btw, was really surprised to see mafia didn't figure out koshi and I + cobratank

I thought it was one of the worst kept secrets imaginable, but apparently it did the trick

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 09:39 GMT

#4837

On November 11 2013 14:42 cDgCorazon wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well it would be nice to have a decent ratio of in-depth posts instead of being spammy.

Apologies for being an instrumental part in town convincingly winning. I feel terrible.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 10:20 GMT

#4839

I wasn't going to post much more, I'd done my mass posting for the game ;]

Only started thinking about the game at all when I started to think s&b would probably flip town after all, and that HCC was mafia after all (sparked by Koshi's "there has been no controversy around VA this game")

I did enjoy your letter. Actually my biggest mistake regarding you was trying to get Koshi's validation for my read too much, should have given pushing you on Day 2 a go :p

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 10:41 GMT

#4841

na, there were just too many lil reasons that you didn't feel like town.

that's always how i'll catch players like you, mostly.

edit: it's why i was annoyed at koshi when i asked him to show me the things that he said made you feel town and he wouldn't. I was just like... ugh -.- that's so unhelpful lol

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 10:50 GMT

#4844

On November 11 2013 19:45 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Yeah i know. Like i said, i felt the same way in Desert. Something is not right but i can't fucking make a case on it. :p

EDIT: Also did you read why we hit Pandain? ^_^

Show nested quote +

Turns out it wasn't quite right lol

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 10:51 GMT

#4845

On November 11 2013 19:48 Promethelax wrote:
Yeah I stopped pasting because life took over. What I've learned from this game is that I still don't have enough time to play mafia well.

I thought you played fine on day 1. Just after obviously other things happened.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 10:58 GMT

#4847

Not quite sure how you read Pandain as thinking like that, from his filter + postgame comment, looks like he was mostly following my read on you? shrug ^^

btw the reason HCC passed me by for so long is that i'm quite used to Vayne pushing his agenda as mafia, which he didn't seem to do here at all. He just let scum get lynched. it was weird.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:07 GMT

#4849

I'd have said s&b was the best equivalent to that this game, and he did indeed give that up which I thought was good play on Pandain's part.

Yeah his kush thing was kinda weird in Golden Sun, read his filter there because you were pushing him on Day 2

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:13 GMT

#4851

naw, kush got lynched because we were lazy + his bluepower (which was us being lazy again). I was pretty over his scumread on me by the time we lynched him.

Honestly, it hasn't been mentioned, but the best thing about fighting a lynch reasonably hard as mafia (which you did at certain points) is that it tired me out and I cba to think anymore after I lynched you :p I'm not used to lynching some mafia and then remaining alive :/

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:22 GMT

#4853

On November 11 2013 20:16 raynpelikoneet wrote:
That was the point of my D2 -> D3. I thought i even said it in scum QT. <3
And at least Crossfire found it enjoyable haha. I just typed and typed everything that came to my mind.

yeah tbh I don't know why I kept engaging with you. I think mostly because some other people seemed unsure even though it was really obvious by that stage.

When you said "marv is 3p" and koshi said "marv could be 3p" I was just like... lame... lol

Pretty happy I made you use your relegate on d2 even though you shouted at me for it ;p

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:27 GMT

#4855

yeah i thought Cloister was silent too until someone brought it up like days and days later. Didn't read closely enough.

Maybe your PM was jinxed... it was impossible to read it correctly for anyone... haha

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:34 GMT

#4857

speaking of such things, i don't have that much to say about the balance, but I think Cloister being a silent action would probably have been a good idea. What with night action resolution period, it becomes very risky to use it (like you mention), so probably would have been better if you could use it without worrying.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:46 GMT

#4859

Was kinda suspicious of the name tbh, when I looked it up didn't seem like it would simply be medic.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 11:52 GMT

#4861

yeah, I'd probably have rolled with it more if you'd said jail, that makes more sense from the description of the word. Dunno where Crossfire came up with that one in the first place lol

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 12:47 GMT

#4864

any flavour theory is bad, and we didn't lynch oats in the end anyways.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 12:54 GMT

#4866

his theory was totally wrong in ACME

and most theories which involve "x isn't mafia because of y reason" will probably be right because statistically x is unlikely to be mafia... doesn't mean it's because of y though

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 16:13 GMT

#4871

On November 12 2013 00:55 cDgCorazon wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well when you do this as town you are on a very thin line. If you are right and actually listening to people and things are going good, then you get the credit.

However, if you act like how Rayn did in Titanic, then you basically get blamed for the loss.

ya, and this happened to me in Personality 2, as you well know

fortunately i'm sexy enough that that was an exception rather than a common occurrence.

Plus I was PMing with rayn about this a little earlier actually. Didn't mean to post a lot originally, and on Day 1 I don't think I really spammed at all, I just posted a fuckton (there's a difference). At some point I realised I had a large filter, and just thought fuck it, I'm gonna post a lot.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 16:19 GMT

#4872

Just as an aside, "content" is really not cramming cases into one post and such.

I tend to build my cases up over a period of time, adding points to it as the game progresses, and following through with the case or ditching it. Everything doesn't have to be consolidated into long posts for there to be "content".

Like in this game i added to the case against Seuss/Onegu and basically made the case on rayn, it was just split over many posts. Doesn't make it any less content.

edit: that's not to say a tonne of my posts weren't pointless this game of course :p

marvellosity

United Kingdom36160 Posts

November 11 2013 21:35 GMT

#4879

On November 12 2013 05:45 VayneAuthority wrote:

Show nested quote +

It's a pretty inconsequential skill to have in the end and one that I don't really dwell on. I probably would have shot some one in the middle like SnB or Pandain night one, so it wouldn't have made much difference but shooting marv n1 is just a bad idea ><

I think this is the first time I've ever been saved night 1...