Catastrophe Mafia - Page 13

On April 08 2014 09:59 justanothertownie wrote:
Sorry buddy, but you are crazy

##Ruby: sandroba

Everything I said was genuine.

On April 08 2014 10:54 justanothertownie wrote:

Well, as long as Sandro is save there is no reason to kill me. And if he isn't save at some point mafia will probably shoot him anyways.

On April 08 2014 11:50 Holyflare wrote:
if jat killed foolish there are then 3 scum kills, that means there are 5-6 scum only, we killed 2 so there are 3-4, originally we assumed there was 7 or 8 in which case we'd be against 5 or 6 scum now.

VA knows the amount of people in a scum team this game.

On April 08 2014 11:56 Holyflare wrote:


lynch va with fire

On April 09 2014 02:16 Holyflare wrote:


What an interesting question robik

On April 09 2014 05:42 austinmcc wrote:
I've joined 200+ page games before, big themed ones, and a Greymist game in Chrono.

I know the feeling, and also, btw, it's impossible. You'll never catch up, you have to play going forward. Especially since you're missing PM stuff that I wasn't in those games.

But I'm making the point for everyone, that wasn't specifically at you. I'm happy to catch you up on what I've done, but I'm not saying "Hey Geript, Killing is wonky/scummy/lying/blah blah." I don't believe, in general, that he's town and I don't believe, in general, that he's truthful about his role being OH YA HALP TOWN MANY HALP KK

On April 09 2014 06:03 austinmcc wrote:
And I really don't think that "he doesn't even know what the majority of it is used for" points in ANY direction. Like...that's irrelevant to alignment, imo.

"Hey guys I used my role so I'm super town and it did super town stuff and now I'm super town kkkk. Also I don't know what a majority of my role is good for. It might be good for mafia! I dunno. But it's townie and I'm townie yum yum."

If you don't know what your role really does, when it's useful, what it's useful for, AND YOU'RE BEING TRUTHFUL about your role, then how in the world can you argue that your role is townie and it's use is townie. You're claiming both to not know exactly what it does AND know that what you're doing is townie townie.

On April 09 2014 06:18 austinmcc wrote:
There's a whole chain of questionable crap there then.

Base level - maybe he lies
Next level - he doesn't know what he does
Next level - he argues that he's town for doing one town favored thing as part of his role

If you trust he wasn't lying about his role, that's fine fine. But if he sincerely DOES NOT KNOW WHAT HE REALLY DOES OR WHY IT'S GOOD, then it is difficult for me to go "Oh that's great, makes perfect sense he'd argue he's town based on his role." Because IF he's been 100% truthful, he doesn't actually KNOW if he's town-favored apparently. And if he's NOT being truthful, that's just a problem in and of itself.

Like...sincerely not knowing what you do or why it's useful is incompatible with "I did this thing with my role and it is townie so my role is townie so I'm town." Add that to his defense-ish of HF, no bueno.

For instance. You are Robik. How do you feel about that HF defense post? HF probably town because he wouldn't do this anti-town thing as mafia.

On April 09 2014 06:22 austinmcc wrote:
Robik, just more general. Who cares about roles and whatnot. Does Killing's posting read town/mafia, and por que?