Extractor Trick Mini Mafia - Page 2

On January 04 2014 08:50 raynpelikoneet wrote:
So you do want to policy lynch me for claiming without thinking about my alignment?

On January 04 2014 08:57 raynpelikoneet wrote:

If i do not lynch mafia on D1 then i have definitely made a mistake but in my opinion this gives me much higher chances of lynching scum. I don't have to worry about people worrying about me. As i said me being parity cop is same as me being vanilla. I get a first scum check at best on D3. In my opinion at that point of the game there should be 2 mafia dead already. If there is not i am doing something wrong. If i am alive on D3 i am doing something wrong. Therefore me being a parity cop has no upsides besides the fact that if i claim it people can actually trust me and trust my thoughts to have a townie agenda without thinking about the possible scum motivations behind them.

On January 04 2014 08:59 raynpelikoneet wrote:

But you just said this:

Especially the bolded part. You do not explain why i am scum for claiming. You jsut say you want to lynch me for my claim. You never explain why my calim makes sense from a scum perspective.

Either elaborate on why am i scum or drop it. Right now.

On January 04 2014 09:04 raynpelikoneet wrote:
One more post about discussing this without explaining why i am scum and i am policy lynching you Slam.

On January 04 2014 09:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:
You have now made 4 posts about my claim where you say "he could be town or he could be scum".
Which is it? If you don't know do something else. Being wishy-washy about it does not get you anywhere.

So which is it, town or scum?

On January 04 2014 09:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay so Slam is town but just very stupid.

On January 04 2014 10:59 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
a counterclaim nets us 1 mafia guarenteed, not a scummy play. Cant let a fakeclaim go un cc'd anyway.

sent there are reasons gum looks bad and thats not one of them. i domt see how rayn is mafia fakeclaiming cop without a cc, and i hv no reason to distrust in that. fuck parity cop, esp with potential gf

On January 04 2014 11:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:
thrawn why would i claim parity cop as mafia instead of just.. you know, not claiming?

On January 04 2014 12:03 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
This is a pointless convo imo.

Im actually liking gum/yam +1 maf

On January 05 2014 13:18 kushm4sta wrote:
So here are the unknown right now:

alakaslam:
Well his early game is way more try hard than the towngame I just played with him recently. I would hope this means I am getting better somehow.
Then his activity falls off, which is a pretty good scumtell in itself usually, especially when there is no excuse to explain it. this is loaded accusation. Blazinghand, I was eating dinner bro. I could ask where you were like ALL OF DAY 1...
Overall his activity points fits with what I perceive his scumgame to look like. it is impossible to defend a meta argument. If you see it that way what am I supposed to do?
Then there is this post:

like wut...blue hunting?! Yes I thought he was trying to set up a counterclaim, hadn't thought the setup through- I don't usually do that @Alaka I want to know how rayne was blue hunting. Also I have no idea why you would jump to the conclusion that rayne was fakeclaiming, Go read that exchange again. I didn't jump to that conclusion I kept saying it was a bad move and thought his replies were scummy- an attitude I have since revoked anyway. since he gave a decent explanation for why he claimed and claiming as scum would be pretty suicidal. Yes... You have passed over my acknowledgement of those facts and his post on it.
Scummers love to accuse townies of blue hunting. I feel like i see it all the time.
conclusion: SCUM

~~~~~~

hopeless
His position on gumshoe throughout d1 makes no sense.
First he soft defends him.

To this:

Suddenly Gumshoe is a good lynch for no reason other than he didn't read before. I would expect a townie hopeless to have like a sentence explaining what aspect of the argument convinced him.

Otherwise there has been a total lack of content from hopeless. This is the feedback I was looking for earlier. I know your opinion on RNG would have been biased though. He's done some mechanics posts and some troll posts, but his scumhunting is practically non existent. I remember his towngame as having a similar length filter but being more focused on logical scumhunting.

Conclusion: SCUM


coag
There is no amount of effort shown this game, which leans scummy to me. It seems like in his town games, he makes an effort to show you he is town. He doesn't do that at all here.

He loves to do this too scummy to be scum shit as scum.
Conclusion: SCUM
Coag has the power of deep SVENGALI toward me
(I cannot ever form a smidgen of some kind of read on him)
~~~~~~~~

yamato
town. just town. His early suspicion on thrawn doesn't look like a bus. Plus process of elimination (I already have one too many scummers lol)

~~~~~

So one of my scumreads is town. I'm guessing it's either hopeless or coag, because both are pretty unreadable.

On January 05 2014 17:59 kushm4sta wrote:
like he's being clear but not about finding scum

On January 05 2014 18:16 kushm4sta wrote:


I think readability is a choice he makes, and therefore it's a null tell.

On January 05 2014 15:58 Coagulation wrote:


so this exchange makes rayn look pretty solid town imo


[UoN]Sentinel is vig obv town



Yamato is playing piss poor and im leaning scum on him. Hes using pretty shit logic like




alakaslam has been lurker hunting the entire game and thats a red flag. scum like to focus on lurker discussion a lot. gonna fos on slam. likely scum.


Kush looks town to me so far. but that aint worth shit cause hes unreadable.


Mr. Cheesecake is vet. gonna assume its legit.


Hopeless1der sorta got a scum vibe but dunno. mostly null

and of course these reads come with the

On January 05 2014 18:20 kushm4sta wrote:
alaka why are you taking about rng on d2 LOL

On January 05 2014 18:25 kushm4sta wrote:
coag is actually super town for realizing this.
coag:

this is dead on

On January 04 2014 10:42 Hopeless1der wrote:
well thats 1 more to hammer. who wants the honor?

On January 05 2014 18:49 Hopeless1der wrote:
Yamato didnt consider that scum might shoot him...where is his town ego? I'm calling shenanigans. Dudes scum.