursday" bit at first but this morning he came in and was interacting with the thread in a sincere fashion and seemed to be putting his mind into figuring out things. He came in talking to yamato about his exams which is neutral but he then gave a snippet on Koshi that to me felt like he was reading the thread and even though he wasn't posting a bunch was in touch with the topic at hand. (at the time Koshi)

Slam - Oh man I hope I'm right so Slam needs like his own section. I have never read him before but I'm going to say that he coming in and having that response to ticatica about palmer and peach read like nonsense but to me seemed like he took a bit to write it as if the people he was referring to were real it would have made sense. But the 2 main reasons were his asking aobut the roundabound case as well as following up with me to make sure I was still trying to read him not once but twice. That to me feels mildly villager this is such a weak read but I'm going to try to actually read you slam! Here's hoping I'm right.

Koshi - First reads felt structured and forced and the Chrom read wasn't what I'm use to on Koshi. He gets the lean and not the howl because maybe he is just trying out a new style. I made a post earlier on reasons I think Koshi might be scum Here

Senani - Chrom had some pretty good points against him he also came off to me as overly defensive. He has fallen out of my mind a bit from early game and I'm waiting to see what he comes into the thread the later part of the day. (Weakest wolf read atm)

Marv - Not playing what I feel like he plays as village, the strong leader. He is softly pressuring people. The first thing he has really seemed to perk up about was Ritoky and hes not even voting him. Seems more concerned about posting witty retorts than finding wolves. In Catastrophe the other big game he was village and I was village played with him day 1 he was leading the lynch around trying to actively hunt and find wolves and wasn't really worried about his voting. He doesn't have a strong scum lean atm frankly it feels like hes not trying=wolfy.

VA - Comes in complaining about the length of the thread and how he isn't going to read it. (at this point it was not even 10 actual pages long zzzz) Then he bows out after another 10 pages without giving reads or context. Since then he has posted a vote on me for a 408 a picture and a self condemnation. I don't mind if he is scum reading me his vote is honestly the most useful thing hes done all game (unlike marv who still hasn't voted) He is not giving this game anything at all. Would vote.

Ritoky - The big thing was how his read in this post had no flow to it. Like he wrote the conclusion before the evidence or something. He seemed to not have have cohesive thoughts. His opening post seemed like he thought about feeding off his game in Cell Mafia 2 with the whole "freedom" thing but it wasn't like last time just one short post about it. I do like however that he brought it up in regards to his MZ read so not bad there but overall wolfy. Would vote.