I'm surprised no one picked up on it. I posted a huge case on Alakaslam, he didn't defend it very well, and then I suddenly change my read on him from Scum #1 to Pure Town. The clues were there.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 20:42 GMT

#2223

So what was your story sponge :D

I picked the reverse check ability, hoping i would get checked, that didnt work out

Umasi

United States1399 Posts

July 21 2013 20:45 GMT

#2224

dw Nightcat
just be like me
roll vet
never be threatening, always wrong, kinda scummy but pretty townie>never get shot

Hurricane Sponge

868 Posts

July 21 2013 20:46 GMT

#2225

Nightcat, you were my #1 scum read at the end of Night 1. Like I said in obs chat, this game setup screams of 'Fuck With The Cop' (Godfather, Framer, Unknown Miller). The mafia could make it so only 1 of their 3 guys returns red, so I tried to make cop checks based on my reads. I wanted to check the second-scummiest guy each night (Gotard night 1, Xzavier night 2) and take the results with a grain of salt.

Sure enough, when Gotard checked back 'Innocent', I figured he was Framed defensively (or the Godfather), and that helped exonerate Nightcat (my #1 read). I was going to push for a Gotard lynch either way on Day 2, but if I'd gotten a Red check back, I would have been much less active to force others to develop the wagons.

Second game ever, first as a PR (much less a cop) so tagging mafia in both of my checks makes me happy.

hzflank

United Kingdom2991 Posts

July 21 2013 20:55 GMT

#2226

I honestly thought Super was SK until I just read this. It made so much sense for Super to kill me. Nightcat...should of killed Chrom! ;(

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:02 GMT

#2227

I didnt want to kill chrom, cause i was afraid mafia would kill chrom since he claimed roleblock first day , and i wanted to make sure 2 people die a day.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:03 GMT

#2228

Its all your fault Hzflank, why were you so townie looking

hzflank

United Kingdom2991 Posts

July 21 2013 21:05 GMT

#2229

It was SK's job to kill the people who were roleblocked. Mafia KP was factional, SK was not.

Your read on me was not townie, you read me as holding back. That is because I was scum :p

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:08 GMT

#2230

Too be fair, i was not expecting a jailer.. since gotard died...

hzflank

United Kingdom2991 Posts

July 21 2013 21:08 GMT

#2231

Ah good point. Chrom was not the most obvious jailer target.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:11 GMT

#2232

All this acting and posting real reads ,with fake read, then Hzflank ruined every thing lol

I was trying so hard to save xzavier the last day, even making up the story about hzflank and xzavier not talking to each other.

If any one went through their filter, you would know that is not even true.....

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:15 GMT

#2233

did you guys skip the first roleblocked, if chrom was jailed???

Hurricane Sponge

868 Posts

July 21 2013 21:18 GMT

#2234

They were setting up an amazing play, actually. They wanted to Roleblock the veteran and kill him in the same night, so the town would think that there was an SK running around (thinking two shots on the vet instead of a RB and a NK).

For obvious reasons, that plan didn't pan out quite as they anticipated.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:21 GMT

#2235

I would have never picked up Umasi as the Vet, he was not trying to step into the bullet, Sponge on the other hand, i through could have been the vet.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:22 GMT

#2236

btw. are you guys playing the next newbie game.
If so i am lynching Chrom and hzflank first day, i dont want to try to read Hzflank again and Chrom is too troublesome. :D

Chromatically

United States1700 Posts

July 21 2013 21:25 GMT

#2237

I see that some people in the obs were saying that I was "far from that towniest person" because I was wrong about some reads... (I think it's hilarious that everyone was calling me scum there early on).

I feel pretty bad for hz, he played great and would have easily won if Nightcat hadn't been town mvp. Nightcat played well too imo, he did a good job of looking like noon town the whole game.

I was wrong about a lot of my reads this game, but I'm particularly happy that I got Koshi right. I should tunnel less D1, though.

I would really like to hear advice from anyone who has it, I definitely had a lot of things to improve on from this game.

Big thanks to iamp for being a great coach.

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:27 GMT

#2238

wait how do you read the obs chat?

Nightcat99

United States239 Posts

July 21 2013 21:28 GMT

#2239

nm i found it , i am dumb

hzflank

United Kingdom2991 Posts

July 21 2013 21:28 GMT

#2240

You were far from Town, Chrom. As long as Super was alive there was that potential association hanging over you. Also, once Umasi claimed RBed then it made your claim a little strange, as you were not the most obvious jail target N1.