Smurf Mini Mafia - Page 61

On June 14 2013 19:54 Hurndall3 wrote:
honestly i just haven't had time to play this game properly. I hope to make a case against pt in the next days so please consider that with an open mind.

On June 14 2013 19:54 Hurndall3 wrote:
honestly i just haven't had time to play this game properly. I hope to make a case against pt in the next days so please consider that with an open mind.

On June 14 2013 20:24 Hurndall3 wrote:
read my brief stint of tryhard preceding the HW lynch. Yes I was totally wrong about everything, but I would not tryhard like that as scum.

On May 31 2013 21:54 Baker1986 wrote:


You do realize you're awful at the "I'm a dick and I post oneliners" attitude?

On May 31 2013 22:01 Baker1986 wrote:


I'm just pointing it out. The entire point of playing like you're playing is to antagonize someone to make him mad until he just snaps and does something stupid, revealing his alignment.

You're just being useless.

also, fuck Flood Control.

On June 14 2013 21:12 Hurndall3 wrote:
but this is just how I play a LOT of the time.

On June 14 2013 21:17 Hurndall3 wrote:
why are you doing that?? you really want to bet this game on the fact that I am NOT a lazy player

On June 03 2013 16:45 PTroughton2 wrote:
McCoy has been town cheiftan so far and Baker seems to be hinting he's rather comfortable with sheeping McCoy. Looking into Baker as well, not sure how comfortable I am with him being a sheep but at least it's McCoy who is the shepherd.
.

On June 04 2013 04:49 PTroughton2 wrote:
2) The reason for bringing this up is that presumably McCoy has at least a null or perhaps town-leaning read on Baker at this point. The overt willingness from Baker to sheep McCoy is suspicious to me because he's enabled to sheep McCoy BECAUSE of McCoy's town read on him. If Baker is playing a magnificent early scum game in which he's in the town leadership's good graces, he can a) let his activity drop off as someone in the thread is speaking for him and b) absolve himself of blame for any mislynches. I wrote that post tired after a quick read-through, but that idea developed in my mind as I was catching up for the first time and I wanted to make a note of it so you knew where I was headed. Need to see how Baker has been participating in the mean time. Granted, if I recall correctly he said this very recently, perhaps during the night? I'll have a better-informed read of Baker when I'm finished re-reading.

On June 04 2013 06:09 PTroughton2 wrote:
P4 of the thread, found the original willingness to sheep McCoy (I think it's repeated later in the game as well)

At this stage of the game, it makes little sense to say that you are willing to sheep McCoy. McCoy could have been wrong (thought I doubt it since I share both a town read on him and his suspicions of Eccleston by this point of the game) and giving him another vote by proxy isn't quite scummy but it is... suspect. McCoy is at that point focusing in on Eccleston, and Baker is in a mild manner in the thread where he starts with a not-certain town read on McCoy to McCoy is the smartest dude in the thread. This is all centered around the events of discussing Eccleston, particularly this post occurs that gives Baker a 100% town read on McCoy:

It seems that Baker comes to the conclusion that the chainsaw defense of Ecc by DrT means both of them are probably scum. If Ecc flips mafia, there's no way in hell Baker is mafia. No way. He's willing to hand off his vote to his strongest town read and calls out a rather obvious scum pair in the thread and if he's right, that's just too gutsy for hours into day one.

Baker is town, or he's got brass ones. I take back my suspicions. Or do you disagree that this would make him town? Just too far out for him to be potentially bussing his entire team when he presumably has the ability and time to steer things away so early in the game.

The counter point to that is that Baker WANTS the two to be linked together, since DrT is well on his way to a lynch and not doing much good for himself trying to change that. Therefore by linking up with McCoy he's not at the forefront of a push that will lynch his entire team but potentially at least trading one clearly scummy teammate for a very lynchable theoretical-town-Ecc.

On June 10 2013 11:10 Hurndall3 wrote:


well my first thought is baker looks bad for this

On June 11 2013 19:43 Hurndall3 wrote:
but yeah right now i think it's a pt baker scumteam if i had to pick

On June 14 2013 01:23 Hurndall3 wrote:
because you didn't want to lynch me instead of ecc