[S] Shadowed Mini Mafia - Page 21

On February 05 2014 11:11 JonnyLaw wrote:
The play feels so calculated. An attempt to lead the town without actually leading.

On February 05 2014 11:24 Balla24 wrote:
JL why don't you talk about somebody else too. The world doesn't revolve around you and your cases.

I don't think we're going to get anywhere talking between us 3 about Jay. Unless you have some new information.

On February 05 2014 11:32 jaybrundage wrote:

This stuck out to me. Does making a big case not imply I want to help lead the town. Can you say what you mean here.

On February 05 2014 11:31 jaybrundage wrote:
@Balla I don't mind I'm glad Jonny is taking interest in our towns fate

On February 05 2014 11:35 JonnyLaw wrote:



It's the timing Jay. Your answers come out as I ask you questions.

I still want to know what you think of Oats, and Suki's case on Oats. You like it but don't think Oats is scummy and don't want to vote. Why did you say that about Suki's case? I hate that comment so much.

On February 05 2014 11:33 JonnyLaw wrote:



What do you think of Oats?

Will you lynch hopeless if he's still lurking at vote time?

On February 05 2014 11:40 Balla24 wrote:


I'd lynch hopeless if we can't lynch lonemeow or oats.

Oats hasn't done anything to change my mind since the two cases on him from me and suki. I did like what he said in response to suki's case, but he ignored what I said (understandable considering we discussed it all before I posted my vote) and did nothing beyond defend himself from suki.

I hope we see more from hopeless (pun unintended ROFL). If he continues at THIS rate then I'd lynch him over lonemeow or oats, but if he shows more, then we will see whether that holds true or not.

What do YOU think? You're doing the same thing I was annoyed with Oatsmaster and Lonemeow about.

On February 05 2014 11:23 JonnyLaw wrote:


I'm trying to talk to you Jay. You called Suki scum twice then change your mind once she posts a case on Oats.

What do you think about Oats? You claim to like the case but don't say anything else. I want to know why. You've played with Oats before this game.

We can chat about Lonemeow after this if you'd like. For now, I'm curious about some of your opinions.

On February 05 2014 11:46 JonnyLaw wrote:


I've asked Jay the same question five times without getting an answer.

I won't lynch Oats today. I read two of his town games and played scum with him in lolpyp. He seems interested enough in this game and it's not different than his normal town play. He could be scum but don't think he's the best d1 lynch.

I've said lynch lurkers since day1. Kill hopeless if he doesn't play.

I'm trying to have a conversation and flesh out how you two sit. You're kinda just agreeing with Jay. That's why I asked specific questions.

On February 05 2014 09:07 JonnyLaw wrote:
Anyway, that was fruitless. The filters could be from the same game. Oats put a little more effort into the normal game but it was a much larger and faster game. I'm going to reread the thread. I'm missing something obvious and the game's still short.

On February 05 2014 11:49 jaybrundage wrote:


Yes I thought suki was scummy before. Her thing about not calling Jonny scum but interesting or what ever word she used did bother me. She just seemed to have no point to your posts. However with her case on Oats it showed that she wasn't just trying to appear to be posting. She actually was analyzing the game and looking for scum. So my read turned on her. Is it possible she's scum that noticed she was getting heat and decided to post a case? Sure possible. But I think the most likely possibility at this point is town.

I don't remember Oats too well in my previous games. He was never someone I really suspected. He can be hard to draw a bead on sometimes. Not a huge poster mostly short clip comments. I even had to go back and look briefly at the LoL PYP game. I think the case made good points I hadn't noticed before. Oats was not on my lynch list before Suki posted her case. And she made a good enough case for me to consider lynching him.

Also I felt the reason to make my own case because I want to contribute to the town. I didn't plan to just sheep Suki's read and just say yea I like all this Ill join. Because I wanted to post my own analysis I got's me an ego you know. Also by posting other scummy people we can choose as a town who we want to go for based on the information we have.

On February 05 2014 11:55 Oatsmaster wrote:
Suki's case was bad though, it all hinged on the point that I thought objecting to koshi's policy was scummy. Which I never said. All I said was that it was what I thought koshi was doing if he was town.

Hopeless, why are you playing scummily different from the past 2-3 games?

On February 05 2014 00:49 Balla24 wrote:


Can you explain a bit more?

1. How does Koshi posting something "bad" make it bait for scum to jump on? Basically: what will scum do with it?
2. Did anybody jump on it?
3. Was this your first thought when you read it?

On February 05 2014 00:57 Oatsmaster wrote:
1. Scum will go and shit on Koshi for it because its bad and scummy.
2. yeah suki and some other dudes.
3. My first thought was why is koshi proposing such a useless policy.

mannnn Koshi's shitposting is AFTER his first post.

On February 05 2014 11:56 Oatsmaster wrote:
Oh man jay why are you so concerned on what people think about you?