|
On July 15 2013 09:29 Nightcat99 wrote:and the game got really hectic, i will be honest that i really wanted to switch out of jrkirby ont he last few minutes because his last minute insight is very sounded and seems very townie. Show nested quote +Ok, Gotard is an excellent lynch target tomorrow. I think chrom should only be lynched after a scum is found, but maybe checked by cop.
I have less of a feeling about koshi, umasi, super.
Xzavier is decent, but not the best lynch.
Chrom and super should be lynched together should one of them be scum by flip or cop check.
That's the best I got, GG guys. and also since hes a proven townie now , we shall really look into his reads.
So scum jumped on his wagon because he was being helpful in the five minutes before his death?
Who jumped on his wagon then?
|
On July 15 2013 09:27 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On July 15 2013 09:16 Chromatically wrote:
ahhhhhhhhhh
The case on Kirby was better than the one on Super, Kirby only looked town for the last ~10 minutes. I'll stand by that.
One of Super or Koshi is scum. Koshi's hard defense of Kirby with little reasoning looks like it could be scum trying to get town cred from a town flip to me. I'll also look at Nightcat because he didn't care about who was lynched at all. last ~10 minutes I am pretty sure you didn't say this in the last 10 minutes. Hurricane wanted to switch 5 minutes before. One of Super or Koshi is scum. What THE FUCK. Can someone explain this to me? defense of Kirby with little reasoning Do I have to quote the 10 times that I said that Kirby was capable to redeem himself. Do I have to quote the entire post I made that Kirby is a better town than Super? it could be scum trying to get town cred from a town flip to me. Right back at you. I kinda love the fact that we made this conclusion at the same time. Look at how sexy we are.
I had doubts about the lynch around the time when I suggested the switch onto you, 17 minutes before the lynch.
Both of you look bad, but you're not both scum because there would be some insane bussing going on.
There's a lot of stuff about your reasoning that doesn't make sense. I don't know if I'll post it now but I will before the night ends.
|
Kirby flipped town.
I defended Super primarily to get Kirby lynched. I still think that people were voting him for bad reasons, and the reasons I put up against the case are valid.
I'm not saying that he is scum, I haven't even read his filter since the flip. I am saying that it definitely deserves consideration now.
|
I need to reread stuff (and take a break), but I'll post stuff tomorrow.
|
On July 15 2013 09:41 Koshi wrote:
Chroma? You still here? Just tell me plain and simple why Super is scum
There was no interaction between Super and Kirby. Super should not have become more or less suspicious by the death of Kirby.
Why is Super scummy?
I haven't even read his filter, I'm just considering the possibility because he was the opposite wagon on a town lynch.
|
On July 15 2013 09:33 Nightcat99 wrote:
what i mean was hes one of the more active people and therefore more helpful then not. i wasnt talking about the helpfulness of the last 5 minutes. Also he was close to being lynch over 2 hour ago thats the time that the scum could have jumped on the wagon.
So he was only helpful because he was active, and that's why scum would want to lynch him?
|
On July 15 2013 09:45 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On July 15 2013 09:42 Chromatically wrote:On July 15 2013 09:41 Koshi wrote:
Chroma? You still here? Just tell me plain and simple why Super is scum
There was no interaction between Super and Kirby. Super should not have become more or less suspicious by the death of Kirby.
Why is Super scummy? I haven't even read his filter, I'm just considering the possibility because he was the opposite wagon on a town lynch. You are smarter than that. YOU WERE the one that put them on the opposite wagon. You are making 0 sense in your last 3 posts. I want to keep going. Can you stay and talk? Just tell me. You must have something in your head. You gave me 5 reasons why super was good at scumreading. You must have read super his filter mutliple times. Tell me why Super or I am scum. Why did you post that?
How does that make no sense?
I was wrong about Kirby, I'm obviously going to consider the other wagon. It's very possible I was wrong about that too.
I never said that Super was GOOD at scumreading. I said that he game 5 reasons for his read. That's a very big difference.
I said that because both you and him are possible scum candidates, but you're not scum together.
|
Why am I "smarter than that"? Weren't you just calling me "full of shit" a short bit ago?
|
I was obviously very overconfident in my Kirby read. That's why I defended Super, because I was so certain that Kirby was the better lynch.
I didn't ignore the Gotard case, I commented on it. It's really easy to make cases as scum, its pushing the reads and the thread interactions that make someone town. He only made the case under heavy pressure. In addition, Gotard was a very easy person to make a case on, exactly who I would have expected a scum Kirby to make a case on.
Alaka, it's a lot easier to criticize the Kirby case when you know the outcome. Pretty much everyone agreed that it was a good case.
It seems like the basis of the scumreads on me is that I led a mislynch, which isn't scummy because the reasons were good. I've been active in finding scum, pushing my reads, and open about my thoughts.
|
What's your point with this Super/Xzav stuff? You blatantly misrepresented Super by saying that he had no reason fir voting Xzav. I pointed out that Super gave several more reasons. You can find them yourself in his filter.
|
PLEASE explain why I'm scum.
|
Control-F "Xzavier" in his filter, it's not hard.
|
The Super/Koshi thing was already explained, it was preliminary feeling right after the flip. Both of them cold be scum, but they're not both scum. So the most likely case is that one of them is scum.
I'm still rereading the thread, so you'll have my actual scumreads before the night end.
I have absolutely no idea what your point is with the Xzavier thing.
I really don't know how the "Chrom hates lists" thing got started. Posting lists of lurkers is bad because it's really easy to do as scum, but it wasn't a huge point.
|
Super gave 5 reasons in his filter, I can quote them if you want. It's not my problem of no one else bothered to check, and I don't see how its scummy at all.
|
The whole thing was kind of silly, I don't see what they did to help. I don't remember anything really scummy from the "Tribunal" itself.
|
Let me read first, I can give opinions after that.
|
|
|
lol I haven't read his filter since the flip
|
|
|
No, people who have no preference either way are still very scummy.
Its one thing to consolidate if necessary, its another to not care at all
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
