onlywonderboy has two highly suspicious players voting him. I can't follow them into that trap.

If owb is lynched and mafia we still cannot exclude them from also being mafia since we have three inactive players. He could be a sacrificial lamb to get pressure off them. Lynching playerboy is the way to go.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 29 2013 21:52 GMT

#374

Also, blurry even though things came up I appreciate you at least showing up and making a perfunctory effort. Seriously, those other two suck

and you suck slightly less than them.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 29 2013 21:54 GMT

#378

To be fair, if owb is mafia there's a good chance blurry is as well. He's posted 4? times and calls out owb and votes himself.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 29 2013 22:21 GMT

#387

Yeah, like I said two possible scum voting owb. Meh, could be a townie following Zaragon who's baiting us all. I don't have a lot to say until night post is up to be honest.

I'll be around most of the day if someone brings up something to discuss im more than willing.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 29 2013 22:22 GMT

#388

Oh shit, 1 outta 3 ain't bad boys. Welcome to the game Koshi. You made my day better.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 02:32 GMT

#435

I'm not sold on anyone to be fair. I wanted heavenz...he responded. I went back to my original read. storm's safe enough for now. I still say we should have lynched heavenz or playerboy.

If you want my feeling on this game. I want to lynch someone who will give the town info by doing so. I wanted storm day1 and it was not going to happen. I thought Mluneth had a chance of being mafia; not high but a chance, and I played on it.

I thought owb had a very, very slight chance so I didnt wanna make the same mistake.

playerboy and heavenz; one is mafia. If we had lynched one of them yesterday it'd be easier to choose.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 22:31 GMT

#511

Okay, time to go through filters again. Thanks for filling in briefly Koshi.

I still think heavenz or playerboy or both are not town. Zaragon, stormtemplar and balla I'm not sure yet. I'll go through and come back with a stronger argument than they're scum because I said so!

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 22:34 GMT

#512

Oh, just got a pm. I was roleblocked.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 22:35 GMT

#513

I honestly am surprised I wasn't nk'd to be honest. Koshi's clear experience in mafia made him a very smart pick though. Well played.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 22:37 GMT

#514

Oh shit, I just realized. This makes storm 100% mafia? Someone was nk'd. I was role blocked, believe me or not.

Or is the mafia playing a smarter game than I imagined. Neither kill nor role block stormtemplar so we lynch him. What a slippery slope we have to climb.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

September 30 2013 22:46 GMT

#518

I switched to MLuneth only when there was no chance remaining to lynch stormtemplar. I said in my first write up I really want to lynch MLuneth but I'm reading him as more of a dumb townie. But, between him and someone not playing I thought we had better odds with MLuneth than randomly guessing one of the MIAs as mafia.

I just don't get it though. If storm is rb why would they not block him? They trust he's incompetent enough to not rb correctly?
It's that or he's lying.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 01 2013 05:59 GMT

#562

This game could have been much simpler had we not tunneled owb. I thought storm was scum day 1 and still do today.

I was willing to drop the accusation because it seemed to be going nowhere. I need to go over the filters again, I got caught up in work earlier today.

There are some questions we need to examine.

1) Did anyone want to save xIvanJ over the other people who didn't play?

2) Did that person vote in a manner indicating scum? Late vote changes, suspicious activity near deadline aka playerboy.

A bit of info to look at and consider.

MLuneth (4): Zaragon, JohnnyLaw, heavenz, Balla24

onlywonderboy (3): playerboy345, Balla24, heavenz, Zaragon

With Balla switching his vote to heavenz last minute.

These facts are not concrete in making a case by themselves but just another piece to look at when considering who we lynch tonight.

Also, curiously storm wanted blurry lynched day one and didn't vote for him then second day instead bandwagoned with me on playerboy before blurry was night killed. To be honest though, last night's kill was very smart as he obviously knew forum mafia better than most of us. I'm going to keep digging at people's actions and hopefully we get more conversation going tomorrow.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 02 2013 03:52 GMT

#576

Zaragon, the only person who picked a target and pushed them hard was heavenz. I give him that for a town read. I mean isolating onlywonderboy was not a good read. I'm sticking with my stormtemplar or playerboy read. I went away from what I liked day 1 and it bit me in the ass. Take your pick but you'll have to convince me to vote away from those two.

Sorry I've been busy. Ill be here the two hours before voting tomorrow to discuss the game. If you have questions or new information to bring up I'm more than willing to digest it.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 02 2013 03:58 GMT

#578

I think they're more of a gamble. If we get one we win. I just think playerboy is scummy. It's late for me I'llo give full reads tomorrow before voting time. I hope you're around then if not, pick your vote and give a reason and I'll evaluate it. I work early in the morning tomorrow.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 02 2013 19:02 GMT

#603

Looking through the four filters I really have nothing new to contribute. stormtemplar's play just looks poor. I don't know if he's trying to play off absentmindedness as an excuse to cover up being scum or he's just absentminded.

heavenz and playerboy have both acted in more questionable manners with their late voting, late advice and reads on votes and flipping their opinions in short time periods when nothing really occurred.

For now, I'll follow along. I'm going to check their filters again to be certain I like where I'm placing what could end up as my final vote.

##Vote stormtemplar

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 03 2013 00:23 GMT

#675

Sorry guys. I really wanted to push playerboy's case again today but I've been swamped at work the last two days. I had a great time playing and will definitely play again soon. I'd join the next game but I'm out of town on business for ten days starting in a week.

Also, congrats mafia scum you guys did well. And fuck it's just like I said in my last post; storm's just a bad townie similar to MLuneth. This is going to be my new online time killer. Thanks for the game and I'm just glad it wasn't Zaragon scum in the end. I had a nagging feeling he was laughing scum all game.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 03 2013 01:50 GMT

#678

I played the same way after you said I checked clear. Only when Koshi said I could be GF did I consider anything else.

Man, this game is fun.

JonnyLaw

United States3482 Posts

October 03 2013 21:14 GMT

#685

I think you did a great job making the odds fair. We had a shot to win the game and got outplayed.

Prev 1 2 3 All

Please or register to reply.