On January 28 2014 23:46 Promethelax wrote:
Why if HF's play likelier town?
HF played weakly and his scum play is strong. Therefore his weak play is more likely to be town. I imagine he was somewhat intimidated by the playerlist. Lord knows I was.

Why is it idiotic to call out both your scum buddies the same way as likely town for shit posting?
Because jesus, once one of those guys flips we look back and go "oh hey look X said Y and Z were town for the same shitty reason. I bet X was full of shit, lets lynch Y and Z"

Townies never say this. Because of the reasons you're bitching about. They think "oh we got the mafia from that part of the list"

wifomwifomwifom

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 14:56 GMT

#2251

On January 28 2014 23:48 kitaman27 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Is the rest of the case valid to the point where you like it more than the case against toad?

I don't think so. Although I've been a little bit tunnelvisioned on toad, which is part of the reason maybe. The post that Prome points out of austin waffling about Fool is kinda nasty.

Mostly it's that i think prome is being dumb with that particular bit of reasoning.

Tell me what you think, kita.

Any issues I have with austin are of a more recent nature, regarding his activity/pushes. He was late to deciding on anything on day 1, which is fine, because he's right,he does always play like that. But he was late committing anything on day 2 as well (VE when VE was basically dead already) and he's late doing anything today. I swear he had the same length of filter as me at some point.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 15:05 GMT

#2258

On January 29 2014 00:02 austinmcc wrote:
marv, how do you connect prome's ego with the non-committal/committal stuff in foolishness's case? Just feeling like player caliber is high makes him less sure of things?

yeah. Like Fool posts 3 posts of Promes with red stuff highlighted. First one is Prome's opinion, and the 2nd two look like Prome just weighing up gonzaw's read heavily because he trusts (+ respects) him. Prome might as well answer that thought process himself to be fair.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 15:10 GMT

#2260

Vote shenannies pretty sexy. Although seems like they're going to end up being kinda unsexy after all.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:24 GMT

#2281

austin, I can't really say I understand why this is so problematic for you. I didn't really get it when you first brought it up either.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:26 GMT

#2283

And normally when I don't understand why you're putting so much weight on something, it's not because I don't understand.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:27 GMT

#2285

P.S. it was themed game mafia that you referenced earlier without knowing the name, and it was kita/me/gonz/crossfire

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:31 GMT

#2287

it's true, that is our eternal dance. It *might* say more about you than me though.

ref: the activity/prome thing. Prome said x and y posts felt off amongst the sea of posts that felt good. As mafia he could just blanketly say "activity = good, yea bros?",... but he's mindful of a couple of posts he's seen still. That he doesn't have to point out if he's scum if he's making a blanket townread on activity. You're painting this as if there's only one plausible narrative

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:39 GMT

#2290

MIght as well just fence-sit for a while longer, eh Toad?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 16:47 GMT

#2293

Too many people way too non-committal too close to deadline. When Wave is away and my activity will be patchy once I leave work (exercise/dinner/shower/bf/broken laptop i can't take to bf's etc)

Fool mafia. Prome town. Final answer. Gogo lynch.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:18 GMT

#2307

austin if a body of posts in general is good, why does someone need to go around picking out individual ones for the thread to see? To what end? It serves no use as far as lynching mafia goes.

You're being irked because you're being silly even though you're the only one who thinks this is actually particularly important. Why?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:24 GMT

#2311

I have no idea what Toad is talking about most of the time, which is why I've been so insistent on picking on kinda "sideways" details like holy's posts + VE being mysteriously easy to read after days of apathy.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:26 GMT

#2313

he's only the manager of the whole forum, kita, how can he be expected to know

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:37 GMT

#2318

austin, it doesn't look bad for me at all, are you insane? It's nothing to do with "seeing" what you're talking about. It's whether it actually means that someone is scummy. I've been pretty clear that it isn't. kita also says that it isn't. You're the only one pushing this...?

IF someone has, say, 100 good posts and 2 posts, which do you highlight?
Or maybe do you say "gosh there's a bunch of good posts, but these are the 2 exceptions"?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:39 GMT

#2319

On January 29 2014 02:33 austinmcc wrote:
Grrr, I'm bad at putting full reasoning into posts this game. The above post should include, in the paragraph about "so it's extra irksome..."

that VE saw what I was seeing concerning the first thing I was poking at prome on. Sandroba didn't.

I'm interested in whether people are seeing what I'm talking about in the second thing I'm poking at prome on.

If, in both cases, townies are at least SEEING what I'm getting at, even if come to a different conclusion/think I'm overvaluing something, then it looks bad for you that you're saying each time you just don't care in either case and don't understand why I do.

I sincerely wish I found it as interesting as you and VE seem to :p

I see, I find not that interesting, I know Prome. etc.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:46 GMT

#2321

This is going nowhere. Are you going to think about anything else austin, or is this somehow the be all and end all?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

January 28 2014 17:55 GMT

#2328

Probably because I'm sexy, with a particularly pert bottom. I do apologise to my utmost for still existing though, kita :>

And I was referring to the Prome-WoS-townread thing, rather than anything else.