Desert Mini Mafia

On September 03 2013 19:59 marvellosity wrote:
Tutan is thrawn? I didn't see that one coming.

because now I can't help attaching overall opinions of thrawn to his posts.

On September 03 2013 22:10 yamato77 wrote:
Thrawn, what do you think of a Hapa/Slam/Sn0 scumteam?

On September 05 2013 08:08 Hapahauli wrote:


Why the particularly strong feelings on Yamato?

On September 05 2013 08:16 Hapahauli wrote:


To play devil's advocate, he really hasn't been all that present in the thread all game.

Also, town-yamato-ish is much more active than what he's doing right now. In what ways does his specific behaviors point to his townie persona?

On September 05 2013 08:24 Hapahauli wrote:


So you have 3 unacceptable lynches (of which I believe you all think are town-reads), you yourself will maintain that you're town.

That probably leaves 3 scum of the next 4 players. Who's your scumteam? Or if that's too specific, who are you leaning strongest scum on? Who are you wavering the most on?

On September 02 2013 23:24 Onegu wrote:



Ok I sent a PM to the hosts and syl (hope thats not illegal/cheating) if I could talk about FT in P4 when we talking about I have never seen his scum play, and since at the time he hadnt flipped and the game wasnt over they told me I couldnt. But now that the game is over I have seen FT play scum, it had no resemblence to this game, but my main point about his meta with me was I have seen him play lurky town in GoT and in that game he still made reads on people just not many, and when he came back he defended himself and posted his reads for his post death flip, he did none of those things this game. While sounding like a broken record, his meta wasnt the only reason I voted for him. His play and lack of interest was also scummy. He deserved to die and I would have done it again because he was playing scummy and against his meta.

The only thing I said to syl in the PM was can I talk about FT in persona, and his answer was no, the game is ongoing. Sorry if this is against the rules or cheating. I just wanted to know if I could talk about it.

On September 05 2013 08:52 Hapahauli wrote:


I can see getting townie-vibes from that, but nothign particularly robust. It's natural for anyone to talk about the subject (PM'ing the host about discussion of an ongoing game), especially if it pertains to your suspicions and defense of said suspicion after a mislynch.

On September 05 2013 08:57 Hapahauli wrote:
Oh he PM'd syl.

Didn't catch that. That's kinda wierd.

On September 05 2013 00:26 Sn0_Man wrote:

PS: Useless setup speculation: It's safe to say that scum NK's are worth 50 water, since they achieved their NK tonight and it balanced-out perfectly with our doctor save. In addition, for balance reasons it prevents town losing D2 if town mislynches twice (which we did). As such, while I'm really unsure if it would help town much, a no-lynch isn't too unreasonable an option. Admittedly all that happens is we lose our doctor (ugh) but I'm willing to assume that he will be roleblocked and killed in fairly short order anyway so this isn't too huge a loss. The problem is that we need his insight for as long as possible. TL;DR we are at MyLo not Lylo or w/e. If we mislynch we lose but if we no-lynch we don't lose on the spot.

On August 29 2013 23:42 Sn0_Man wrote:

I somehow scored like 3 free townreads early though so if nothing else he doesn't seem to be cherry picking somebody easy to point a finger at (another point in his favour).

On August 30 2013 05:42 Sn0_Man wrote:
Koopa why ain't you pushing hopeless a bit more?

He seems like the best lynch so far tbh.

On September 05 2013 01:50 Sn0_Man wrote:
I hope it's marv

On September 05 2013 06:35 Sn0_Man wrote:
@rayn:

Thrawn is admittedly AFK which isn't helping anything. I thought he had some contributions earlier though.

Your last post made more sense about yamato. PS If yamato is scum I'm thinking its him/thrawn/marv which makes u look disgustingly smart

On September 04 2013 09:27 marvellosity wrote:
I know I have a decent chunk of time tomorrow evening, so I shall use it wisely

On September 05 2013 19:43 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I dunno, probably lynch marv, Sylencia and yamato. Possibly Sno_man in exchange of yamato if he is able to reasonably explain himself.

On September 05 2013 19:06 thrawn2112 wrote:

I read through all of sylencia's posts. Overall it was pretty bland, not the most interesting read. It didn't look particularly townie, nor scummy. I think the posts where he talked about his play were genuine. I'd like the people who want to lynch him to tell me truthfully if syl's meta doesn't allow for him to be town, because by his own description, it does?

On September 05 2013 20:04 raynpelikoneet wrote:
thrawn do you think scum are marv, Sylencia and Sno?
why not yamato?

On September 05 2013 20:12 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am pretty sure Onegu is town, having played with him a couple of games. He is far more aggressive as scum.

I don't really know Sylecia's meta. I am basing my read on him on his posts, which are really bad. Like, he accuses Onegu of going after easy targets all game and that's pretty much it. He has done the exact same thing, but without proper reasoning. At least Onegu's reasons sound like a townie could think.

What do you think of what me & Hapa said about yamato on D3? Does yamato's posts make sense to you? Why?

On September 05 2013 20:40 Onegu wrote:
So I am here! Any question I am here for.

On September 05 2013 23:47 Onegu wrote:
Yeah Syl is most likely scum, I have thought he was scummy since day one, also lynching him has zero downside if his claim is true we still dont lose the game, if he is scum fake claiming scum dies its a no lose situation.

##VOTE SYLENCIA

On September 06 2013 05:39 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Yes, makes sense. Sylencia is all out bussing him. Which one, Sylencia/marv do you think is more valuable to scum?

On September 06 2013 05:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:

All blues were given a fakeclaim, which is vanilla role-PM.
Sylencia does not have it. He has his red role, and blue fake claim.

On September 06 2013 05:45 raynpelikoneet wrote:

They will get both lynched either way! Because they are both fucking scummy.
I need you the next day! Please, vote for marv!

On September 06 2013 05:44 Hapahauli wrote:


Breadcrumb is fine, and the role-claim is plausible.

I guess I shouldn't be putting too much stock into the role PM stuff.

It seems l ike you guys have your heart set on lynching marv. At this point, I doubt there's much I could do to stop you, nor do I have any real compelling evidence to do so. My gut read on marv is still town, and I'd expect far more pro-active scumplay from him than to afk for the past 48 hours.

Anyway, I'm goign to be on for another 30 minutes and then I have to go to class. I won't be able to check the thread on my computer until after the deadline, however I"ll be able to check stuff on my phone and move votes around accordingly.

On September 06 2013 07:48 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Why the fuck does someone think Sylencia is not scum unless both of me and Hapa are lying?

On September 06 2013 18:32 Hapahauli wrote:
I think asking yourself "what's the mafia motivation behind the claim" is a wrong way of looking at this. The question should be "is mafia capable of doing such a play?"

Mafia have many options at LYLO to fuck with the town. A fake claim is one of them. It might seem like an "unnecessary" play, but it's a possible play (and one we have a lot of evidence for). That's what playing mafia's all about anyway - making enough "unnecessary" plays to distract people from catching on to you pushing your objectives.

On September 07 2013 04:13 yamato77 wrote:

what are you even saying?

On September 07 2013 04:01 yamato77 wrote:

at what point did I "stop doing things that made me town?"

I read that line and thought: "is thrawn mafia?"

if you are, consider that your downfall

On September 07 2013 22:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
So people just stopped playing or what?

On September 10 2013 03:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Yeah, people who thought i was crazy were marv... Who was scum.

I dunno, i have no idea what yamato thinks because his mind changes every 5 seconds...

On September 10 2013 04:03 raynpelikoneet wrote:

It is not about my case on you. It's about before that. Even then marv was sure you were town which can clearly be seen from his posting. It makes no sense for him to act like that when he does not know who you in fact are. Oats even pointed that out at some point. He said "marv knows who Koopa is and won't tell us". I got the exact same feeling then because his town read was not well justified and you never questioned him about it.

On September 10 2013 04:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Why do you want to know what i think of yamato? Why don't you think what the guys who did not out 2 mafia and lynch them in a row think about each other?

On September 10 2013 04:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am talking about the lynches i lead on 2 mafia members. Why is it so important for you to know what i think about some other people as i am as close to confirmed town as anyone can be in this game?

Why are you questioning me and not the dudes who actually can be mafia?