Doctor Who Mafia 2 - Page 7

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 02:54 GMT

#2167

As for kita I had him on my scum list on N1 and the start of day 1 I did list others as more suspicious but once claims started happening I decided lynching into any blues when we had already lost 2 (shrink/medic) wouldn't be good for town so I went on my top scumread outside the claims which was kita.

I'd be interested in theories on the night kills we had 0 then 2. I know the "lovers" role is common on epic mafia I'm not sure how it plays in here but thats one option for the 2 kills. I thought I read something in one of the flavor bits that might have pointed to it but I need to reread closer. I'm glad more people gave reads last night than the night before hopefully we can keep an eye on that and see who goes shifting around.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 03:44 GMT

#2191

@thrawn yeah well my preferred check is kita the only reason I'd say to check you is to reaffirm my read. I still think you're town the way you post about how my post counts dropped cause it most definitely did I don't like making excuses but I am in 2 other games currently and its stretching me thin. I didn't think I would be in all three simultaneously but thats not an excuse. I did still try to hunt scum that day(day2) and brought up a large case on vivax and had him voted up until his claim. I find it hard for you to suggest I was converted if I was who did my read change on? I think I was pretty clear N1 on my reads I can go back and quote the post if you'd like.

For the official record I don't currently suspect thrawn and kita is my main suspect I find it odd he withheld information on his role maybe he has a good reason but idk everyone is at least seemingly being transparent.

As to the delay on my responses thrawn I'm working trying to post as I can I was off work day 1 so naturally my responses are faster within the half hour I'm off work again this evening and can talk more fluidly. .

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 03:54 GMT

#2193

@thrawn its odd you're so suspicious of me and don't want to check me.

It doesn't garner me any extra info being checked so I'd rather it wasn't me but with all the other people claiming blue roles aside from myself and thrawn I understand for town that looks mega fishy. (I mean wtf everyone else gets fun things and I get plain old green

) I have something to say more on Amiko cause he randomly got his role changed (sounds cool that it happened but why? Like what brought on the change just a random townie day 2 gets a nuke out of no where? Was town thought to be in a bad spot at this point?)

@austin so how many scum you think there is cause if I was being objective I would say 3 at this point unless they missed a conversion then 2 assuming a 1 scum start.

@others I think an answer to austin's question on who to check would be useful. Did kush ever answer how rapidly the check works?

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 03:56 GMT

#2195

On April 05 2014 12:48 thrawn2112 wrote:
Ok tehpoofter here is a nonrelated question.

When you saw the recent flips, what were your first thoughts?

(i'm looking for thoughts regarding scum, not setup speculation stuff)

Kita is mafia. JJD had a role that could do something to others kita as mafia would know that its not a medic/shrink/inventor since JJD had the nuke yesterday. Austin lived through the night so unlikely to be vigi my next thought would be cop. JJD was going saying adamantly against kita if I recall correctly. So that was my first thought that Kita didn't want a cop claim with a red on him thus

The reason I bring up the lover's thing is cause DJO was a random kill idk why he was targeted.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 03:59 GMT

#2199

I can see that I touched on it earlier seeing as there is 2 people claiming vt and all the rest some type of roles it is odd. Sucks we lost our cop without getting kita's info.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 04:00 GMT

#2200

On April 05 2014 12:58 thrawn2112 wrote:

Show nested quote +

why was djo the random kill and not jjd?

JJd claimed a visiting role I don't think DJO ever did unless I missed it. I think thats pretty easy to see.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 04:30 GMT

#2215

Off work. So you think 3 Austin. I think the number matters because some people don't make sense as mafia unless they started higher IMO

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 04:30 GMT

#2216

@amiko what didn't you like?

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 19:25 GMT

#2263

At amiko I don't read the lore as I really haven't seen dr who. Also don't shoot me.

This game doesn't make sense. I'm honestly surprised Kita is green. One of our claimed roles is mafia because it can't be just thrown. Maybe multiple roles.

What are pEoples theOrieS if I'm town (I know I am but let's venture there)? I like Austin as town I feel like role teams would be vivax/hope or Kush/Kita because they confirm each other but if it's just one fake role it's amiko (I believe he has a shot though)

Someone explain how my reads make sense for someone converted and by whom. I was advocating n1 reads and did my own same with n2 I have been very open. So idk why people think I'm converted minus activity drop.

I gotta head to work ill post from there.

I wasn't converted and am still lame ass vt. Content is down cause I'm in three games. This being the most progressed and least amount of posts.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 21:27 GMT

#2283

@austin I understand your scum case on kush. Where I'm at right now is that there are 2 blue claims verified by each other. Vivax/Hopeless. and Kush/Kita. I have to assume one of them is fake and then maybe + thrawn or amiko? I believe austin's in the most town unless he was converted by Vivax the night JJD and vivax visited and JJD got the check for what he started the night as. But if thats the case I feel like Austin would push on me or thrawn for an easier ML rather than go on kush/kita.

I feel like a night shot from amiko would be best because we have more info and if we lynch into the wrong "half" of things he could correct us. This obviously doesn't work if hes scum but if thats the case we probably already lost tbh.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 21:59 GMT

#2288

@Thrawn because unless you and me are mafia one of the roles is lying thrawn. It worries me you don't think that this is the case. Looking at the roles and figuring out which makes the least sense is a good way to figure out. Like thrawn who is your mafia?

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 22:05 GMT

#2290

kush and who?

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 22:19 GMT

#2295

Hmm I really am interested in kita's massive post and role claim. No reason not to now.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 23:19 GMT

#2308

On April 06 2014 08:17 thrawn2112 wrote:
just post your role pm please!

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 23:24 GMT

#2309

@austin/others around. So if Kita/kush are mafia how likely is it that its just 2? I mean someone is on the bus train hard or its just them. Maybe amiko is the 3rd the way hes talking but idk... If its kita/kush/amiko then i think it was kita alone then kush then amiko conversion wise. But maybe the n1 stuff could have been an attempt to convert toad and he couldnt' be plus they killed amiko or something.

I just don't know if amiko really fits a 3rd there. So I'm wondering what is the third there? (Maybe were lucky and its only 2 but idk)

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 05 2014 23:44 GMT

#2325

yeah vivax new invention each night but can't repeatedly item the same person. Thats how I understand it + the mod announcing. Its odd that he gave the item to kush though.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 06 2014 18:21 GMT

#2464

Trying to catch up now. Off all day so I should be able to dive in pretty deep to this thread.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

April 06 2014 19:02 GMT

#2468

##Vote: Kushm4sta

Its time to pick a side and kush's role seems too good to be town.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts