|
On July 25 2013 08:08 austinmcc wrote:
But TG mainly looks bad because he ended the day at x-1 and got a lot of those votes because his D1 actually reads scummy to me. Like, claim aside, his posts were scummy to me. And given that he started picking up votes with a couple hours to spare, and ended x-1, I would expect scum to pop in and lynch him if he were town. A no lynch is fine for them, but they passed up a dead townie if he's town, plus any incremental value of making me/others look scummy for lynching him. Nor do I think you're gonna pick up a bunch of scrutiny when everyone is clamoring for this guy to be lynched and begging people who haven't even read thread to vote him and lynch him.
I actually disagree with this part. Here's why. Considering the activity level D1, a no lynch is far preferable to a town mislynch IMO and here's why.
1. Said town mislynch is going to be an easy topic to hide in all game long.
2. Said town mislynch can be pushed on D2 or D3 reasonably easily
3. Low activity combined with stupid majority voting rules means that after a no-lynch, 2 NKs and a mislynch. At a 9-3 or 8-3-1 split, you can force town into lylo at 5-3 instead of at 4-3 which is a HUGE boon because you can still be getting rid of the obv town while keeping the lurkers/scummy players to help hide in.
|
On July 25 2013 08:15 FiveTouch wrote:
Were TAA or jrkirby around any time near lynch?
AFAIK neither were. Jkirby went off early IIRC and TAA was like MIA as much D1 as he's been today.
|
Yah, I thought about that. I don't want to get too wrapped up in it. I've been thinking about a number of situations. Like, assume I'm paranoid/insane for a second, then it makes perfect sense to have rolecop and vigilante as town; quite possibly we could even have a town RB. It could just be terribly a terribly ironic situation that unfolded.
|
On July 25 2013 08:27 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On July 25 2013 08:25 getmoript wrote:
Yah, I thought about that. I don't want to get too wrapped up in it. I've been thinking about a number of situations. Like, assume I'm paranoid/insane for a second, then it makes perfect sense to have rolecop and vigilante as town; quite possibly we could even have a town RB. It could just be terribly a terribly ironic situation that unfolded. In all honesty, if you're paranoid, I'll still be surprised if TAA flips town. Like, regardless of whether the check is trustworthy, the reaction to the check ...
No I wholly agree there. Thus the irony in the situation (a paranoid cop getting scum lynched on a red check).
|
On July 25 2013 11:06 austinmcc wrote:
jrkirby, you're ducking the panda question.
Also, you left off last night right before lynch saying you'd look into TG. Did you ever do so? Either way, talk a wittle bit about TG please.
Yah, it's a panda question. No ducks allowed.
|
Careful with the pre-flip associations, guise, though we'll know one way or another pretty soon anyway.
I'm feeling real good about this considering the radio silence from TAA---often means scum resignation to one's fate.
-Wave
+ Show Spoiler +(Or horrible town play, and I suppose we've seen plenty of that, so ugh)
|
On July 25 2013 12:38 Onegu wrote:
@wave what are your thoughts on cora?
Both of us had a scumread on him for quite a while. Geript thought it was a better idea to claim and push TAA for today, so I'm going to sit back and see how this pans out because there is a fair bit riding on the flip it seems.
If there's not much else going on right now maybe I'll dive his filter again.
|
Oh man I really can't wait to see this flip.
|
Wow. Now that's quite interesting. YAY!!!! Night.
|
Well there's no reason to believe that TG was lying about being roleblocked. It's just a question of whether he's scum or now.
|
Ahhh I feel all warm and tingly.
Guess that means we might be dead tonight, eh other head?
So now the question becomes, was TG actually lying about getting roleblocked or did scum know TAA was going to flip anyway so they tried to get us to lynch him?
Cora actually was following the line of reasoning that if one is lying they both are....hmm.......
-Wave
|
We're reasonably sure it wasn't offensive JK roleblock, right? Because that would be a decently easy way to confirm one way or another.
I guess we'll just have to look at what the actions were regarding TG's lynch and if people were just fucking stupid or actually protecting him.
TG and Cora could be last two scum.
-wave
|
Yah, I don't really care about the roleblock. All WIFOM. He definitely was roleblocked imo, but I don't think that there's a real good amount to read into it from there.
|
On July 25 2013 15:26 jrkirby wrote:
Didn't TG claim RB before getmoript claimed TAA was red? Or do I have the order wrong?
That's correct.
|
@Wave. What do you think of JJD?
|
@VE who do you think Onegu should shoot?
|
On July 25 2013 15:32 getmoript wrote:
@Wave. What do you think of JJD?
I don't know how much you want me to reveal here but I pretty much stopped caring about him since you told me your read on him. 
On July 25 2013 15:32 getmoript wrote:
@VE who do you think Onegu should shoot?
TG/Cora/Oats.
Any of those three honestly.
|
Yah, TG is probably town but I don't think it's a 100% thing. I think this also makes Marv/VE confirmed not scum. I think they would've coached TAA better.
|
Just read his filter WoS and post your thoughts.
|
Actually probably not Cora---he blueclaimed so you might be able to get something useful out of him and upon lynching him we might learn more. TG probably.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
