Newbie Mini Mafia L - Page 2

On October 31 2013 01:55 onlywonderboy wrote:

That seems...very aggro. I don't think there's anything wrong with giving people a heads up if you're going to be MIA. I mean I guess scum could hide behind those sort of posts, but just just putting a blanket out there that all MIA warnings are scummy seems weird to be.

On October 31 2013 14:54 OdinOfPergo wrote:
ROFL LOL I DIED ON THE FLOOR HAHHAHAHAHAHA OMG.
OK guys soirry. Seriously.
But just look at this.

Fucking mod kill this traitor on principle.
OKOKOK Sorry, expect to see this same quote when I post my case on him.
But I couldn't let this slide ROFL

On October 31 2013 15:06 Obzy wrote:
I don't really expect to be sheeped; being confirmed doesn't exactly make my reads better, or more correct. You can just be certain that they're genuine lol. Storr, your post just now, once again, doesn't actually say anything about reads. It talks about general ideas in the game of mafia as a whole, but you don't seem to have opinions on anybody actually in the game except me because I'm IC.

I don't really think anybody's done that yet - maybe Von, a little bit, with his read dump - but he's getting quite rightly lambasted for it. Rather, you actually haven't looked closely at anybody, you've merely stated that it would be wise to be wary of the people that are following the confirmed townie, because you yourself are currently that confirmed townie's target blah blah blah.

Your recent post didn't actually say anything relevant to the game at hand, even though you're here, and capable of doing so.

On October 31 2013 15:14 Balla24 wrote:


Can't you simply say that what you are doing right now, discussing sheepign on the IC (when nobody in particular is doing this, although you might be trying to subtly jab at me, I can't tell) is exactly "a great way to stay under the radar and provide "content" without actually doing anything."

Who in particular do you think is doing what you're saying?

On October 30 2013 10:07 cakemanofdoom wrote:
Storr's post seems to be just trying to randomly add suspicion on Balla. There's no justification behind it, only a weak suggestion that the post might be bad somehow. Almost like he's hoping for someone else to jump in and find a reason to get Balla lynched.

On November 01 2013 01:30 cakemanofdoom wrote:
The main thing I have against E00e right now is that he barely talks, and only when prodded. His post content... well, they could be worse. I'd be happier lynching July or Storr than E00e. July's point is decent in his first post, but everything else is just suspicious. Storr just hasn't been seriously helpful.

poofter: Sure, the fact that you attack me makes sense. I still don't like the "new evidence" you brought while doing so, and according to you we've agreed to disagree or something like that. From there on, your posts until your case on me make sense, but they also aren't very useful.

To reiterate, I think you're scummy because you haven't contributed anything substantial, but you've posted enough that it could be mafia pretending to be helpful. I think I've already phrased it like that, and I don't like how you cherry pick my openmindedness to criticize while ignoring the more direct accusations I make. You've accused me of twisting facts, but right now it seems like you're flat out ignoring some of them. You look very scum at the end of that post.

##Vote: Tehpoofter


I'll be back to switch my vote if this doesn't gain traction.
E00e if it's the only thing going. July or Storr if enough support.

Not sure what to think about nyx? His posts aren't good, and people seem to agree with that, but it also looks like he's getting something of a pass because it's similar to bad posting from a previous game where he was town. Right now, though, he's had two retracted scumreads, and suspicion on poofter. I like the suspicion on poofter, but I'd still lynch if it was the only thing that would go through based on his lack of good posting earlier.

Storr... thoughts are the same as in my previous post. Sure, he's recognizable, but it's not much use if he's not reading people. His directing the town to be productive is nice, but it's also fairly common-sense. Seems like an easy way for scum to pretend to be helpful. I was inclined to wait for his reads, but there isn't as much time for that right now.

Summary of my vote preferences in order: poofter, Storr, July, E00e, nyx.

On October 31 2013 01:22 July617 wrote:



If apologetic-ness/ questiony-ness is suspicious, then doesn't your post sound like a bit of an apology? "You're going to "try" and make reads (Often times mafia "try" to make reads to look like they're contributing ) , and you also agree with Jonny's points but you still question parts of it because they sound like a stretch ?
I dunno, maybe i'm reading too into it or maybe i'm not but that's my town post for now .

On October 31 2013 04:12 July617 wrote:


Because when I read what other people post, i just don't see what they're grasping for . Now imagine if you felt like that most of the game. People will obviously call you scum when in reality i'd just like a clearer explanation.

On November 01 2013 02:01 July617 wrote:


Sounds like a mafia play to me .

On November 01 2013 03:18 July617 wrote:


He's acting allot like Sagaz did in our last game and Sagaz turned out to be mafia, he's really agro for no apparent reason, attacking nyx mostly in his filter on page 2 and then grasping for straws on page 3 . Suspicious yes, either way whoever dies tonight we'll see what they flip whether they be town / mafia / or blue, I honestly feel like we're going in circles here, I'd like to just lynch and be done with it and see what happens day 2. I don't think we're going to get anything more from today, not unless someone screws up and slips .

On November 01 2013 05:26 July617 wrote:



Cake i picked him because he's inactive and I though lynching inactive was a priority|?

On November 01 2013 06:09 JonnyLaw wrote:
@obzy I know what you're saying and I've considered it quite a lot. I've made my points on Odin confusing the thread and won't elaborate.

Which lurker would you prefer to lynch in favor of Odin? Nyx? Owb? July? Storr? I've gone over the cases in my head a few times and reread their posting. OWB and Nyx are just difficult to read. July's posting doesn't give me a scummy vibe. I'm neutral there. Storr...I don't know at this point. I like the Odin lynch.

Quick question for everyone. If you had control of seven votes who would you lynch today and why?