|
On July 22 2013 07:01 FiveTouch wrote:I don't seem to have strong opinions about anybody. Just browsed through his filter and didn't feel much one way or another. Don't really know what to do. Oats is *so* quiet it's hard to know what's going on with him, you'd figure he'd be posting more as scum than this if he was actually around, so meh. Can you be compelling about TAA for me? :p ~marv
Why do you bring up Oats over anyone else in your answer?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Because my brain had been musing on the fact that Firm chose Oats as his 'example' lynch
|
So who do you actually want to lynch?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Not sure. I'd take TAA over Firm though.
|
|
|
@Marv. His responses read to me like the more he gets pressured the less thought he tries to put into his responses. That reads like scum hasn't fully thought through their line of reasoning. Plus, he keeps on having these "Well you want to know what I think" type of posts which feel really non-towny; very "See what I'm contributing"-esque. For someone like me that'd be the norm, but he doesn't come across as that type of person and between Wave and Me, he's the lurkier player I'd like to kill.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
rayn, because I think I agree with getmoript's analysis more than I do yours on Firm. I could totally see TAA as mafia, even though I'm paranoid he might be newb town. I'd like to see more out of Firm before committing.
|
The thing is Firm is very aggressive and straight forward as town. Here he is nothing like that at all. He is trying to fake that by calling out "scummy behaviour" without actually doing so (it didn't make people scum). When people start to question him he goes on to lurkers, to switch the attention onto something else ("look, there are 7 people who have not posted shit") instead of giving out reads on active players or trying to question scummy ones of them.
Also marv, why the fuck are you basing your opinion on what others think about TAA/Firm? Why not think by yourself?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
This game has been exceptionally quiet so I don't think it's entirely fair to judge him for playing differently than he previously has as town.
And I think plenty by myself, thank you dearest, I wanted to know if getmoript would produce similar reasoning as I would, and they did, so that feels decent to me.
|
omfg, i don't know what to think. I kinda want to lynch FiveTouch..
|
I prefer an oats lynch to TAA I think. Don't believe either smurf is mafia at this point, so long as most of 5T's posts have come from marv.
I have not hydraed, by hydraing as scum seems particular troublesome. Some other dude might do something scummy and you can get lynched for it. If anyone HAS hydraed as scum, is that the case? You're paranoid your hydra partner might do something you find scummy? If that IS the case, then getmoript is posting too much/too freely to be the D1 lynch, and if he ever drops the bad cop, worse cop, even worse and angry cop act then that would be nice.
|
On July 22 2013 08:14 austinmcc wrote: If that IS the case, then getmoript is posting too much/too freely to be the D1 lynch, and if he ever drops the bad cop, worse cop, even worse and angry cop act then that would be nice.
lol <3
|
@Austin... Why Oats over TitsAndAss?
|
On July 22 2013 08:19 getmoript wrote:
@Austin... Why Oats over TitsAndAss? For legitimate and illegitimate reasons.
He was scum in Nuclear and one of the things that stuck out about him when I was really looking at him on D2 (before forgetting him qqqqqqqqq) is that he was somewhat inactive and just not affecting the game like I think Oats should.
Oats is REALLY inactive this game and not affecting the game, yet at least has LOOKED at the thread at some point.
So in part, it's wrong because I'm lynching him due to looking too hard at last game. But that gets a little WIFOM-y in my head - maybe he's angry/unmotivated because he just got scum again / maybe I'm just overreacting.
TAA is...I misread his filter before and wanted to talk with him, but then couldn't find whatever it was I wanted to talk about. He's been SO bristly and SO jumpy on calling people scum that I give him minor minor not-scum points. But I'm more than willing to chat about him and consider it.
|
Have you looked that the points I've brought up about him?
|
TAA, who was this post referring to? FirmTofu or FiveTouch, and which lurker post?
On July 21 2013 23:11 TheAwesomeAll wrote:
also a strange thing about FT is the calling out the lurker post. He left TanGeng out of his list of "ill hop aboard these bandwagons any day" call for no apparent reason. Im really interested in TanGengs collor if FT turns red and vice versa. E
|
On July 22 2013 06:55 getmoript wrote:Show nested quote +On July 22 2013 06:51 FiveTouch wrote:
Yeah my vote was outdated.
getmoript, you think TAA's cases were malicious rather than wrong townie then?
~marv I don't read him as wrong townie. Feels like he's trying to post just to post and not actually try to force or move discussion which is something I see very rarely out of town. Why do you think he's misguided townie? See above. Yeah, he's not rallying the troops for a lynch, but he's calling a bunch of folks scummy and he's jumping around so much. If he's just posting to post, why is everything an accusation? It reads more like he had a scumread or two, then started getting attacked, the just started attacking everything back (to me). I'd agree with misguided townie over scum based on his cases/votes.
On July 22 2013 07:14 getmoript wrote:
@Marv. His responses read to me like the more he gets pressured the less thought he tries to put into his responses. That reads like scum hasn't fully thought through their line of reasoning. Plus, he keeps on having these "Well you want to know what I think" type of posts which feel really non-towny; very "See what I'm contributing"-esque. For someone like me that'd be the norm, but he doesn't come across as that type of person and between Wave and Me, he's the lurkier player I'd like to kill. I see what you're saying, but I think you can spin this both ways and I like the other. Yeah, some of his responses look very unprepared, but I think that's townie and not scummy. I know when I get accused I post lots of stupid crap because I'm so worried about being thought of as scummy and needing to find scum and needing to defend myself and...being accused of being scum just gives a townie so much more to worry about (unless you're really, really used to getting called scummy or don't care at all). The less thought/more posts reads like that to me, not like scum unraveling.
The "you want to know what I think" point is ... interesting? I don't think I've seen mafia do that, don't think I interpret that as a mafia tell, but he HAS made a bunch of those, and it's a thing that I'll note. Especially if you can say "this is something I would do as town," then I don't think it's utterly damning on someone whose playstyle I don't know.
|
Lynch FirmTofu. rayn off. cya tomorrow.
|
fivetouch made a post calling out the lurkers,
On July 21 2013 15:19 FiveTouch wrote:
Okay I've read the thread and I want to lynch a lurker. Throw a dart between DocH, Zephirdd, Oatsmaster and TAA. None have even tried to fake caring about the game, so I'm not even going to fake caring about their lives. Who's it gonna be guys?
I prefer Zeph, as he's actually posted yet has said literally nothing...but like I said, I would support any of the other lynches I mentioned without hesitation.
-VE
evidently he named almost every lurker(up to that point) except TanGeng.
TG strikes me as smart and competent with the few posts he made but he hasnt contributed yet so im kinda interested in him and then FT made that post which intentionally left TG out of the spotlight so i thought it was worth pointing out.
|
The "that'd be the norm for someone like me" point refers far more to the stream of consciousness type posting. Like I post mostly on gut as town and move from there where I can keep on going. Not the "well do you want to know what I think" type of posts; I don't think I've ever really seen that as town and I honestly can't imagine doing it as town. I've seen something like, "well you want to know what I think. Here's what I think" type of post all connected not this strung out sort of play.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
