It's really simple if you just think Oats.

Possibility 1) TG town. He has no reason to lie about being roleblocked.

Possibility 2) TG scum. Maybe they hid a RB under the rayn shot. Maybe they didn't RB at all. But scum wouldn't RB one of their own. He could be lying about RB.

To answer your question, if scum ACTUALLY REALLY roleblocked TG, we can assume he's town. Unfortunately we can't know for sure. We know he claimed it and we know that scum wanted us to believe it.

-VE

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 11:26 GMT

#1508

VE went to bed shortly ago TG, what part are you confused about? I'm not totally sure what you're asking.

~marv

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 11:35 GMT

#1512

On July 25 2013 20:30 TanGeng wrote:
What part of the scum play, specifically the RB claim, makes it clear that scum intention is in confirming my roleblocked claim?

Still not entirely sure what you're asking, I think I'm being dense.

What do you think the alternative is to whatever you're asking? Might help me get a grip.

~marv

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 11:54 GMT

#1516

On July 25 2013 20:41 TanGeng wrote:
When TAA claims RBer, the only one that could be claimed as RB target was me. Is there any other option that looks feasible as a claim target? Correct me if I'm wrong here.

So my question is: What makes it scum intention rather than a forced side-effect?

What you said sounds right.

I'm probably not about to answer your question because i'm just paraphrasing, but if you're mafia obviously mafia want people to believe you were roleblocked, and if you're town they want it to appear like they were mafia hiding a roleblock on one of their own.

I can't speak for VE's exact wording but I'm confused because there shouldn't really be too much confusion in the first place ^^

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 11:55 GMT

#1517

getmoript is right, there's roughly a 0% benefit to speculating about 3p right now. Possibly less.

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 13:08 GMT

#1538

If you shoot Firm, I'm pushing for your lynch.

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 13:25 GMT

#1541

On July 25 2013 22:23 Onegu wrote:
I dont like a cora shot much, and 5T if that is supposed to scare me sorry, firm defended TAA until it was beyond obv he was scum. And in games I have played with him as town or he obs a game I was town we both had very close to the same scum reads while we are very different this game.

That's exactly a good indicator of why he could well be town.

TAA was totally doomed, so defending him is a really really stupid thing to do if he's mafia. Do you think Firm is really really stupid?

~marv

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 13:29 GMT

#1544

Well, there we go then. There exists the possibility that Firm is playing a really really stupid mafia game and defended a scummy redcheck when the rest of the town wanted to lynch him, but I wouldn't bet on it, would you?

Firm is also a player (like Corazon) who we know will post enough and get more information out of.

~marv

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 13:55 GMT

#1547

Pretty desperate for you to be town, TG, just so I can be right, to be honest.

FiveTouch

Marshall Islands1474 Posts

July 25 2013 13:59 GMT

#1551

There's no evidence that Firm freaked out about anything.

Firm doesn't seem like the freaking-out sort, frankly.

Wouldn't mind him explaining the potential blue thing though. You're right in that that is odd.