You Only Shoot Once Mafia - Page 3

On May 07 2014 08:08 Tehpoofter wrote:
@VA do you think that Palmer/Caller reactions was scum on scum? scum on town? Like seeing how the days have played out which is most likely in your mind?

7 posts 3 given.

On May 07 2014 09:00 justanothertownie wrote:
Palmar has good reads this game. Oats/BH were both scumreads (granted BH was traitor) and Foolishness is in there too. No way in hell I will be voting him. Also marv/rayn meta on Palmar says he is town. Idgaf Palmar is most likely town Palmar afaik.

On May 07 2014 08:58 austinmcc wrote:
What are the reads? Cuz as best I can tell, he's got enough town that you likely end up at the tail end of his scumlist.

I get the palmar/caller thing, but the summation of your thoughts on foolishness is "he has PRETTY MUCH the same reads as me", with no further detail, and no explanation of where you guys disagree?

---

---

---

Look at what he does with SnB, prplhz, or people in past games. He pulls from multiple games, generally creating a full idea of what someone plays like.

With oats, his QT posts are:





those are both D1. Nothing about oats's stuff ever brought to thread though, and that was it. No more posts in QT about his meta. Nothing in the game about his meta. I don't see "hey here's a single post and a single post" as equivalent to what I think of when I think of Fool looking at someone's past games. There are...NO conclusions there except "eerily similar", there was NO checkup on whether people who said "oats = oats" had merit, etc.

If you read just the text of those posts, you go "Foolishness says he's looking into oats!" But there's nothing in thread. There's no analysis, no conclusions, anywhere. Especially in a game where I had a hard time convincing people that this looked like mafia oats and not "oats", it is ... off ... to me that the above is ALL we've got, ESPECIALLY if Foolishness thought he was scum, and ESPECIALLY if he was almost the D1 lynch and Foolishness thought he was scum, and ESPECIALLY if Foolishness was the secondary lynch candidate AND oats was almost the D1 lynch AND Foolishness thought he was scum.


If you're town and Foolishness is scum, you're going wrong because you're not drawing a complete picture of Foolishness, you're valuing little things he says in a QT over what's in thread, you're looking at some things and you're not looking for CONCLUSIONS and ACTIONFOOLISHNESS.

---

---

---

I personally think this is 100% wrong.

On May 07 2014 09:14 WaveofShadow wrote:
Alright Austin I feel better about lynching him. Just know that if he flips town you yourself may be in trouble, despite your early Oats push.

He trolled like this in LXI too where he was one of like 8 cops or some shit.
Vayne I really don't want a no-flip right now, can I get you to switch? A foolishness flip will really help us get a better read of basically everyone in the end anyway has the entire game has sort of revolved around him for way too long. Hell that's a good reason to flip him on its own.

Slam switch back pls kthx. I do feel the urge for shenannies but we have a lot of the towniest people on Foolishness right now so at least you can feel good about that.

On May 07 2014 09:15 austinmcc wrote:
21
For this exact moment, I don't care if you're going to afk and do very little all game.

But i WOULD like to know what "foolishness has pretty much the same reads as me so I have no reason to lynch him" means.

What are the reads you agree with/disagree with? What ARE foolishness's reads? Do you know them?

Regardless of whether you feel this
I'd still actually like to know why you feel the way you feel about Foolishness. (Also I totally want to take stances on oats, he's not unreadable AT ALL (you can join folks in reading thug life for that, lol))

On May 07 2014 09:26 austinmcc wrote:
22

gonna hold off posting more for a moment. People not posting, would be nice of you to donate some to JAT or myself, <3<3

Thug Life was austin keeps ranting that oats is town, oats WOULD have been lynched on like D4 or D5, but got cop checked overnight as town. Mr. Cheesecake in particular was pushing him for the next day and that was the main way he outed himself as mafia. Oats isn't unreadable. I can't claim to know his alignment 100% every game, but I've had a good track record of being correct any time I actually have a strong feeling on him. I dunno that I could teach you how to oatsread like I could teach you how to Dougie, however.



VA, I ... don't like that. Shocker. You're okay with Foolishness because of his reads from the start of D2. Of those 4 reads, 2 guys are dead (and he was 1 and 1), 2 are alive. And he doesn't APPEAR to be scummy on WoS anymore, although he hasn't explicitly said as much (see his posts referencing WoS). You're not at all troubled that "Foolishness's Reads", which you may like, are found at the start of D2, and he's basically put in less effort since then, despite town pushing itself further and further into a good position?

On May 08 2014 13:02 Alakaslam wrote:
Did anyone expect differently?

Too bad there wasn't another martyr.

I have nine left.

Ace and palmar talking about "Who do we want to take to lylo"

If not me, you folks are idiots. By definition you want confirmed town at lylo. Since I know you aren't idiots,

##Vote: Ace

Ask me why.