I believe it.

But it's not like it has much of anything to do with his alignment, because he could be telling the truth as either alignment. And there's nothing he's done all game that's made me think he's mafia so right now austin is a super green read. Most recent;y the way he went about doing the town/scum djo thing and the conclusions he drew from his own efforts were really townie and probably hard to fake as mafia

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 00:43 GMT

#1256

and about not being around for the lynch? eh. either he's telling the truth or he's not, so whatever. that's literally all you can say about it. so you have to look at everything else he's done, and those things indicate that he's town

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 00:48 GMT

#1258

Why did you ask me? It didn't look like you were scumreading austin and I'm pretty sure it doesn't look like I'm scumreading austin.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 00:53 GMT

#1259

On April 02 2014 09:47 kitaman27 wrote:
You still think kush is sketchy?

When I went to look at him originally, I found these quotes from persona and golden sun where he was town, which seems to match the same mentality this game.

Show nested quote +

It lines up with his position of not lynching slam and suggesting that we look at those that do since mafia are likely to go after third party targets. His post length seems to be what I would expect from a town kush as well.

so my read on kush is kinda fucked

1) going into N1 i was more interested in hearing from him. i town read him early, but he hadn't done much so I needed to see him post more. AND since I was townreading so many other people and felt more confident about those reads, I thought he muight just be scum because of PoE

2) i thought that the hidden vote mechanic must come from mafia

3) kush claims the hidden vote

4) now I think kush is town again lol

it was the way he claimed it that made me think he's town. he wasn't defensive about it and didn't seem to understand that people would find him suspicious for using a hidden vote to lynch town rayn. if he was scum he probably would have not claimed it or the claim would have been at least a bit defensive

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 01:04 GMT

#1261

idk. alak is pretty closed to confirmed to being not scum so i really don't think it mattered what mafia decided to do with their votes. i'll go look in a bit

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 01:12 GMT

#1263

bird gods have nothing on 4th dimensional townies

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 01:40 GMT

#1265

i dunno kita. I really dont. i have a feeling that D2 is going to feel exactly like a normal game's D1

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 02:29 GMT

#1270

On April 02 2014 11:24 JarJarDrinks wrote:
So it seems no one has a problem w/ me firing my nuke @ slam? Unless someone tries to convince me otherwise I'll do it sometime tomorrow morning.

why aren't you firing it at kita? during the night you said you were treating him as "confirmed scum"

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 02:44 GMT

#1277

what do you think about nuking gumshoe?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 03:03 GMT

#1284

i was only in favor of the mass claiming because I assumed rayn knew what he was doing and would be able to figure it out. i'd rather hold off on that right now

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 04:02 GMT

#1301

austin i've already checked, the extra vote happened some time during the 2nd to last and last vote count

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 04:04 GMT

#1303

GUMSHOE!!

Are you aware that this thread exists?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 05:04 GMT

#1327

jjd can you confirm that point #4 happened before he says he's not interested in rayn/slam?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

April 02 2014 05:23 GMT

#1329

On April 02 2014 14:21 gumshoe wrote:

Show nested quote +

Cause Artanis set up so fun: D in all seriousness I'm pretty much caught up. Will provide awesome case tommorow on super scum read. Also wouldn't mind a mass claim, might help tell us what exactly scum is capable of.

can't you just say something now? you are sorta holding the game hostage