On April 08 2014 03:52 Steveling wrote: He can't be that stupid to not understand why after what happened yesterday palmar is 100% confirmed scum. He can't be.
Is getript always that thick guys? It's my first game with him.
how does scum voting on cephiro or prpl out anyone or anything?
they are afk, they just have to post something like "i have no time and will sheep x (being the player on the wrong wagon)" and then all will be fine! town AND scum are likely to do that so no information is gained about anyone
On April 08 2014 03:51 mderg wrote: Do I see it correctly that we have to decide between the active and slightly scummy looking prplhz and the inactive and slightly scummy looking Cephiro? Seems really easy to decide... NOT
On April 08 2014 03:45 Holyflare wrote: because there's 3 hours left and he can ninja vote, have you ever played mafia before?
Thereby outing me and slam, that would be oh so nice of him. This game goes on after today for town Holy, only scum are guranteed to lose if prplz dies.
Honestly, I think you're trying too hard right now. Seriously, please stop because you're wrong.
Answer the question Geript, say you think Ceph is scum, why is he not voting, who is the 4th scum, why are they not voting?
Why are scum not voting for scum.... hmmmmm. Well Let's look at the potential scum: Balla--inactive hasn't posted in a while. LSB--pretty inactive Ceph--Hasn't voted since he ninja voted Coag for no reason given Tehpoofter--Went poof
On April 08 2014 03:51 mderg wrote: Do I see it correctly that we have to decide between the active and slightly scummy looking prplhz and the inactive and slightly scummy looking Cephiro? Seems really easy to decide... NOT
On April 08 2014 03:45 Holyflare wrote: because there's 3 hours left and he can ninja vote, have you ever played mafia before?
Thereby outing me and slam, that would be oh so nice of him. This game goes on after today for town Holy, only scum are guranteed to lose if prplz dies.
Honestly, I think you're trying too hard right now. Seriously, please stop because you're wrong.
Answer the question Geript, say you think Ceph is scum, why is he not voting, who is the 4th scum, why are they not voting?
Why are scum not voting for scum.... hmmmmm. Well Let's look at the potential scum: Balla--inactive hasn't posted in a while. LSB--pretty inactive Ceph--Hasn't voted since he ninja voted Coag for no reason given Tehpoofter--Went poof
Like please use your head and start to think.
lsb is in slams group, he cant be scum with slam. Same to Balla, we can rule those two out.
That leaves tehpoofter... whats his motive for no voting? Jack all, his absence is null, scum would benefit immensley having him here.
On April 08 2014 03:57 Steveling wrote: Btw I happened to see poofter's game in 2 other games. He's now playing actively in 3 games, so yeah. Who does that....
Online till deadline from now. I figure I owe the other players at least that much.
There are several reasons for why I haven't been actively playing, but they're not of importance. I'll post my thoughts on today's lynch and the remaining cells in a moment. It will be brief.
On April 08 2014 03:59 Steveling wrote: ##unvote ##vote: Cephiro
Steve, if Prplz is scum, the team is outed.
Its me, slam, tehpoofter, ceph, sentinel, no other combo makes sense, its either us, or just Prplz, so whats easier to believe? Do not sheep Geript, he is often wrong, do not sheep Holy, he has changed his reads 50 times over.
Above all, bilieve in me T_T I know it takes courage, but please man, dont be bullied by scum and geript.
On April 08 2014 03:45 Holyflare wrote: because there's 3 hours left and he can ninja vote, have you ever played mafia before?
Thereby outing me and slam, that would be oh so nice of him. This game goes on after today for town Holy, only scum are guranteed to lose if prplz dies.
Honestly, I think you're trying too hard right now. Seriously, please stop because you're wrong.
Answer the question Geript, say you think Ceph is scum, why is he not voting, who is the 4th scum, why are they not voting?
Why are scum not voting for scum.... hmmmmm. Well Let's look at the potential scum: Balla--inactive hasn't posted in a while. LSB--pretty inactive Ceph--Hasn't voted since he ninja voted Coag for no reason given Tehpoofter--Went poof
Like please use your head and start to think.
lsb is in slams group, he cant be scum with slam. Same to Balla, we can rule those two out.
That leaves tehpoofter... whats his motive for no voting? Jack all, his absence is null, scum would benefit immensley having him here.
Yah. Scum generally benefits from scum being active. But inactive scum are inactive. You can't do shit about making them active.
It's actually really dumb to expect geript to consistently stay with that notion of holyflare and never question antyhing HF does because of it. You're pushing him to live up to what is probably a joke.
#3 is actually a good point, and if there was a way of testing it that'd be great. ie if we could somehow interrogate only the Cav head without him being funneled answers from the geript head. But I don't think we can so whatever.
#2 is just a meta read, and I'm not even sure I agree scum geript is passive, he was plenty mad at me in survivor.
Like I don't know, if this is geript mafia he's not playing like he played in survivor. He was much more cowboy-ish and less interactive in that game than he
is now.
This is a well reasoned defense and I totally agree with it, as you know : D
Compare that to this shit.
I like this prplhz
He said something yesterday that caused me to think "man this is townhaze", but I can't remember what.
He wasn't very active during the time I was active at.
Here is the post I'm referring to.
It's a great observation, especially since I think Steve had just mentioned earlier that he was going to focus on his own group, then started randomly asking people for who to read up on.
(post in question by prplz)
More aribitrarily calling Prplz town.
so after reading through the game you have absolutely no idea where to start filtering and instead you just filter whoever arbitrarily shows up?
prplhz is town. No arguing, I'm better than anyone on TL at reading him.
prplhz should never be lynched
but prplhz is a pretty strong townread, I've pointed out at least one of the posts that make me think he has to be town.
This is the entirety of Palmers argument that Prplz is town, compare that to the one on Geript, which was insanely well reasoned, Geript is obgectively townier than prp... and yet
[quote]Also I have no idea how you can think geript is more likely to be town than prplhz.[/quote]
Geript I agree, Palmer argument for why your town is inpecable, his read for Prplz doesnt even come close, so why does he read Prplz townier? Palmer knew he could get away with town reading you, he also knew that was critical to winning the game because your a huge threat to him otherwise. His read was so good on you because scums reads are perfect. That said he would have never lynched prplz over you / : which makes no sense given how amazing the read on you way. Face it bud, you got pocketed.