|
On October 03 2013 16:52 Dirkzor wrote:
I recently looked into sloosh (and found a gem I think). I am waiting for him to answer... Also in Rayn after BH asked and his case. But you would know if you read the thread as you so kindly advocated earlier that people do before asking questions...
I know my vote is on him. So?
Okay so when you say "some of the things that made me think HF is scum have been proven wrong" you're saying there are still things that make you confident in your read?
Could you please explain why you think HF is scum, or is it still purely based on feel?
|
On October 03 2013 17:06 Dirkzor wrote:
I don't think he is a good lynch if that's what you are asking...
BUT YOU'RE VOTING HIM
Ugh... okay. Who do you think is a good lynch?
|
marv, is dirk lynchbait? He's starting to feel like it 
Sloosh was right at the very least about him being consistent >.<
|
Man this sheeping me thing sure is working out for you, eh marv?
I dunno about Risen.
Confirmation bias cases is kind of what he does as town. I haven't seen him play scum though.
His "woe is me, does thou not listen to reason?" and then leaving.... I can see that coming from town Risen OR scum Risen.
Because yes, the last couple of games risen goes for a weird target and ends up being talked down to because of it.
Yes, he decided I was scum and then made a case, but townies do that too. I'm not comfortable lynching him today.
I could lynch rayn I guess but that would basically be a policy lynch, and I think after game of thrones I have learned my lesson and can figure him out in later cycles.
Sloosh, are you around? I'd like you to explain how you feel good about my lynch?
Also explain how my "waffle" on BH is scummy, please.
|
I was referring to this:
On October 03 2013 17:44 Clarity_nl wrote:marv, is dirk lynchbait? He's starting to feel like it Sloosh was right at the very least about him being consistent >.<
Although mainly joking >.>
|
On October 03 2013 18:42 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2013 18:39 Clarity_nl wrote:
Man this sheeping me thing sure is working out for you, eh marv?
I dunno about Risen.
Confirmation bias cases is kind of what he does as town. I haven't seen him play scum though.
His "woe is me, does thou not listen to reason?" and then leaving.... I can see that coming from town Risen OR scum Risen.
Because yes, the last couple of games risen goes for a weird target and ends up being talked down to because of it.
Yes, he decided I was scum and then made a case, but townies do that too. I'm not comfortable lynching him today.
I could lynch rayn I guess but that would basically be a policy lynch, and I think after game of thrones I have learned my lesson and can figure him out in later cycles.
Sloosh, are you around? I'd like you to explain how you feel good about my lynch?
Also explain how my "waffle" on BH is scummy, please. The problem with this whole post is that it lists people you don't want to lynch, but doesn't really offer people you do want to lynch.
Well, that's kinda where I'm at.
Oats is a mystery wrapped in a conundrum for me, sloosh is probably closest to lynchable for me right now, hence my post asking in questioning him
|
english difficult, me hollander
|
Not really, no. I really disliked the way he entered the thread.
His early townread on dirk still confuses me. Only just now after he's still derping with his vote do I begin to believe he's being lynchbait.
Like, he got lectured on his vote being important and it should have weight behind it, and then he goes and says the guy hes voting for is not a good lynch. That's not scum play.... probably.
|
I'm not seeing what you're seeing regarding sloosh. His convo with you was kinda forced on him by you.
He made a comment on BH saying that I was on his dick...?
|
On October 03 2013 18:54 Oatsmaster wrote:
Well Risen is scum mainly for not explaining his unvote on Holyflare, also his opportunistic push on Clarity after somebody raised concerns.
It feels like for me he is going from one target to the next. Like, Hey Holyflare looks scummy lets push him. Then oh man cant lynch, ok Clarity looks ok.
Yeah.
How is this different from town pushing someone, then realizing they're town, then finding a different target
Who expressed concern about me before Risen made his case?
|
On October 03 2013 18:56 Oatsmaster wrote:
meh I dont get why Dirk looks town to you, marv and clarity.
He doesn't, but he's starting to look like >not scum< with the way he's been acting since the pressure got put on.
|
|
|
On October 03 2013 19:11 Oatsmaster wrote:
huh ok Risen was the first to say that Clarity was scummy.
Not sure how you guys think that it affects my read on him.
Has to do with you saying his case on me was opportunistic
Because if he's the first one to make a case on me, how is that opportunistic?
|
On October 03 2013 19:07 Oatsmaster wrote:Look at this post by Dirkzor Show nested quote +On October 03 2013 17:06 Dirkzor wrote:I don't think he is a good lynch if that's what you are asking... There are something about him. He posts the way I would If I was scum. Openly and making cases without really following through with anything. Like this post Link. It is a good constructed post and actually have some good points, but where is the punch at the end. What is he trying to do beside having thread presence? So, yeah it is still somewhat feel based... He says that Sloosh made a good post. And somehow twists it into something that is scummy. Why?
The post you quoted is about HF btw.
|
I think people are giving too much credit to what dirkzor pointed out. It was pretty obvious, why wouldn't scum point it out?
|
Oh my god oats are you an actual person?
|
On October 03 2013 19:37 marvellosity wrote:
Who's "people"? Check out why I unvoted him, it wasn't that.
You and bh I supposed. Although yes, I know that's not why you unvoted him.
BH especially, he basically said "because he pointed this out I will not lynch him today"
|
On October 03 2013 19:47 Dirkzor wrote:
Why was/is sloosh so sure I'm town? I'm having a hard time to figure this out. His reasoning and the way he see my timeline fit rather good with reality, but why did he come to that conclusion when no one else did/have? I know I'm town, but I also know that my first post wasn't stellar... Why was he defending me?
Maybe it only looks weird to me since I know my alignment is town, but it looks preemptive if I was lynched.
Anyone agree?
Seeing as I basically posted this. Yes, I agree.
|
On October 03 2013 19:51 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2013 19:47 Dirkzor wrote:
Why was/is sloosh so sure I'm town? I'm having a hard time to figure this out. His reasoning and the way he see my timeline fit rather good with reality, but why did he come to that conclusion when no one else did/have? I know I'm town, but I also know that my first post wasn't stellar... Why was he defending me?
Maybe it only looks weird to me since I know my alignment is town, but it looks preemptive if I was lynched.
Anyone agree? Yeah it is kinda interesting. Need to give it some thought. also ##UnvoteOats' answers have been reasonably satisfying to me. Well, as satisfying as Oats answers can really be.
You need a real man, marv. Call me.
Anyway, dirk you should join me on the wagon of justice, in honor of iamp.
##unvote
##vote Sloosh
|
That super townread on risen though.
rayn how do you feel about risen's defeatist attitude shortly after posting his case?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
