It's not about whether he's right or wrong. It's why he's so damn sure of himself when there's no reason to be.

Also I'm taking guesses right now as to what I ended up deciding to do last night.
Any takers?

Have you never played with Vivax before? In LIX I smurfed, was so townie that a town-full of vets elected me mayor, I pushed two mafia all day 1, used my mayoral lynch to kill a mafia, and pushed more mafia into day 2.

Vivax is cop and gets a redcheck on someone, but is SO convinced that I'm mafia somehow that he votes for me instead of his redcheck. You'd have to see it to believe it almost.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 05 2013 22:12 GMT

#2241

And it's the weekend! Hurray, that means I'll have some time to sit down and look at stuff properly. Will probably sheep gumshoe anyways though.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 05 2013 22:13 GMT

#2244

On July 06 2013 07:12 WaveofShadow wrote:

Show nested quote +

But it's like a switch flipped between D1 and D2 somewhere. He did not like play like this for half the game.

yeah he decided I was mafia. same in LIX, same in personality 2. once he gets into his head that I'm mafia, all reason disappears. It's consistent.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 05 2013 22:20 GMT

#2247

still noone cares

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 12:03 GMT

#2279

Gonna ##Vote: JarJarDrinks until he gives me a better option. Hint: WoS is not it.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 12:29 GMT

#2282

gumshoe and I have said enough things in the thread about why you could well be mafia, to which you have responded to some of them. Mostly process of elimination too.

And I don't believe your wos scumread.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 12:31 GMT

#2283

also stuff where you were asking gumshoe why he was town seems extremely out of place. gumshoe should be looking extremely townie to you right now. So out of place it makes you scum in fact.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 12:42 GMT

#2286

Did you read his really good analysis that got town to lynch fuba? You think that's some elaborate scum-construction?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 12:58 GMT

#2289

I think I've speculated enough on that type of shizzle.

Basically I don't think you're thinking like a townie. There exists the possibility that you're just right about stuff and I'm wrong, but I don't think that's it.

Which is why I, at least, need to see a case from you that's not on WoS.

By the way, it's not the fact that gumshoe got us to lynch scum (ok, it is that) but it's the way he wrote about it and argued for it. If it's a scumplay it's really brilliant and just seems so god-damn unlikely. I'd have hoped you would think the same too.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 13:48 GMT

#2295

On July 06 2013 22:47 JarJarDrinks wrote:

Show nested quote +

Like Who do you think is scum right now stutters? Even if you think I am, there has to be another person in the game that's scum right? So wouldn't Fuba have had that persons role to claim?

Stutters is right, why don't *you* tell *us* who's scum instead?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 14:03 GMT

#2300

I don't think you're scum because claims, I think you're scum because I don't believe your WoS read, I don't get why a townie would be asking why gumshoe looks townie, I don't like how you passively agreed with rayn's theory to retract it weakly later, I don't like how you went from pushing fuba to just dropping it for WoS.

If you're town and you can't find scum or at least demonstrate a townie thought process (which is primarily where I think you've fell down, repeatedly) then we're gonna lose today.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 14:04 GMT

#2301

Stutters, he's talking about day 1, not day 2

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 16:52 GMT

#2313

who gives a flying fuck if fuba had a few votes in a short space of time?

He *didn't* get lynched and he *didn't* have to fakeclaim, which is both the goal of a mafia player and a townie. Your whole argument rests on "well he had a claim, why didn't he use it" - well, he didn't have to use it in the end. End of conversation.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 16:53 GMT

#2315

Your entire argument rests on the idea that fuba would necessarily have fakeclaimed to save himself when he didn't need to.

It's ludicrous.

Move on.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 20:00 GMT

#2325

On July 07 2013 02:15 gumshoe wrote:
Btw WOS, you never answered my question.

Show nested quote +

Also Jar Jar. May I please have a case on why Solstice is scum?

stop picking his target for him.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

July 06 2013 21:14 GMT

#2330

On July 07 2013 05:10 gumshoe wrote:

Show nested quote +

I didn't, he did day 1. I'm just curios why he abandoned his number 2 read. Especially when solstice would work well with most of his reads.

The point is, you're saying "make a case on s0lstice". No, he should make his case on whoever he pleases. Stop predicting what he should or shouldn't do, and just let him do it.