|
@Amiko, I believe t was obvious that tamburini was not going to shoot Yell0w, and here is why. Going a bit off of video mafia plays, you usually don't shoot the ones you want to lynch in the day. So I feel as if tamburini thinks yell0w will get lynched today or he did at the time he made his vigi claim), he has a shot outside of yell0w whom he thinks is scummy.
Of course this is all on the basis that tamburini is the vigi and not the serial killer, the latter seemingly more unlikely by how I've seen tamburini play.
Tamburini is town here, and everyone who votes on him is a scumbag. (Or more likely mafia).
We need to find a mafia outside of tamburini today, and we only have a few hours to do so.
I like Amiko's points on Sweetfrost, they line up with mine a bit.
Sweetfrost to me hasnt contributed much to this game besides trying to make it seem like I am scummy, without giving straight reasons to as why, and then votes on someone totally different whom most people havent even considered looking at. Some may fine this townie, but I find this as his attempt at seeming townie, and then possibly blitzing at last moment to vote on someone who is town and get them lynched since the votes are so spread out right now.
So I definitely need to hear more from Sweetfrost.
|
I honestly don't think that tamburini should out his shot.
|
[QUOTE]On May 02 2014 05:00 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
[QUOTE]On May 02 2014 04:59 27ninjabunnies wrote:
I honestly don't think that tamburini should out his shot.[/QUOTE]
Oh yes before the end of night 1, I agree.
however right now, no.
For this reason, mafia can't double stack on his kill if they don't know who it is.
|
Ooops, that previous post went all wacky.
|
Okay, so he was town, but luckily just town and not a role.
Which means we have two roles still alive (and this is what I am stating as a possibility).
I feel bad about voting him off, but then again, he had done nothing to try and sway our votes off of him. Even as just a vt, you'd think he's fight to the death (I know I would).
Tamburini, I suggest to you that you claim your night kill closer towards the end of the night, that way mafia can't blitz at last second if they do not have a role blocker.
Also, I'm going to reread Sweet's filter to find anything that stands out, and anyone who had addressed him. I hope I'll have something substantial to give to town after I read.
|
Edit: More than two roles. My bad. I'm used to the blue text for roles being 3p roles. I should read better.
|
I agree Eden... Wow... So townie... Why do I not want to like you?
|
So I just finished my last college final, and currently have to pack up my dorm room, so I probably won't be able to post for the next couple of hours. But if you have any questions for me, go ahead and address me. I'll look through everything and make one big post.
|
On May 02 2014 09:55 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
@Bunnies, how was your finals?
How do you feel about being able to talk at night?
Okay, serious question now.
If you were vigi, who would you kill, other than yellow? Would it be a kill for information, or would it be a kill in an attempt to catch mafia?
Finals were good. glad they are over. It's amazing cause I get to study abroad next semester.
Talking at night isn't too bad. I like that we get to discuss the lynch, possible lynches for next day, etc.
Plus it gives the possible night kills a chance to get their reads in before they die.
If I were vigi, I would kill, other than yellow, possibly Epishade or Eden or Meat.
I can elaborate on these reads in a bit after I finish packing so I can quote things and give reasons as to why.
You always shoot to kill mafia, not find information, so I find your question very odd. You want as much town as possible, because multiple town is better than mafia overrunning town.
So I'd shoot whoever I find the most scummy. Because that would give more information that shooting a town.
|
On May 02 2014 10:10 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I mean, someone might look really scummy, but there might be someone who's been acting strangely (like tambo). If I were vigi, I'd kill tambo. It would wield the most information.
I honestly don't think killing the vigi would reap the most information. For one, tamburini declared himself as leader, gave few reads, and then outed as vigi. You have nothing really to go off of what he had done besides the people pushing to lynch him.
Plus you reduce town KP, even though vigi is pretty much mafia sided anyway.
Sqrt, how many games of mafia have you played?
|
On May 02 2014 10:14 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
Well, if I were vigi, tambo is highly unlikely vigi.
As for the amount of mafia games, do you mean here on team liquid? This is my third team liquid game, and aside from that, I've only played irl mafia. I've played irl mafia for about 4 years now, I think.
Okay, so you know a bit about mafia.
True, if you were vigi, tambo would highly unlikely be vigi, unless the host decided to put two vigis in (which to me seems a little op).
But why bring this point up sqrt?
What do you have to gain from this questioning, unless you are the actual vigi?
|
On May 02 2014 10:18 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
Just curious to see who your kills would be.
Okay, so you claim your kill would be tamburini.
Let's say hypothetically you were not vigi. And somehow you magically have a gun.
Why would you shoot the possible only vigi within the game?
Give me your reasons.
|
@ Sqrt As in, what information do you think you will gain?
|
On May 02 2014 10:30 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I asked: if you were vigi, not if you magically had a gun.
If you were vigi, it's really unlikely that tambo isn't vigi. So I would shoot him. To see if he's SK, or mafia.
You are not answering my question.
Unless you are vigi, you dont have a gun. So Im magically giving you one.
Now, answer my question.
|
@sqrt Thank you for answering.
So do you think tamburini is actual vigi?
|
@sqrt Okay, what are you reasons on why you don't think tamburini as vigi?
|
On May 02 2014 11:35 mtamburini wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2014 10:16 27ninjabunnies wrote:On May 02 2014 10:14 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
Well, if I were vigi, tambo is highly unlikely vigi.
As for the amount of mafia games, do you mean here on team liquid? This is my third team liquid game, and aside from that, I've only played irl mafia. I've played irl mafia for about 4 years now, I think. Okay, so you know a bit about mafia. True, if you were vigi, tambo would highly unlikely be vigi, unless the host decided to put two vigis in (which to me seems a little op). But why bring this point up sqrt? What do you have to gain from this questioning, unless you are the actual vigi? Gamblers fallacy, there can be more than one of the same role in this game.
Oh yes, I know this.
I think it would be op to have 2 vigis, but it is possible.
Sqrt's questioning is just throwing me off.
|
I'm super sad no one is talking at night.
|
On May 02 2014 17:10 ahswtini wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2014 10:32 27ninjabunnies wrote:On May 02 2014 10:30 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I asked: if you were vigi, not if you magically had a gun.
If you were vigi, it's really unlikely that tambo isn't vigi. So I would shoot him. To see if he's SK, or mafia. You are not answering my question. Unless you are vigi, you dont have a gun. So Im magically giving you one. Now, answer my question. Why are you so fixated on fantastical scenarios like people magically having guns? Are you trying to get a list of suspicious townies that would-be vigs would want to shoot, so the scum know who not to target tonight?
No basically the reason why I questioned it was because it seemed as sqrt was softing vigilante. As if his shot was going to be on tamburini. His questioning was weird to me.
So I asked if he wasn't vigilante, but had a gun, would he still shoot tamburini?
This gives me a read of whether or not he would take a chance to shoot the vgi, or try and hit mafia outside of tamburini in order to find information.
|
@Sqrt You have the weirdest questioning.
Are you trying to find out who you and your mafia partners should kill tonight?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
