The reason I want to lynch Giggletummy is that he claims that the whole scooby-doo nonsense is not productive to the thread, but the fact of the matter is that it had to do with something about /this/ game - primarily Holyflare's read on Hopeless - so the point actually /is/ relevant to this game. That he's calling it "not productive" indicates to me that he's either scum trying to buy credibility later if/when Hopeless flips town or scum trying to deflect off of a scumbuddy in this situation. There's a possibility that he's just tunneled in on Holyflare if he's town, but judging from his posts to and about Holyflare I don't see this as possible. Hell in his case on Holyflare he never even says he thinks Holyflare is scum - just does a play by play of the whole Holy/DP scenario and gives a non-conclusion.

I think Giggletummy is the lynch today guys, and I like both rayn and Palmar who are both on GT for different reasons. My reason is the best reason though and everyone should vote for GT.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

March 19 2014 20:51 GMT

#1372

That is in fact really wierd. I noticed it too. He does not even call Holyflare mafia.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 19 2014 20:53 GMT

#1373

I mean to put it another way, the Scooby Doo nonsense has led him to his best (and only?) scumread of the game - so how can he possibly believe that it's not productive?

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 19 2014 20:54 GMT

#1374

rayn I'd like you to explain why you think thrawn is town. HF raised a really good point about thrawn leaving DP off his PoE list earlier and I don't really know how you missed that. It's pretty blatant.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 19 2014 20:56 GMT

#1375

On March 20 2014 03:00 raynpelikoneet wrote:
thrawn what has DP done that make you think that he is town?
This is what you say:

Show nested quote +

there must be a reason.

You didn't miss it. What about his explanation leads you to believe that he's town?

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 19 2014 20:57 GMT

#1376

On March 20 2014 05:54 VisceraEyes wrote:
rayn I'd like you to explain why you think thrawn is town. HF raised a really good point about thrawn leaving DP off his PoE list earlier and I don't really know how you missed that. It's pretty blatant.

Seriously I'm getting like no respect this game.

My point about thrawn's third town read being absolute horseshit is far better.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 19 2014 20:59 GMT

#1377

On March 20 2014 05:57 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

Seriously I'm getting like no respect this game.

My point about thrawn's third town read being absolute horseshit is far better.

Palmar you haven't mentioned a single point I've raised about anyone or anything. I don't care if you're butthurt about not being listened to, at least you're being townread for it. I'm being scumread by people who should know better and you don't hear me bitching.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

March 19 2014 20:59 GMT

#1378

He does these things where he bases his read on someone based on only a really small amount of info he finds townie. It does not matter if there is something scummy but the townie things usually override the scummy things (see for example his read on Balla & to some extent bumatlarge in LXIV: Restart). I don't think his read on DarthPunk is good but it's what thrawn does as town. He weighs the townie things and scummy things someone does and makes a read based on both and it's clearly to be seen from his posts. I don't remember him doing that as mafia, at least it does not show from his posts.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 19 2014 21:01 GMT

#1379

On March 20 2014 05:59 VisceraEyes wrote:

Show nested quote +

Who is scumreading you?

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

March 19 2014 21:02 GMT

#1380

On March 20 2014 03:27 thrawn2112 wrote:
excuse me for not wanting to wade through your early shitposting hf. lately I think you've been really townie but that stuff in the beginning reminded me of all the reasons I hate playing mafia. you were being needlessly antagonistic. i'm not dp, and despite not knowing his alignment I felt bad for him because of how you were playing the bully. you were accusing DP of doing nothng while at the same time, spending all of your energy making sure that he can't get anything accomplished thanks to your constant one liner interjections and useless insults. all of which (the insults and useless one liners) made it really hard for me to judge either of you based the arguments you were having, so I decided I wasn't going to care about your alignments until you guys started doing other things. and that is why I asked you to stfu about dp.

so yes, in the context of my job as a townie I am bad for skimming all of that, but I don't care

Also this post reads really townie to me.