III Titanic Mini Mafia: MS Paint Edition - Page 3

On March 20 2014 02:40 Holyflare wrote:
we talked about you earlier, did you not see that?

On March 20 2014 02:28 thrawn2112 wrote:
hopeless is town so i dont care about that question.

ggtmy should probably go on that list but there is something about how this stuff happened that makes me think he might be town:



as for oats, he had been consistently calling me scum up till a point where he wrote a lynch list that didn't innclude me, nowhere in his filter does it indicate that his read on me was changing before that lynch list post. his push on me wa a main component of his play so if he were scum i'd expect him to at least document the fact that his thrawn-read changed, if not give his reasons for the flop, given how scum want to keep their story straight. furthur, the fact that he has reads that change that aren't documented in his posts suggest that he is actualyl thinking about his reads even when he's not posting about them

On March 20 2014 02:46 thrawn2112 wrote:


yes as in, yes I saw it. something you want to talk about?

On March 19 2014 19:35 thrawn2112 wrote:


here is my current pool of lynch candidates, i've arrived at this list by eliminating people who have done things that make me think they must be or probably are town

3. Hopeless1der
4. djodref
5. Holyflare
6. VisceraEyes
11. Oatsmaster
12. GiggleTummy
15. Alakaslam

I never said "VE over some other guys," there are obviously a lot of people in this game that deserve to die

On March 20 2014 02:58 thrawn2112 wrote:


I have no clue. I will say that all those reasons I mentioned could have easily happened as a direct result of you tunneling him. like, dp's non-read on you could be because of the exact same reasons I was having trouble reading you. you were being a huge asshole during that tunnel and it just didn't feel genuine, it felt like you were edging him on to try and force him into looking scummier.

so maybe that's why I included you but ommitted dp, but honestly i do not remember. poe lists tend to be snap decisions for me

On March 20 2014 07:29 Tehpoofter wrote:
@GT Your entire filter is about HF being scum do you have any town reads? Any reads on other scum? Which of the lurkers is most likely to be a good town later assuming they're town. Like the tunneling you're doing on HF seems scummy someone said earlier having only one read tends to be maf sided I have to agree with that.

On March 20 2014 07:53 Palmar wrote:
Thrawn is mafia for his 3rd townread. I don't believe for a second that anyone following the thread could possibly have his third strongest townread at the time on poof who basically said nothing at the time. There was more than enough content in the thread at the time to come up with a reasonable third townread. Not to mention his first 2 townreads was basically just copying thread sentiment (koshi/rayn). And when I pushed him for not including me he had no reason to think I'm mafia, just that one random list with little explanations from poof is better than everything I had posted up to that point based on different expectations of our play.

It's also super interesting and should not be forgotten that poof's venn diagram was missing some pretty obvious people, I think most notably hopeless and giggle, and it included VE who had at the time basically done jack shit. I'm not entirely sure it makes him scum and apparently he knows VE, but it's worth mentioning.