EPTOn January 23 2014 06:03 Foolishness wrote:
No, but Marvellosity is known for getting things done on day 1.
Show nested quote +
On January 23 2014 05:53 WaveofShadow wrote:
There's a lot of 'overall play' I'm disappointed with atm, Prome included to some degree.
Does it make those people scum?
On January 23 2014 05:51 Foolishness wrote:
I'm not upset with any of Marv's individual posts, but his overall play so far.
On January 23 2014 05:47 WaveofShadow wrote:
Yeah...I'm in agreement with a lot of marv stuff from his filter, and the timing at which he posted stuff. One thing that stuck out is the above.
I'm wondering why marv gave me a ??? at that point considering it seems likely he thought I was town before that from his attitude towards me.
Meh..maybe not.
And then this comes after my return
I guess I expect marv to know...I dunno...more about me? Maybe why I was shocked he found me scummy in those games because I don't believe i've shifted my meta all that much in between games, and town-marv always seems to find me town eventually for all the right reasons.
Yeah....would not lynch, but marv you left me high and dry---our palaver did not quench my thirst for you this game. (And it's basically become tradition at this point)
On January 22 2014 07:50 marvellosity wrote:
I think his post looks reasonable townie and there's a lot of effort. I'm not sure how much i agree with his reads atm
kita lower, prome higher, marv much much higher, WoS ??, gonzaw higher
But his reasoning feels townie - putting me where I am because I'm forgettable, while ego crushing I like it as an angle to take, it's non-routine
i think he's capable of these posts as mafia, especially after the champions game, and the way he made a list at the end was actually eerily similar to how he made lists at the end of those posts :p but overall the meat of it made sense. and he's trying
On January 22 2014 07:45 Hapahauli wrote:
Would this suggest that you agree with Fool's reads, or do you just think his post is a town-tell?
Do you think he's capable of faking those kinds of posts as scum?
On January 22 2014 07:37 marvellosity wrote:
ok he can stay for now
##unvote
ok he can stay for now
##unvote
Would this suggest that you agree with Fool's reads, or do you just think his post is a town-tell?
Do you think he's capable of faking those kinds of posts as scum?
I think his post looks reasonable townie and there's a lot of effort. I'm not sure how much i agree with his reads atm
kita lower, prome higher, marv much much higher, WoS ??, gonzaw higher
But his reasoning feels townie - putting me where I am because I'm forgettable, while ego crushing I like it as an angle to take, it's non-routine
i think he's capable of these posts as mafia, especially after the champions game, and the way he made a list at the end was actually eerily similar to how he made lists at the end of those posts :p but overall the meat of it made sense. and he's trying
Yeah...I'm in agreement with a lot of marv stuff from his filter, and the timing at which he posted stuff. One thing that stuck out is the above.
I'm wondering why marv gave me a ??? at that point considering it seems likely he thought I was town before that from his attitude towards me.
Meh..maybe not.
And then this comes after my return
On January 23 2014 02:49 marvellosity wrote:
Wave is waffling earnestly at length as I'd expect him to. Although he's only got one scumgame, I'd very much expect him to be more direct than he has been if mafia. I've been suspicious of him in two reasonably recent games for being slow and waffly (##, LXIV) and now it just seems it's how he opens day 1 as town. So maybe not obvious after all. I just think his thought process is transparent. Like he's posted a lot of his thought process, where's his agenda?
Mainly with Holy that he seems angrier than was justified. But most of all it's the constant niggling at Hapa, especially with his last post(s) when Hapa was by a large margin the towniest guy in the thread. It's just not natural at all. Tbh I don't make a massive amount of his absence, I believe he'd be here posting as either alignment, so not that alignment indicative.
On January 23 2014 02:43 kitaman27 wrote:
Could you expand on this, even if it's brief? I didn't pick up on the obvious reason. Mine read was more based on the lack of anything wrong, rather than an abundance of anything he has done that is helpful.
Also, could you justify your Holyflare vote for me with specifics? You mention that you thought gonzaw's points were good. Is that what you're going by or is the vote mostly due to his absence from the thread?
I currently don't have a strong preference between sandroba and Holyflare and it seems like sandroba hasn't been inspired to rejoin the thread. I'll vote with you for the time being.
##Unvote
##Vote Holyflare
On January 22 2014 22:53 marvellosity wrote:
Wave looks better, for obvious reasons
On January 22 2014 22:49 kitaman27 wrote:
I'd much rather hear who marv is considering voting, rather than defending a player he thinks is town.
I'd much rather hear who marv is considering voting, rather than defending a player he thinks is town.
Wave looks better, for obvious reasons
Could you expand on this, even if it's brief? I didn't pick up on the obvious reason. Mine read was more based on the lack of anything wrong, rather than an abundance of anything he has done that is helpful.
Also, could you justify your Holyflare vote for me with specifics? You mention that you thought gonzaw's points were good. Is that what you're going by or is the vote mostly due to his absence from the thread?
I currently don't have a strong preference between sandroba and Holyflare and it seems like sandroba hasn't been inspired to rejoin the thread. I'll vote with you for the time being.
##Unvote
##Vote Holyflare
Wave is waffling earnestly at length as I'd expect him to. Although he's only got one scumgame, I'd very much expect him to be more direct than he has been if mafia. I've been suspicious of him in two reasonably recent games for being slow and waffly (##, LXIV) and now it just seems it's how he opens day 1 as town. So maybe not obvious after all. I just think his thought process is transparent. Like he's posted a lot of his thought process, where's his agenda?
Mainly with Holy that he seems angrier than was justified. But most of all it's the constant niggling at Hapa, especially with his last post(s) when Hapa was by a large margin the towniest guy in the thread. It's just not natural at all. Tbh I don't make a massive amount of his absence, I believe he'd be here posting as either alignment, so not that alignment indicative.
I guess I expect marv to know...I dunno...more about me? Maybe why I was shocked he found me scummy in those games because I don't believe i've shifted my meta all that much in between games, and town-marv always seems to find me town eventually for all the right reasons.
Yeah....would not lynch, but marv you left me high and dry---our palaver did not quench my thirst for you this game. (And it's basically become tradition at this point)
I'm not upset with any of Marv's individual posts, but his overall play so far.
There's a lot of 'overall play' I'm disappointed with atm, Prome included to some degree.
Does it make those people scum?
No, but Marvellosity is known for getting things done on day 1.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=389088&user=SuckMyTopdeck
Read his filter there (he's hydra with SnB), and tell me if it changes your read on him or not.
