Newbie Mini Mafia LIII

On March 06 2014 07:09 IAmRobik wrote:
sqrt-1,

also, if you don't mind indulging me, how much mafia have you played, and in what environment have you played it in? Video? Forum? IRL? EM? Other?

Thanks boo.

On March 06 2014 09:09 mtamburini wrote:


When I first read IAmRobik and Moose interactions, I was ready to lynch both of them cause I thought there would one between them for sure just based on the fact of them attacking each other. However that view changed once sqrt posted that their opinion on the matter was it was two towns fighting. I'd like an explanation on it as maybe you see something I dont. I am more inclined to sheep Roberts read on the situation and it sounds a little too good.

On March 07 2014 01:43 Moose_ wrote:
My mistake i was under the impression that i made a first post. So i actually didn't like his post at all. I felt like he came in to literally add nothing to the game besides saying that he liked sqrt.

Currently i am going to be keeping my eye on him and i really want to look more into sqrt. and want to to hear his reaction to this.

The only positive thing i can say about the post is that he is paying attention as he realized some of us were using different names for each other.

On March 06 2014 16:24 Thorgear wrote:
since i seem to be the only one posting around this time,i 'll say this. i do want the people who haven't posted yet to say something, but i wouldnt suggest we vote for them.. as i understand it, if they dont post at all during the day, they will get replaced or mod killed. thats why i think we should look at the people that are actually going to reply, as we can get information from that.

On March 07 2014 07:09 mirks wrote:


Thats not what I was implying, I feel if I voice the reason it is too easily mimiced and I'm not trying to let scum know why i townread people.

On March 06 2014 09:09 mtamburini wrote:


When I first read IAmRobik and Moose interactions, I was ready to lynch both of them cause I thought there would one between them for sure just based on the fact of them attacking each other. However that view changed once sqrt posted that their opinion on the matter was it was two towns fighting. I'd like an explanation on it as maybe you see something I dont. I am more inclined to sheep Roberts read on the situation and it sounds a little too good.

On March 07 2014 01:55 mtamburini wrote:
My biggest problem right now is people wanting to lynch the players who have not talked yet, I think that is pretty scummy because they can be replaced and/or mod killed so if they are scum not participating thats great they will be modkilled and we will win that much easier. I feel like the people who are willing to lynch them are just picking on someone who cannot defend themselves making it seem like its a safe lynch.

With regards to Thorgear post it I feel like after 3 pages of posts they would have a lot more to give to us.

My question for Thorgear, you think sqrt is town for the questions hes asking. What do you think of his reads?

Inb4 robert post
inb4 Moose post

On March 07 2014 07:22 mirks wrote:


You already sided with him, for the first half of your reason why he is now mafia.

I don't get how his fight with robert now makes him scum in your eyes when you used that fight to call him your top town?

On March 10 2014 06:00 mtamburini wrote:
Something interesting that happened yesterday was mirks and sqrt both voted on eachother. Generally when I see something like this I immediately think 1 between them.

Sqrt also mentioned that he thought Moose and Robert were just two town fighting. Do you still think that is a fair assessment at this point in the game? Could you and mirks be two town fighting as well?

On March 10 2014 06:58 CPHoya wrote:
mirks you're making it sound like the game comes down to whether the wolf team is exactly sqrt and thor, or Moose and you, and if I have to make that decision I'm going with Moose and you over both of them, based on tone and content

On March 10 2014 07:59 mtamburini wrote:


I was wondering the same thing sqrt. I was happy finally saw me as town, but then the idea of me slipping into a pocket started crossing my mind making me paranoid. Thats why I wanted CPHoya to explain why these lines are possible.

Where is your head at so far besides my question?

On March 10 2014 08:21 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I say no lynch today.
##Vote No Lynch

On March 10 2014 05:32 mirks wrote:
No, I did not get roleblocked.

Also looks like we we wrong on cruisette. I'm sorry for pinging her out first but she was incredibly scummy in my eyes.

Moose - He's looking stranger as the game goes on. I liked his tone on day 1 but he hasn't really contributed anything that has sold me as town. I agree with hoya that him saying the last mafia is really weird.

SQRT - This guy is my number 1 scum. I don't like the way that he voted me yesterday and tried to make it look like I was subvertly trying to get cruisette lynched. Also I said before in my reads it really looked like he knew cruisette was town and was defending a townie for credit. Its a mafia play to defend the person who looks the scummiest and looks like they are gonna get lynched that day. Theres also the connection between him and tambo, where he gave strong reads on tambo being mafia and then proceeds to vote me.

Hoya - I've liked the content you provide so far, but i know you are a strong player in forum mafia and I have no reads as to your alignment.

Thorgear- I'd say thor is my top town. He was on the same page with me yesterday on the sqrt read .I like the way on day 1 he made alot of typos and grammatical errors and I feel like town is more likely to not give a shit what they post. That said, I'd like to hear some more content from him today.

I also agree that not lynching today is the best play. The absolute worst play town can make today fmpov is lynching me and mafia wins.

On March 10 2014 09:14 Thorgear wrote:
i posted earlier on today, after you first posts of the day.
my biggest problem with people going on mirks, is that no one is defending him. and yesterday he could of easily kept his vote on cruisette and made it 2-2 vote count on cruisette at the time.
if we are going to lynch someone today it should be out of the people that voted for cruisette.