I said a couple random things, Holy made a case in his filter. Concentrates unnaturally on Exo even though his last post indicates he doesn't find him suspicious. All pretty odd. And yeah the 3p post was bad.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 15:43 GMT

#3911

On June 18 2014 00:40 Rainbows wrote:
I like his point about gumshoe calling out keto but not calling him scum.

in an ideal world, that'd make them both mafia

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 15:47 GMT

#3915

On June 18 2014 00:44 sinani206 wrote:

Show nested quote +

I've never played with gumshoe before. How experienced is he?

Reasonably experienced. Not massively strong, but not weak either, overall. When he's invested as town he's pretty good.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 15:48 GMT

#3916

I should add that he's not that often invested as town :/

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 15:59 GMT

#3918

neither of those things are necessary for gumshoe to be mafia

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 21:23 GMT

#3937

ok. i swear to god i am lynching one of fool/sand today (sorry holy, rainbows, whoever else). this shit has to stop.

or start. you get me.

##Unvote
##Vote: mattisfoolish

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 17 2014 22:24 GMT

#3941

well let's see if sandroba proves mif wrong or not.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:00 GMT

#4080

On June 18 2014 11:56 batsnacks wrote:

Show nested quote +

Roundabound, poofter, and sinani were my initial scum reads day 1. None of them ever sufficiently convinced me otherwise, but poofter flipped town so I was at least wrong about him. Bunnies' play is very similar to last game when she was mafia; it is worth mentioning I guessed her alignment correctly last game. One of marv/hf is mafia in my opinion because there is no way they are both still alive as town. Sand/MIF because afk scum tactics. CR maybe because he came into the thread all thoughtful, thorough and trying but now he doesn't care.

how do you propose i should have died exactly?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:01 GMT

#4081

On June 18 2014 12:00 roundabound wrote:
JK needs to not JK marv tonight. Just let medic put a protection on him. Marv is needed tonight for serious business.

oh please tell me you didn't.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:26 GMT

#4082

On June 18 2014 12:40 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
batsnacks, if we put any stock into marv's protection claim, then he's obviously going to be alive for quite a while. idk about hf though, i have him as town as of right now but its a toss up because his scumhunting is always weird imo.

also, robik, answer my question. ive got a brand to maintain and im not gonna rep total shmucks.

Any stock? It's virtually guaranteed to be true? lol. People are so weird.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:31 GMT

#4083

I'll probably be lynching sandroba if things carry on as it is, although sand was probably doing football-brazil things last night.

so he has today to dazzle my socks off.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:42 GMT

#4085

mif pushed gumshoe on d2, that's a very uninteresting point really

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:44 GMT

#4086

I don't even understand why you're questioning it, you know mif has been pushing gumshoe, and as it stands/stood, gumshoe was the wagon with actual votes on it. I don't get why you're questioning that.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:58 GMT

#4088

yes mif are being terrible. that's not news. but him voting gumshoe should not be a surprise to anyone.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 09:59 GMT

#4089

also you can't update the gumshoe read, gumshoe hasn't posted.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 10:06 GMT

#4091

....

ok holy. *pats*

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 18 2014 10:15 GMT

#4093

well look, there's plenty of reason for mif to be mafia, indeed my vote is on him right now. But voting for a scumread and not updating a scumread when that scumread hasn't posted isn't really one of them :p

What I don't get is why we have a massive discussion thread about behaviour when the "behaviour" that is really deleterious to our games is people not putting in any effort. Even if the thread is super long, you can still filter a few of the consensus mafia reads and give reasons why they are/aren't mafia. That's the real stain on mafia games, people not trying or giving a shit. Not someone saying fuck you occasionally or whatever.